Essay on Reasoning according to Saint Thomas Aquinas

Essay on Reasoning according to Saint Thomas Aquinas

Length: 882 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

1) Aquinas does not require that each individual person have good reasons for what he or she believes. He explains that there is the human reason (God is triune) and natural reason (God exists) which considers some truth of God. He discusses limitations to human intellect. He explains that the truth is open to reasoning. He reasons that humans have better knowledge of God when they cannot understand. He explains that many people are not fitted to reach the highest level of knowledge, which is understanding God. When truths are explained they are mixed in with false statements. Aquinas reasoning does make sense, it is vague and confusing to grasp, but the underlying components are logical. It is a good reason, because he allows for the individual to decide what he or she wants to believe and believes as their own.
2) According to Aquinas there are certain “truths of faith” that we should accept even though we are unable, by human reason, to see that they are true. He states that the divine Wisdom knows everything, and it is designed to reveal to people its teachings. He explains that the truths of reason cannot be opposed to the Divine truth, they cannot be thought of as false, and truths by faith are not allowed to be thought of as false. He states that, “…only the false is opposed to the true…” This reasoning was confusing to me, the statement makes sense, but just the explanation is hard to follow.
3) Fideism is taking a neutral stance about religious truth claims, putting all your commitments aside and turning towards the neutral side. Evans’ objections to fideism are whether or not neutral stance is desirable, because once someone becomes neutral will they be even able to understand religion. Evans explains how we cannot ...


... middle of paper ...


...ut we should be able to hear others out and maybe come to common ground, but the process will deepen faith.
7) Of the two I preferred Evans views, they were easily read and vast evidence was given. Evans position made the most sense to me. I agree that every individual has their own beliefs, but should consider others views as well. Aquinas’ views and reasoning were hard to follow and vague.
8) I agree that religious truths and natural truths are both true, but I disagree that they have nothing to do with each other. And that even though they operate of different planes of human consciousness, I think that they influence each other vastly. All our thoughts come from somewhere and are influenced by various factors, so I think that religious and natural truths influence each other is different ways, and help us both explain what we stand for.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay A Brief Analysis of Saint Thomas Aquinas

- ... “Whatever is moved is moved by something else. Potentiality is only moved by actuality” (Archie). There is an excellent example of this “an actual oak tree is what produces the potentiality of an acorn” (Archie). There must be a first mover, in order for there to be motions. He believes by taking away the actual is like taking away the potential, as well; it both goes hand in hand. A good example of this would be: “the reason a student has the potential to be awake is that he had (actual) toast for breakfast....   [tags: philosophy and religion]

Better Essays
1278 words (3.7 pages)

Saint Thomas More : Principles With Utopia Essay

- ... No improvement in public life can occur without the elimination of social illness at its deepest level. This is not mere fancy, Raphael reminds his friend; the good life can be realized, if it can be visualized. More visualize the Utopia as given by the monastery example. It addresses many social ills that were plaguing Europe at the time. More uses the monastery as a basis for a solution to these ills and I have listed The elimination of private property (because monasteries were open to visitors and travelers), Moderated Pleasure (illustrated by activities with in the monastery that suggest the old saying everything is good in moderation), The Nature of Labor and family structure as a...   [tags: Utopia, Thomas More, Utopia, Politics]

Better Essays
1278 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about Reasoning According to Kant

- Reasoning According to Kant Kant believes that, reason thinks of all cognition as belonging to a unified and organized system. Reason is our faculty of making inferences and of identifying the grounds behind every truth. It allows us to move from the particular and contingent to the global and universal. Each cause, and each cause's cause, and each additional ascending cause must itself have a cause. Reason generates this hierarchy that combines to provide the mind with a conception of a whole system of nature....   [tags: Kant Philosophy Reasoning Essays]

Better Essays
725 words (2.1 pages)

The Achievements of Saint Thomas Aquainas Essay

- Saint Thomas Aquinas (1225-1272) is fundamentally an Aristotelian, and for some, one of the greatest philosophers, and one of the best theologians. His theological writings became regulative of the Catholic Church and his commentaries on Aristotle, represents a great cultural resource, which are now receiving a greater recognition. As a very catholic man, he tried to prove the existence of God. But How. Thomas Aquinas recognized that there were people who doubted the existence of God. Because to them logic did not allow or explain His existence....   [tags: theology, philosophy, biography]

Better Essays
631 words (1.8 pages)

Saint Thomas Aquinas and the Intellective Soul Essay

- ... The intellect though is able to potentially cognize all bodies. Thus it must be something non- bodily or it would subject to the limitations that are placed upon it by matter. Since the intellect acts on its own, without a body, it must also subsist on its own since things subsist in the same way in which they act. Therefore Aquinas holds that the soul is non bodily and subsistent on its own. Aquinas believes that phantasms are needed for the intellect to produce thought. These phantasms are created by matter....   [tags: phantasms, possess, immaterial]

Free Essays
547 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on Moral Development and Importance of Moral Reasoning

- 1.0 Introduction: Lawrence Kohlberg was the follower of Piaget’s theory of Moral development in principle but wanted to make his own theory by expanding his theory and study on that particular topic. Kohlberg was a very bright student and he served as a professor in the Harvard University. He become popular when he issued his Moral Development Theory by conducting research on that topic at Harvard’s Center for Moral Education. Kohlberg believed that people moral behaviors are based on their moral reasoning, and their moral reasoning changed in accordance to their behaviors and actions when they move from one stage to another....   [tags: Moral Reasoning]

Better Essays
3004 words (8.6 pages)

Moral Reasoning by the Great Philosophers Essay

- "Moral thought, then, seems to behave like all other kinds of thought. Progress through the moral levels and stages is characterized by increasing differentiation and increasing integration, and hence is the same kind of progress that scientific theory represents." Quoted by Mr. Kohlberg himself. Kohlberg developed a set of stages on what he thought how man develops morally. Lawrence Kohlberg's reasoning for the stages of moral development stemmed from Swiss psychologist Jean Piaget; who was one of the first to study systematically moral reasoning in children....   [tags: reasoning, moral, code, development, ]

Better Essays
1380 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on St. Thomas Aquinas 's Faith And Reasoning

- 1. St. Thomas Aquinas is known for his faith and reasoning. St. Thomas Aquinas was declared a saint in 1323, but died in 1274. During this same time period, religion was still a prominent concept. The Crusades were happening at this time, and the push for Christianity was being enforced everywhere. St. Thomas Aquinas was a Catholic Priest and many of this teachings and concepts are still taught within the Church. Catholic theology teaches that the World belongs to man in Genesis 1:28 it says, “Be fruitful and multiply, and fill the earth, and subdue it; and rule over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the sky, and over every living thing that moves on the earth”....   [tags: Human, Agriculture, Sustainable agriculture]

Better Essays
1556 words (4.4 pages)

An Analysis of Wright’s Poem Saint Judas Essay

- An Analysis of Wright’s Poem Saint Judas       Upon reading the poem "Saint Judas" by James Wright, the reader quickly realizes that the poem deals with Judas Iscariot, one of Jesus' twelve apostles.  The author describes Judas as "going out to kill himself,"(line 1) when he sees a man being beaten by "a pack of hoodlums"(2).  Judas quickly runs to help the man, forgetting "how [his] day began"(4).  He leaves his rope behind and, ignoring the soldiers around him, runs to help.  Finally, he remembers the circumstances that surround his suicidal intentions and realizes that he is "banished from heaven"(9) and "without hope"(13)  He runs to the man anyway and holds him "for nothing in [his]...   [tags: Saint Judas]

Better Essays
740 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about Saint Thomas Aquinas

- Saint Thomas Aquinas I chose to write about Saint Thomas Aquinas because I have heard of his life and found it interesting. There was also a large pool of knowledge to research from, about Saint Thomas Aquinas. I also knew he is called Doctor of the church and I wanted to learn more about that. I was interested in Saint Thomas Aquinas because he was misunderstood by his peers and was also called "the Dumb Ox". I wanted to understand how someone can be so misunderstood stood and be a brilliant philosopher....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1602 words (4.6 pages)