A Comparison of Quebec to the Rest of Canada Essay

A Comparison of Quebec to the Rest of Canada Essay

Length: 1364 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Quebec’s social identity and defining characteristics contradict and conflict with those of rest of Canada. Since the genesis of our country, the political, social disagreements, and tensions between Quebec and the rest of Canada have been unavoidable. Utilizing Hiller’s key contradictions in the analysis of a Canadian society, we will compare and contrast the nature of the societal identity in Quebec compared to that of rest of Canada, emphasising on the major differences and tensions between the province and the rest of the country.

Although Quebec is in Canada, a majority of Quebecers do not identify with the national identity of Canada. Both societies create a sense of identity as well as nationalism (Hiller, 295). Hiller mentions two approaches to assessing Canadian identity; the unitary approach and the segmentalist approach (Hiller, 277). The unitary approach suggests that society consists of people who regardless of their ethnic back ground, identify as belonging to the national society, while the segmentalist approach concentrates on groups and communities that share racial, linguistic, occupational, or cultural similarities (Hiller, 28). While most Anglophones are more unitary or pan-Canadian, Quebec heavily identifies with the segmentalist approach. This dissimilarity of identity perspective may be problematic for the country, at the same time however, it can also be viewed as a struggle where contradictory parties find a way to compromise and reshape Canadian society together (Hiller, 277). Canada’s former Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau made it his objective to unite Quebec with the rest of Canada. In 1969 Trudeau’s government implemented Bill C-120, otherwise known as the Official Language act, which made French an...


... middle of paper ...


... Analysis (5th ed.), Toronto: Pearson Prentice-Hall.
Bélanger, Claude. "The Official Languages Act of Canada - Studies on the Canadian Constitution and Canadian Federalism - Quebec History." .Marianopolis College, Nov. 2005. Web. 02 Apr. 2014.
CBC-Digital. "CBC Digital Archives - Separation Anxiety: The 1995 Quebec Referendum - Separation Anxiety: The 1995 Quebec Referendum." CBCnews. CBC/Radio Canada, 06 Mar. 2014. Web. 02 Apr. 2014
Dougherty, Kevin. "Marois Ready to Use Notwithstanding Clause to Protect Charter." www.montrealgazette.com. Montreal Gazette. 31 Mar. 2014. Web. 02 Apr. 2014.
Polese, Mario. "Regional Economics." The Canadian Encyclopedia. HISTORICA FOUNDATION, 02 July 2006. Web. 13 Mar. 2014.
Tencer, Daniel. "Income Inequality: Canada Does Surprisingly Little To Reduce Wage Gap. “The Huffington Post. The Huffington Post, Winter 2013. Web. 02 Apr. 2014.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Four Political Parties Of Canada Essay

- The Four Political Parties of Canada      In a country as vast and as culturally diverse as Canada, many different political opinions can be found stretched across the country. From the affluent neighbourhoods of West Vancouver to the small fishing towns located on the east coast of Newfoundland, political opinions and affiliations range from the left wing to the right wing. To represent these varying political views, Canada has four official national political parties to choose from: the Liberals (who are currently in power), the Progressive Conservatives, the New Democrats, and the Reform Party....   [tags: Canadian Politics Political Government Essays]

Strong Essays
4270 words (12.2 pages)

Essay about Conscription in World War Two

- The act of applying conscription during the First and Second World Wars have nearly torn Canada apart. The conscription crisis of 1917 was a treacherous event that occurred during the First World War. During this time the relations between Quebec and the rest of Canada were in an all time low in our Canadian history. The Québécois thought conscription was merely unnecessary no matter what circumstance; while all other Canadians did essentially want conscription occur. The contrast was inevitably high on the issue of conscription between the Québécois and the rest of Canada thus creating a solution when conscription was indeed needed was impossible....   [tags: Canada History]

Strong Essays
1652 words (4.7 pages)

The Independence Of Quebec And Quebec Essay

- Other Quebec nationalists looking to instigate a separate nation of Quebec instead chose to take a more radical approach to the cultural debate. One famous group was the Front de Liberation du Quebec, also known as the FLQ . The FLQ first emerged in 1970, and quickly entered the national spotlight with a series of terrorist attacks in hopes of rallying the people of Quebec. Instead, their actions created a state of terror and panic with the people of Quebec and English Canada instead viewing them as a threat....   [tags: Canada, Quebec, Pierre Trudeau, October Crisis]

Strong Essays
1016 words (2.9 pages)

Foucault’s Biopolitics and Agamben’s State of Exception Essay

- The Canadian identity has changed through the years from the makeup of ethnicities, culture and values but all these changes are kept within a normative standard. The state has a stake in minimising conflict and diversity at the expense of the minority. Political writers theorise on the motive for government actions with the two primary theories being Foucault’s “biopolitics” and Agamben’s “state of exception”. Biopolitics stresses the importance of biology and how the government seeks to protect life rather than condemn, creating an effective and optimised population for capitalism....   [tags: Canadian politics, Canada]

Strong Essays
2800 words (8 pages)

Essay about Quebec 's Journey Towards Nationalism

- Introduction In general, nationalism can be defined as a sentiment based on common cultural characteristics that binds a population and often produces a policy of national independence or separatism (Dictionary.com, 2012). The nationalist movement in Quebec has been known to be one of the most powerful national movements in the developed West (Meadwell, 1993). Quebec is an ideal example of a sub-state nation that has claimed the right to sovereignty from a federal state. The reason for this is that provinces within the Canadian federal state have particular exclusive constitutional powers, which includes the legislation of social programs....   [tags: Quebec, Canada, French Canadian]

Strong Essays
1090 words (3.1 pages)

Canadian Domain As A Canadian Province Of Quebec Essay

- Introduction Quebec is the largest Canadian province, with the second largest population and economy after that of Ontario. Historically, the province of Quebec presents a unique frontier for the analysis of Anglo-French relations. It is important to note that Canadian domain as a whole was principally an extension of France until the British forces led by Jeremy Amherst took hold o Montreal in 1760. The 1763 signing of the Treaty o Paris essentially sealed this acquisition of Canada by the Great Britain....   [tags: Quebec, Canada, Constitution Act, 1867]

Strong Essays
1354 words (3.9 pages)

Essay about Why Quebec Has A Strong Argument

- The PQ victory is one to fear. Primarily it is important to recall that Quebec has never seen independence. The province of Quebec started off as a French colony and has been ruled since the Treaty of Paris in 1763. Furthermore, the Francophone population is at risk. There are no special policies to protect them from disappearing as majority of political life and economic enterprise is English-speaking and at a decline in Quebec. As a well-informed civil servant in the Prime Minister’s Office it is clear that action must be taken to prevent detachment of Quebec from the Canadian landscape....   [tags: Canada, Quebec, French Canadian, French people]

Strong Essays
1221 words (3.5 pages)

Canada: The Quiet Revolution in Quebec Essay

- Canada: The Quiet Revolution in Quebec The English-French relations have not always been easy. Each is always arguing and accusing the other of wrong doings. All this hatred and differences started in the past, and this Quiet revolution, right after a new Liberal government led by Jean Lesage came in 1960. Thus was the beginning of the Quiet Revolution. Lesage had an excellent team of cabinet ministers which included Rene Levesque. The Liberals promised to do two things during the Quiet Revolution; one was to improve economic and social standards for the people of Quebec, and the other was to win greater respect and recognition for all the French people of Canada....   [tags: Canadian Canada History]

Free Essays
1066 words (3 pages)

Quebec Separatism Essay

- Canada is known by outsiders to be a very peaceful country. But if you ask any Canadian they well tell you that is unfortunately not the case. For there is a large ongoing conflict between Canadians. The conflict is between the French and the English, or more specifically between Quebec and the rest of Canada. As a result of this conflict, along with some wrongdoing and propaganda. Quebec has considered and has gone as far to hold referendums over Separatism (Surette,2014). Separatism is that the province of Quebec separates from the rest of Canada to form its own country....   [tags: Quebec Separatism]

Strong Essays
1400 words (4 pages)

Quebec Essay

- The reaction to a majority vote in Quebec and their subsequent succession. Quebec has struggled with a need to be maitres chez nous “masters of their own house” (Young, 1998). Many attempts at resolving Quebec's issues has resulted in tensions from both sides. Because Quebec has a strong national identity, and do not define themselves as strictly Canadian, Quebec is seen as difficult, unyielding and discontented. Quebec's separation perhaps is inedible and the future of Canada questionable. Canada without Quebec will bring about many complications and whether there is a rest of Canada (ROC) after Quebec a major challenge....   [tags: Quebec Profound Nationalism, Sovereignty]

Strong Essays
2106 words (6 pages)