Punishment should be Commesurate with the Seriousness of the Offence Essay examples

Punishment should be Commesurate with the Seriousness of the Offence Essay examples

Length: 1147 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

This essay will critically evaluate the accuracy of the statement "punishment should be commensurate with the seriousness of the offence". Account will be made of the respective aggravating and mitigating circumstances that will have an effect on the sanctions that are available to impose on offenders. Consideration will also be given to the circumstances of the offender and to the effect that the crime has had on the victim. In theory by taking all the facts attributable to the offence into account it will be possible to ensure that any sanctions that are imposed upon offenders are proportionate to the offence that has been committed. Offenders deserve to suffer as a consequence of any crime that they have committed but the punishment should be justifiable. Only those who have offended deserve to be punished. Punishment should be neither too severe or too lenient. The purpose of the punishment is also a factor that should be taken into consideration when sentencing offenders.

The are five reasons for sentencing which are contained in section 142(1) Criminal Justice Act 2003. The courts are required to have regard to the purposes of sentencing. The purposes of sentencing are to punish the offender (retribution). Deter the offender from reoffending (deterrence). Reform and rehabilitate the offender (rehabilitation). Address the harm suffered by the victim (reparation, restoration, compensation). The protection of the public (incapacitation). The principal of retribution endeavours to ensure that the offender suffers an equivalent level of harm as has been suffered by the victim of the offence. The theory of deterrence aims to prevent offenders from repeating the crime that they have been convicted of. Sanctions wit...

... middle of paper ...

...e and proportionate to the seriousness of the offence that has been committed. That each case should be judged on the individual aggravating and mitigating factors associated with the offence and on the other individual details of the offence. The circumstances of the offender and the harm caused to the victim of the offence or to the community should have an impact on the severity of the punishment that the offender will receive. It is therefore accurate to say that punishment should be commensurate with the seriousness of the crime. However, if the purpose of the punishment is that of deterrence the offender may receive a punishment that is much harsher than expected.

Works Cited

Bagaric, M. (2002) Punishment and Sentecing: A rational Approach, London, Cavendish.
Sentencing Avisory Panel (2002) Domestic Burgalry : The Panels Advise to the Court of Appeal.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Purpose of Punishment in a Modern Society Essay

- Punishment has been in existence since the early colonial period and has continued throughout history as a method used to deter criminals from committing criminal acts. Philosophers believe that punishment is a necessity in today’s modern society as it is a worldwide response to crime and violence. Friedrich Nietzche’s book “Punishment and Rehabilitation” reiterates that “punishment makes us into who we are; it creates in us a sense of responsibility and the ability to take and release our social obligations” (Blue, Naden, 2001)....   [tags: Punishment and Rehabilitation]

Strong Essays
2222 words (6.3 pages)

Essay on Should Teens Be Tried As Adults For Serious Crimes?

- There have always been people who commit crimes, which is the reason why we set up laws. If a criminal breaks a law and is caught, their sentence in jail or prison would be determined by the seriousness of the crime. Some crimes are more serious than others. Petty crimes such as stealing from the store or loitering do not deserve such a heavy sentence, but criminals who commit serious crimes such as rape and homicide deserve a much heavier sentence, whether it is an adult or an adolescent. Some argue that teens should be given a lighter sentence for the serious crimes they commit because they did not know any better while the family of the victim is suffering greatly....   [tags: Crime, Prison, Capital punishment]

Strong Essays
1086 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Purpose of Punishment Approaches

- Feinburg (1994, cited in: Easton, 2012: 4) says that punishment is “a symbolic way of getting back at the criminal, of expressing a kind of vindictive resentment”. When punishing an offender there are two key principles that determine the kind of punishment. These are the Retributivism response and the Reductivist response. The first principle, Retributivism, focuses on punishing the offence using 'denunciation' where they denounce the crime that has been committed so society knows they have done wrong, and it also uses 'just deserts' where the equity 'eye for an eye' is the main idea....   [tags: Retributivism, Reductivism]

Free Essays
628 words (1.8 pages)

Restorative Justice Gaining Support in South Africa Essay

- 1 Introduction Punishment is central to any legal proceeding where the accused is found guilty. It falls directly under criminal law and is determined by punishment theories. Whether South Africa is moving towards restorative justice approaches influences many aspects: it allows protection of society and results in more crime-free life for the offender. Consequently, it gives offenders the chance to learn from their experiences, gain insight into their behaviour and allows victims to handle their injustice....   [tags: punishment theories]

Strong Essays
1239 words (3.5 pages)

Is Restorative Justice Gaing Support in South Africa? Essay

- Introduction Punishment, central to any legal proceeding where the accused is found guilty, directly falls under criminal law and is determined by punishment theories. Whether South Africa is moving towards restorative justice approaches influences many aspects: it allows the protection of society, results in more of a crime-free life for the offender and it gives offenders the chance to learn from their experience, and gain insight into their behaviour and allows victims to handle their injustice....   [tags: punishment theories, criminal law]

Strong Essays
1515 words (4.3 pages)

Retribution: Impractical to Implement Essay

- In this paper, I will be arguing that retributivism is impractical to implement as a theory of punishment based on the judgments of desert, proportionality and moral responsibility. In order to do so, I will begin by giving a definition of punishment. Punishment can be defined as “the authorized imposition of deprivations—of freedom or privacy or other goods which the person otherwise has a right, or the imposition of special burdens—because the person has been found guilty of some criminal violation…” (Bedau, “Punishment”, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)....   [tags: punishment, judgement, responsibility]

Strong Essays
1721 words (4.9 pages)

Constitutionality of the Death Penalty Essay

- On September 9, 1993 a seventeen year old boy, Christopher Simmons, and his a few of his friends met up to discuss and devise a plan to commit a robbery and maybe even a murder, just for fun. Simmons’ plan was not complicated: find someone to burglarize, tie up the victim and either leave the victim tied to a tree or push them off a bridge. Simmons and his accomplice went through a window that was slightly cracked and proceeded into the bedroom of Mrs. Crook. The two teenagers tried the woman up and loaded her into the back of her minivan....   [tags: capital, punishment, rights, crime, consequences]

Strong Essays
1476 words (4.2 pages)

Schools Should Eliminate the Use of Zero-Tolerance Policies Essay

- The public schools of the United States, despite their proud past, are currently experiencing many difficulties. They seem to be under constant scrutiny and pressure to produce higher academic achievement and at the same time are being criticized by large segments of society. It is no secret that the environment which students experience in the public schools has changed greatly over the past twenty to thirty years, but there are many possible reasons for this; most of these explanations do not place the blame squarely on the schools themselves....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Argument Essays]

Strong Essays
970 words (2.8 pages)

Should Punishment Be Justified? Essay

- Why punish. Is the use of punishment ever Justified. In Punishment: The Supposed Justifications Revisited, Ted Honderich aim to answer these questions. Society needs to establish a well thought-out moral explanation as to why we punish and what we strive to achieve with the use of punishment as it is at the core of our punitive system. Honderich set out to analyze the supposed moral claims that justify the use of punishment and to determine if they are reasonable enough for the intentional infliction of suffering and deprivation....   [tags: Crime, Prison, Criminal justice, Punishment]

Strong Essays
1037 words (3 pages)

Capital Punishment Should Not Be Instituted Essay

- Exemptional Executions Brigg Trendler Period 6 Mrs. Monette 8 December 2014 Since 1967, a total of 1392 executions have occurred in the United States ("Executions by Year"). What a shocking amount. This staggering number creates questioning on the topic of capital punishment. Is the death penalty really constitutional. Research and study over the topic leads to the conclusion that capital punishment should not be instituted in the United States for various reasons....   [tags: Capital punishment]

Strong Essays
1345 words (3.8 pages)