Politics Administration Dichotomy And Political Representation Essay

Politics Administration Dichotomy And Political Representation Essay

Length: 1220 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Politics-administration dichotomy and political representation
While gesturing beyond the culture of modernity and its assumptions and preoccupations, Catlaw (2007) argues there is a continued tendency to view the primary problems of public administration narrowly in scientific, epistemological terms rather than broader question about the ontology of modernity, specifically, its particular construction of the political and the divisions, relations, and objects that it posits. As discussed earlier, the political ontology of representation begins from the presupposition of ‘the People’ (Catlaw, 2006). In effect, this is a name for a positive conception of the human world and in the language of deconstruction it presumes a doctrine of being. Catlaw (2007) explains, “representation asserts that there is a constituted political community that is antecedent to any formulation of a state or government. Political institutions, thus, are not generative but, analogous to a non-constructivist view of scientific concepts, merely represent (as in making present again) the given preferences and desires of the People” (p. 228). While modern political discourse collapses this distinction into the nation-state, particularly in international relations, the split clearly persists in the idea of popular sovereignty and representative government.
Catlaw maintains the division between the political and the domestic constitute the very core of Western political life since at least the Greeks. By attaching the field to a specific vision of socio-political order, scholars in public administration have always been confronted with difficult choices about critiquing, affirming, rejecting, or assuming these divisions. Catlaw considers that if the boundarie...


... middle of paper ...


... human processes to make sense of the world. Historically as well as social-scientifically, the mistake is to view structure as permitting us to think that, once and for all, we have a sure grip on the Past and to “choose one of these histories to the exclusion of all others. In other words, while Bevir understandably sees a concern for structuralist ahistoricism, Catlaw sees as a fundamental problem with historisizing.
These works on legitimacy and modern representations of authority are deeply interconnected with human subjectivity, a new political ontology and biopolitical practice. This requires a challenge to the traditional views on legitimacy and subjectivity. The transformations of these take shape and form in Catlaw’s book Fabricating the People, and further developed in several papers. The following section will explore Catlaw’s posthumanist biopolitics.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Dichotomy between Politics and Public Administration Essay

- Politics-Administration Dichotomy essentially has a two part meaning; there are two functions of government for this idea, as the name implies politics, and administration. The argument about the dichotomy between politics and public administration has been around for several years with no overall consensus on why they should be distinct from one another. Looking critically at both sides of the idea, there are ways to demonstrate an accurate presentation of the administrative agencies working and there are also ways they have proved to be inaccurate....   [tags: Woodrow Wilson, sociological analysis]

Better Essays
1353 words (3.9 pages)

Public Policy and Administration Essay

- ... (How Federal, State, and Local Governments Interacts, P.5) The layer cake model is designed to separate the areas of authority between the local government, state government and national government, leaving each government to fund its own responsibilities. The marble cake model merges some of the responsibilities such as the funding for public school system, but parting certain responsibility solely to the state, for example; infrastructure repairs of bridges and roads. The picket fence model shares various fiscal relationships among different levels of government....   [tags: development, the layer cake model]

Better Essays
1856 words (5.3 pages)

Essay on Great Britain´s Reform of The Public Sector

- In mid-nineteenth-century, Britain as the starting point of the reform of public sector. Northcote-Trevelyan Report of 1854 was set up to look more widely into the administration of government, it gave rise to the traditional public administration model. In 1995, after the successful launch of Commonwealth Profiler series, The Auckland Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting of 1995 mandated its “Towards a New Public Administration’ Programme, inspired public sector reforms in advanced Western countries....   [tags: bureaucracy, public administration]

Better Essays
1694 words (4.8 pages)

Theories in Frederickson’s book,: The Public Administration Theory Primer

- As explained in Frederickson’s book, “The Public Administration Theory Primer” there is so many types of organizational theory in public administration. We are going to explore only three of these theories and their applications to public and non-profit administrations in the 21st century. The first theory we are going to analyze is the theories of Political Control of Bureaucracy. This theory focuses on the question of bureaucracy compliance with the law and the preferences of the lawmakers. There is much distrust of American philosophy in the power of government in public administration....   [tags: Institution, Structure]

Better Essays
1953 words (5.6 pages)

Traditional Model to New Public Management Essay

- Traditional public administration is traced back to the works of scholars like Max Weber, Woodrow Wilson and Fredrick Taylor. This form of administration was mostly influenced by Max Weber with his bureaucratic model and theory. Max Weber was a well-known sociologist born in Germany in the year 1864. He came up with his bureaucratic model as a way to trying of improve management in organizations. ‘Weber emphasized on top-down control in the form of monocratic hierarchy that is a system of control in which policy is set at the top and carried out through a series of offices, whereby every manager and employee are to report to one person in top management and held accountable by that manager’...   [tags: Public Administration, Tradition, Modern]

Better Essays
1315 words (3.8 pages)

Bureaucratic Reform in Indonesia Essay

- Public Administration Role in Implementation of Bureaucratic Reform in Indonesia Bureaucratic reform is one of the government's efforts to achieve good governance. The experiences of many countries show that bureaucratic reform is the first step to achieve the advancement of a country. Bureaucratic reform is not only about the effectiveness and efficiency of the reform process in the bureaucracy, but also become the backbone in the life of the nation. Bureaucratic reform applied in ministries and government agencies in accordance with the demand of current conditions and situations....   [tags: public administration, governance]

Better Essays
1118 words (3.2 pages)

The Political Administration Dichotomy Is Defined As A System Of Government

- If one was to look at the political administration dichotomy, in theory only elected officials should be the ones who decide the public policy, since they are decision makers, but once the policy is made by the elected officials then the policy implementations. Furthermore, administrations are the responsibility of the bureaucrat with whatever they do. In practice, the bureaucrat is involved in implementation and formulation, in which they have the expertise and the knowledge on the subject. The question then is should bureaucrats be involved in policy formulation....   [tags: Government, Policy, Bureaucracy, Implementation]

Better Essays
1186 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on Frank J. Goodnow 's Politics And Administration

- Frank J. Goodnow’s “Politics and Administration,” infers that politics and administration cannot be divided and are in need of each other to function. However, politics are superior to administration. Goodnow’s further analyzes and identifies three forms of authorities that enforce and implements states will. The first responsibility of authority is to respect the right of the people when conflicts ascend between either private or public matters. The second is judicial authorities also referred to as executive authorities that ensure the needs and policies of the state are executed....   [tags: Political philosophy, Government, Politics]

Better Essays
1009 words (2.9 pages)

Mill´s Construction on Representative Government Essay

- ... By valuing the passive quality of political participation over its active quality, he underhandedly undermines the practice of democracy; education need not amount to any influence on the exercise of authority. Surreptitiously, Mill claims democratic influence on the exercise of authority is great theoretically, but only theoretically; practical influence on the exercise of authority must be left to the “specially trained and experienced few” of “superior minds.” Mill openly champions representative government – government in which people rule through their representatives – as the best form of government....   [tags: democratic, government, authority, political]

Better Essays
1005 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Weaknesses And Weaknesses Of The International Political Administration

- What are the aspects, strengths and weaknesses of one theoretical approach to global governance. Global governance deals with world politics or foreign administration therefore compelling the performance of actors (state and non-state) in the international political system’s administration. It is an important field in the study of international relations and been defined differently but ultimately geared towards the sense of international political administration. The World Health Organisation defines Global Governance can be defined as the different ways organisations, institutions, businesses, and governments manage their affairs, further explaining that it refers to the way in which globa...   [tags: International relations, Political philosophy]

Better Essays
935 words (2.7 pages)