The Sad Truth

863 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Patient autonomy case

Imagine you or one of your family members being in a persistent vegetative state, a conduction in which a medical patient is completely unresponsive to physical and psychological stimuli and shows no sign of high brain function, being kept alive only by medical intervention. That would be more than difficult to imagine, but for the Cruzan’s family it was a reality. Nancy Cruzan was in a car accident, which resulted in massive injuries. Nancy was in an unconscious state and very unresponsive in daily activities. She was in a vegetable state with an implanted feeding tube in her stomach. As years passed by the family decided they wanted the feeding tube to be removed in order for Nancy to get the peace she needed. The Supreme Court didn’t quite agree with the family’s decision of removal of the feeding tube. The Supreme Court seized the family’s upright decision to remove the feeding tube from Nancy Cruzan because her family knows what is better for her rather than someone who knows almost nothing about her.
On January 11, 1983, Nancy Cruzan was in an automobile accident. Her car flipped while driving down Elm Road in Jasper County, Missouri. Nancy was found lying in a snow ditch. She was oxygen deprived for around 12 minutes. It only half of the time she suffered from oxygen deprivation to cause permanent damage to the brain. Nancy was then taken to the hospital and said to be in Persistent Vegetative State because there was so much brain damage due to the lack of oxygen she had. Her entire body functioned only on internal controls, which maintains heartbeat, reflex activity of muscles and nerves for low-level conditional responses body temperature, as well as the digestive tract. “Although PVS is very serious, Nancy showed some...

... middle of paper ...

...anything about her other than the accident and her current conditions. Nancy was truly helpless there is nothing one could do to help her she could only lay there. The state argument about life itself mattering not the quality was shameful. But in reality if you really think about it is she living and life. She can’t speak, nor do anything a living person can, but breath. Just because she is breathing doesn’t mean she is “living”. The family should have been the ones who decide what is best for Nancy not the court especially using those arguments.
The Cruzan family had suffer a great loss when Nancy got into the car accident, and suffered a greater one by not letting her get the peace one would always hope for. At last she did pass away peacefully by getting her feeding tube removed, but it shouldn’t have taken so long for one to decide if it was right and wrong.

Show More
Related

  • Terri Schiavo Interview

    1277 Words  | 3 Pages

    In February of 1990 a woman named Terri Schiavo collapsed at home suffering cardiac arrest in her home in St. Petersburg, Florida. She was resuscitated but had severe brain damage because she had no oxygen going to her brain for several minutes. Terri was severely brain damaged and in a vegetative state but could still breathe and maintain a heart beat on her own. After two and a half months and no signs of improvement, impaired vision, and the inability to move her arms and legs she needed a feeding tube to sustain her life since she seemed to be in a persistent vegetative state. For 2 years doctors attempted speech and physical therapy with no success. In 1998 Schiavos husband claimed she would not want to live in that quality of life without a prospect of recovery so he tried several times over the course of many years to pull the feeding tube so she could pass. Bob and Mary Schindler challenged and fought for a

    Read More

  • Terri Schiavo Case Summary

    636 Words  | 2 Pages

    A case such as this one was the first of its kind, so the outcome of the trials was very important for setting a precedent in similar cases in the future. This is a Landmark Case for long-term comatose patients without a mandate. From then on, there would be no more legal issues when facing this type of situation. It is also important to note that American conservative groups used this case to promote their disapproval of Mr. Schiavo’s position, in a failed attempt to end the Death with Dignity Act.

    Read More

  • Betancourt v Trinitas and the Issue of Futility in Modern Medical Practice

    725 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...ourt to decide whether treatment should be removed from a comatose patient but rather to establish criteria that respect the right to self-determination and protect incapacitated patients.” After this decision was made that hospital started an appeal Rueben Betancourt died during the process.

    Read More

  • Please Let Me Die Case Study

    1244 Words  | 3 Pages

    In this paper, I will be arguing a that in the Please Let Me Die case, the patient did not give informed consent to rejecting treatment due to a variety of factors. In summary, the patient was a 25-year-old male named Dax Cowart who suffered severe burns over 65% of his body after a propane gas explosion. He had several fingers amputated and his right eye removed after he was stabilized. He was discharged with minimal use of his hands, totally blind, and needed assistance with daily activities. He asked that treatment be discontinued throughout his hospital stay and rehabilitation, but his request was denied because his physicians deemed him not competent. I believe he was not competent because of his injuries; as is said about many patients

    Read More

  • Terri Schiavo's Case: The Quality Of Life

    1805 Words  | 4 Pages

    There was a woman named Terri Schiavo who was declared in a permanent vegetative condition by doctors for 15 years because of severe brain damage she received. Her husband, who was her legal guardian, claimed she voiced her opinion that she never desired to be kept alive on life support if anything ever happened to her. In order to keep Terri alive she was required to be nourished by force feeding her through a feeding tube, which her parents were doing to keep her alive in a vegetable condition. Her parents desired to prolong her life and keep them from having to suffer losing her by continuing to do this so the husband was not hampered with taking care of her. Terri’s parents tried to use religion as a way of keeping their daughter alive

    Read More

  • Justine Moritz in Frankenstein

    358 Words  | 1 Pages

    As the defense has so diligently pointed out, it is indeed a sad day in the history of our judicial system when an innocent woman is sent to her death for a crime that she did not commit. I, for one, am not planning on having that momentous occasion take place today, and this is for one simple reason: Justine is guilty. While the defense has done nothing but parade Justine’s friends in front of you saying how much of a “nice person” she is, I, the prosecution, have presented you with cold, hard facts, all of which point to the guilt of the defendant.

    Read More

  • Mary Johnson Case Study

    553 Words  | 2 Pages

    Imagine getting the news that someone had killed your child. You would probably be mad, upset, and even depressed. You would probably blame anyone who witnessed it, and you would probably want nothing to do with your child’s killer. Mary Johnson was shocked to get the news that her son had been shot and killed after an argument at a party. She was devastated, but she didn’t let that get the best of her. She stayed strong.

    Read More

  • Ventalation Case Summary

    2502 Words  | 6 Pages

    This case is considering whether or not it is ethical to take a brain dead woman that is pregnant off of ventalation. This specific case involves a resident of Texas named Amanda. Amanda was thirty years old. Amanda was married, was mother of an 18-month old child, and worked in the healthcare industry. One day, Amanda collapsed and the doctors then later determined she had a massive pulmonary embolism. She was then declared brain dead after being taken to the hospital. Brain death is the irreversible cessation of all the functions of the entire brain, including the brain stem (Baumrucker 672).

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Movie Wit

    833 Words  | 2 Pages

    ... research experiment and not like a patient or with the decency she deserved. Some of the things that the doctors did to Vivian were so unethical and so inhumane that it makes one cringe just thinking about it. Fortunately for Vivian, Susie was the light at the end of the tunnel. She provided care that was compassionate, kind and professional. One hopes that in the future I can embody the qualities that Susie had and display them to my patients on a daily basis. In nursing school we are so focused on knowing the science behind everything or getting our medication out in time that we forget why we became nurses in the first place. We became nurses so we could care for others that could not care for themselves. Susie was the true definition of a nurse and provided patient centered compassionate care to Vivian allowing her to die in a dignified and meaningful way.

    Read More

  • History of Euthanasia in America

    899 Words  | 2 Pages

    1976- The New Jersey Supreme Court rules that the parents of Karen Ann Quinlan, who has been in a tranquilizer-and-alcohol-induced coma for a year, can remove her respirator. She dies nine years later.

    Read More

  • Therapeutic Hypothermia

    1806 Words  | 4 Pages

    According the statistics from the American Heart Association (2012), when electrical impulses to the heart suddenly become uncoordinated, causing the immediate cessation of the heart to function, this is considered a cardiac arrest. Cardiac arrest that occurs outside of the hospital has an incidence of 359,400 with a survival rate of 9.5 % (American Heart Association (AHA), 2012). In absence circulation, neurological injury occurs from the lack of oxygen delivered to the brain (Deckard & Ebright, 2011). This disruption of oxygen can cause a cascade of events that include hypoxia, cellular death, the activation of the inflammatory response, and cerebral edema. The continuation

    Read More

  • Euthanasia and Futile Care

    1631 Words  | 4 Pages

    Imagine visiting your 85-year-old mother in the hospital after she has a debilitating stroke. You find out that, in order to survive, she requires a feeding tube and antibiotics to fight an infection. She once told you that no matter what happened, she wants to live. But the doctor refuses further life-sustaining treatment. When you ask why, you are told, in effect, "The time has come for your mother to die. All we will provide is comfort care."

    Read More

  • Ethical Theory Of Autonomy In Nursing

    1265 Words  | 3 Pages

    Once a person has freely made his choice, health care providers are required to respect the patient’s decision as part of the patient’s autonomy. A patient’s family might demand doctors to keep a patient alive living off of either machines or pain medication, even after doctors established such methods would not be effective anymore. Even though, the patient’s family knows that the treatment is no longer achievable, they may still expect doctors to do everything under the patient’s autonomy. However, the true reason is that the family is not ready to let go of a loved one. Therefore, they are willing to put the patient through pointless pain and suffering at the end of his or her life. In such cases, it would be easy for a doctor to obey the family’s request, but it would not be the right thing to do for the patient. Doctors must educate and instruct patients and their families about patient autonomy, and the principle of “do no harm” in

    Read More

  • Voiceless Victims Research Paper

    2072 Words  | 5 Pages

    Every parent dreams of walks in the park on a perfect sunny day with their child, hearing their first words, taking their first steps, and watching them grow up and live to their full potential. No parent has ever wanted to sit in a dark hospital, clinging onto their baby’s tiny cold hand, and have the only hope they can hold onto taken away from them in a flash. A few weeks ago, I heard a story that caught my attention about a young two-year-old boy who was forcibly taken off life support against his parents’ wishes. After extensive research, it has become evident that this is not the first time this has happened. This has aroused my curiosity as to why a court would deny someone the right of life support if there was still a possibility of survival. As of September 2017, the High Court of the UK ruled that a judge’s approval is no longer needed before removing somebody from life support. In regards to this decision, hospitals should not remove someone from the aid of life support when the family disagrees without first taking it to court, and review to see if there are any possibilities of hope.

    Read More

  • Case Brief Schindler V Schiavo

    548 Words  | 2 Pages

    Mr. Schiavo petitioned the guardianship court to determine if his wife should be removed from life sustaining treatment. The court ordered that his wife’s feeding tube should be removed. His wife’s parents, Mr. and Mrs. Schindler immediately sought an injunction to replace the feeding tube until their appeal could be heard. Mr. and Mrs. Schindler claimed to have new evidence that Mr. Schiavo lied to the court about knowing his wife’s wishes under these circumstances. Mr. and Mrs. Schindler are also suing for guardianship rights over their daughter so that they can make future medical decisions on her behalf (Fla. App. 2001).

    Read More

More about The Sad Truth

Open Document