A Comparison of the Legacy of Upton Sinclair's The Jungle and Rachel Carson's Silent Spring

A Comparison of the Legacy of Upton Sinclair's The Jungle and Rachel Carson's Silent Spring

Length: 1714 words (4.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

1906 would see the publication of Upton Sinclair's The Jungle, pushing through major reforms of the meatpacking industry and eventually causing the government to take actions to protect the health of its people; almost fifty years later, the publication of Rachel Carson's novel Silent Spring would invoke a similar, but changed response to the threat of DDT. Although both would lead to government legislation creating major changes, the original intentions of the authors themselves differed, as well as their satisfaction of the results. However, both still leave a legacy for today, as legislation still stands that reflects the widespread reform that ensued. Both Silent Spring and The Jungle, would have wide reaching influences, but with different motivations and different goals in mind.
Although Silent Spring and The Jungle would both create similar reforms, their authors would have much different motivations for writing them. Rachel Carson, before publishing Silent Spring, would major in marine zoology at Pennsylvania Women's College, where she would develop her interest in the naturalism and conservation going on at the time (Lear, 23). After graduating, she would take a job at the U.S. Bureau of Fisheries, where she would write about different issues concerning the environment at the time. After writing several books to some success, she would begin work on Silent Spring, as it she would find her naturalist causes to be her impetus. She even later on in her life write to her friends, What I discovered was that everything which meant most to me as a naturalist was being threatened, and that nothing I could do would be more important."(Carson, 17) On the contrary, however, Sinclair would not find his motivation...


... middle of paper ...


.... Radical Innocent: Upton Sinclair. Boston. Random House, 2006.

Carson, Rachel. Always, Rachel: The Letters of Rachel Carson and Dorothy Freeman 1952-1964 An Intimate Portrait of a Remarkable Friendship. New York. Beacon Press, 1995

Carson, Rachel. Silent Spring. New York. Houghton Mifflin, 1964.

Lear, Linda. Rachel Carson: Witness for Nature, Henry Holt, New York, 1997, Owl Books paperback 1998

Murphy,Priscilla Coit. What a Book Can Do: The Publication and Reception of Silent Spring, Amherst. University of Massachusetts Press. 2005

Reed, Lawrence W. "Of Meat and Myth," The Freeman. November 1994

Sinclair, Upton Jr. The Jungle. Mass Market Paperback. New York. Reprinted 2004, 1906.

Young, James Harvey, "The Pig That Fell into the Privy: Upton Sinclair's The Jungle and Meat Inspection Amendments of 1906," Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 1985.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Legacy of Rachel Carson Essay

- Rachel Carson has forever changed the very dynamic of the United States. Her books brought environmental issue to the forefront of public concern. She advocated fiercely and passionately for a change in the government’s policy with the environment. Her work and tireless effort centered on the growing problem of insecticides and pesticides in the general public, namely DDT. The chemical itself was extremely prevalent in the domestic markets but also a popular insecticide used during WWII. In one of life’s great ironies, the creator of DDT, Paul Muller, received the Nobel Prize in Medicine 1948....   [tags: Biographical, Pesticide Regulation, Silent Spring]

Strong Essays
1262 words (3.6 pages)

Silent Spring By Rachel Carson Essay

- ... DDT was far more effective than most other pesticides, killing hundreds of different kinds of insects rather than just a few varieties (The Story of Silent Spring 4). The chemical’s molecular structure was almost entirely resistant to water, adding to its merits (Lytle 136). Because of its effectiveness, the chemical became nearly omnipresent worldwide, and production of synthetic pesticides skyrocketed from around 259,000 pounds in 1947 to 637,666,000 pounds in 1960 (Carson 17). However, although DDT helped farmers rid their crops of insects, the pesticide carried terrible consequences (Carson 7)....   [tags: DDT, Pesticide, Rachel Carson, Nature]

Strong Essays
2441 words (7 pages)

Essay about Analysis of Silent Spring by Rachel Carson

- Analysis of Silent Spring by Rachel Carson Silent Spring is a novel written by a woman named Rachel Carson, which was published in 1962. With advance sales of 40 000 copies the book went on to be recognised in 1992 as the most influential book of the last 50 years, and was held in much the same respect and admiration as great works such as Karl Marx's 'Das Capital and Charles Darwin's 'The Origin of Species'. About the book ============== The book takes an in depth look at the hazardous and detrimental consequences of the use of chemical fertilisers and pesticides in not only agriculture, but in other activities particularly leisure....   [tags: Silent Spring Rachel Carson Agriculture Essays]

Strong Essays
1277 words (3.6 pages)

Essay about Analysis of Silent Spring by Rachel Carson

- Analysis of Silent Spring by Rachel Carson Review: This book was focused on the concern of pesticides that industries, along with us as individuals, have been dumping (both knowingly and unknowingly) into water. Carson was concerned that the chemicals which the farmers spread on their fields, and even the chemicals we use in our homes (among others), in the end, might come back around and harm us. The beginning of the book tells a story of a place, that was once so beautiful, turned dead and ugly due to a “strange blight that crept over the area” and destroyed everything....   [tags: Silent Spring Rachel Carson Pollution Essays]

Strong Essays
714 words (2 pages)

Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring and the Beginning of the Environmental Movement in the United States

- Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring and the Beginning of the Environmental Movement in the United States When Rachel Carson's Silent Spring was published in 1962, it generated a storm of controversy over the use of chemical pesticides. Miss Carson's intent in writing Silent Spring was to warn the public of the dangers associated with pesticide use. Throughout her book are numerous case studies documenting the harmful effects that chemical pesticides have had on the environment. Along with these facts, she explains how in many instances the pesticides have done more harm than good in eradicating the pests they were designed to destroy....   [tags: Environment Carson Silent Spring Essays]

Strong Essays
2912 words (8.3 pages)

Essay about The Power of Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring

- The Power of Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring In 1962, Rachel Carson published Silent Spring and was greeted with a roar of protest and approval. After years and years of controversy and skepticism surrounding its argument, Silent Spring was and still is recognized as a perceptive warning of things in progress and things to come. The book set the stage for the first real and effectual environmental movement. In 17 chapters, many of which can stand alone as essays, Carson develops a deceptively simple premise: the use and overuse of synthetic chemicals to control insect pests introduces these chemicals into the air, water, and soil and into the food chain where they poison animals and humans,...   [tags: Silent Spring]

Strong Essays
1472 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on Silent Spring By Rachel Carson

- ... Carson’s concern with the well-being of the environment stems from the events transpiring as cause of The Cold War. With the war came the first military uses of atomic weaponry. This style of warfare undoubtedly had very negative effects on the environment. There was dangerous pollution and irrecoverable contamination. The atomic strikes brought new chemicals into the air that would certainly impact the health and safety of the targeted cities. This rapid assault on the environment was unnatural and completely at the hands of mankind....   [tags: Nuclear weapon, World War II, Cold War]

Strong Essays
756 words (2.2 pages)

Silent Spring By Rachel Carson Essay examples

- ... This article predicted that doomsday would occur with the century and certainly with the lifetimes of those who were alive at the time. It stated that if society continued with their trends, there would be a “disruption of life support systems” (Sale 1993). Subsequently, the so-called Doomsday agenda was pushed and as a result, numerous books focusing on this subject were published. Although they contained charts and data, they were not necessarily true and in most cases ignored scientific facts....   [tags: Environmentalism, Environmental movement]

Strong Essays
1523 words (4.4 pages)

Rachel Carson's Silent Spring Essay

- Research Paper: Silent Spring Rachel Carson, born during the industrial boom in a small town called Springdale. There, a glue factory very near to her home exposed Carson, at a young age, to some of the effects chemicals can have on a small town. As Carson grew so did her ambitions to learn more about the environment. This determination won her a scholarship to Pennsylvania College for Women and later she furthered her education at Johns Hopkins University, studying Marine Biology. She was a woman always supportive to her family, so when financial trouble hit home, Carson left school to aid....   [tags: health detrimental environmental issues]

Strong Essays
1604 words (4.6 pages)

Rachel Carson Essay

- One of the prime ecologists in the world, best known for her book Silent Spring, was Rachel Carson. Rachel Carson’s book caused controversy and a scare for the progression of the environmental movement. “(Silent Spring) spells out in memorable detail through out the book the effects of synthetic insecticides and herbicides on water, soil, plants, wildlife, fish and human beings. But in the book’s final chapter she suggests alternative courses of action for mankind —- a way out of this march toward death.” (Holmes, Pg....   [tags: Biography, Silent Spring]

Free Essays
975 words (2.8 pages)