The No Selves Argument Essay

The No Selves Argument Essay

Length: 2299 words (6.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Thomas Nagel, in “Brain Bisection and the unity of consciousness,” presents a thesis for the nonexistence of selves in human beings. Selves, in the case of Nagel’s argument, are the physiological bases of mind that constitute the subject of experience. A self may be thought of as the fundamental person, or the “Personal Identity”. There has been substantial difficulty in identifying the number of persons present in a human being, and the initial and seemingly apparent answer of “one” becomes less convincing upon inspection of further evidence. (Nagel, 1971, p. 396)

In particular, medical patients who have undergone a partial or complete corpus callosotomy exhibit strange behavior under specific conditions that casts doubt on the conclusion that each human has one self. The corpus callosum, the cerebral commissure between the two hemispheres of the brain, serves as the communication pathway for messages between the hemispheres. Typically, information from sensory organs is duplicated or communicated throughout the brain regardless of the origin of a sensation and which hemisphere it is directly connected to via the corpus callosum. (Nagel, 1971, pp. 396-400; Sperry, 1968, pp. 723-725; Sperry, 1984, pp. 661-663)

When the corpus callosum is severed, often a last resort surgical procedure to resolve some medical issue such as epilepsy, not all information can be transmitted between the disconnected hemispheres, and the resulting effects provide interesting evidence that has spawned many theories regarding selves and their countability. These effects have been shown in monkeys, humans, and cats using carefully devised studies and experiments. For human patients, a special apparatus is used to stimulate each hemisphere separately....


... middle of paper ...


...sphere dominance for understanding intentions of others: Evidence from a split-brain patient. BMJ case reports [doi:10.1136/bcr.07.2008.0593].

Puccetti, R. (1973), “Brain Bisection and Personal Identity”, British Journal for the
Philosophy of Science 24, 339-55.

Puccetti, R. (1989). Two brains, two minds? Wigan’s theory of mental duality. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 40:137-144.

Sperry, R. (1968). Hemispheric disconnection and unity in conscious awareness. American Psychologist, 23, 723-733.

Sperry, R. (1984). Consciousness, Personal Identity and the Divided Brain. Neuropsychologia. 22, 661-673.

Vining, E., Freeman, J., Pillas, D., Uematsu, S., Carson, B., Brandt, J., Boatman, D., Pulsifier, M., Zuckerberg, A. (1997). Why would you remove half a brain? The outcome of 58 children after hemispherectomy. Pediatrics, 100, pp. 163-171.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Argument for the Existence of God Essay

- The Argument for the Existence of God It is an undisputed fact that some people claim to have experienced God. It is these religious experiences that have been used by philosophers to argue for the existence of God. The main way of expressing the argument from religious experience is as follows: P1 Someone experiences an entity C1 The entity exists P2 Someone has experienced God C2 God exists Those who champion the argument seek to differentiate ordinary experiences and religious experiences....   [tags: Papers]

Term Papers
1166 words (3.3 pages)

Cellphones and Technology Essay

- Technologies within cell phones are changing rapidly; so rapidly that the changes cannot be controlled. Cell phones and phones in general have evolved greatly since they were first invented, with everything available with only a click of a button. In general, phones have gone from being connected to one through an operator, to calling someone using a dial phone, to being able to contact someone while they are on the go at a pay phone station, to having one’s own personal hand held cell phone. Cell phones have greatly come a long ways and have technologically improved....   [tags: Our Cellphones Our Selves, Impacts]

Term Papers
2064 words (5.9 pages)

Analysis Of The Article ' The Basic Argument ' Essay

- Strawson’s “The Basic Argument” claims that free will does not exist and that each and every individual cannot be held morally responsible for their actions. My interpretation after reading the persuasive essay is that this notion is correct. Before reading the excerpt from Strawson’s argument, free will was a point of mental struggle. I have often throughout my life thought of the teaching of free will I have grown up with; a religious based one. To me, the argument of free will never seemed whole....   [tags: Thought, Mind, Free will, Human]

Term Papers
1103 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on A Pro-Gay Marriage Argument

- In the United States today, the divorce rate is at 50% throughout the nation. With promiscuity on the rise, and the effects of the ever dropping economy, marriage is no longer a priority to some. Still to others, overlooking the fact that many no longer see marriage as crucial, they are determined to save what they consider constitutes the model for marriage. For years, marriage opportunities for homosexuals has been an ongoing debate, and it still continues today. Many critics of the ordeal pose the argument that the allowance of same-sex unions would single-handedly demolish the already fragile structure of marriage (Head)....   [tags: Homosexuality, argumentative]

Term Papers
842 words (2.4 pages)

The Argument For Why Abortion Is Morally Wrong Essay

- In my opinion Marquis ' argument for why abortion is morally wrong has a couple of flaws, it’s biased towards the fetus and makes some unreasonable assumptions. Specifically, Marquis account of why killing adult human is wrong can potentially lead to some controversial conclusions. Marquis also doesn 't consider any consequences on the lives of the potential parents of the fetus. Due to the nature of the topic of abortion, it really only applies to women who are thinking of getting an abortion, and as such, we can 't make the standard assumptions that we will have with normal fetuses....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Value, Fetus]

Term Papers
1178 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about Descartes’ Argument from Divisibility

- Descartes’ Argument from Divisibility Works Cited Missing Reneì Descartes’ treatise on dualism, his Meditations on First Philosophy, is a seminal work in Western intellectual history, outlining his theory of the mind and its relation to the rest of the world. The main argument running through the Meditations leads from his universal methodic doubt through his famous cogito, to proofs of dualism, God, and the world. The Cartesian dualism is one of the most influential ideas to come out of the work; the style of the Meditations, however, is one of personal rumination, following what appears to be Descartes’ stream of consciousness , and it allows for mild tangential discussions....   [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Papers]

Term Papers
1693 words (4.8 pages)

Why Animals Should Not Be Tested On Including History And The Arguing The Opposing Argument

- In this paper I will support the argument on why animals should not be tested on including history and the arguing the opposing argument. I strongly believe that animals should not be tested on because it is inhumane and unnecessary. In this day and age, animals don’t need to be tested on because we have such advance technology in the medical fields which includes the replication of cells and other human parts. Animals have no voice and cannot speak up for them selves on how they feel or what the problem is....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights]

Term Papers
1946 words (5.6 pages)

Argument Vs. Argument : Argument Essay

- At the heart of philosophy is philosophical argument. Arguments are different from assertions. Assertions are simply stated; arguments always involve giving reasons. An argument is a reasoned inference from one set of claims – the premises – to another claim – the conclusion. The premises provide reasons to believe that the conclusion is true. If the premises are true, the conclusion is more likely to be true. Arguments seek to ‘preserve truth’ – true premises will lead to a true conclusion. It is worth knowing a little bit more about arguments straightaway....   [tags: Logic, Inductive reasoning, Argument]

Term Papers
777 words (2.2 pages)

Essay Possible Selves

- An individual’s possible self is a significant aspect of their life to understand what their future may or may not hold. An individual’s possible self also presents a conceptual connection linking cognition and motivation (Markus & Nurius, 1986). “Projecting one’s self into the future involves creating possible selves that represent what they could become, what they would like to become, and what they are afraid of becoming” (Kail & Cavanaugh, 2007). The stages of Reflective Judgment have distinguished itself by its ability to illustrate the development of reasoning from adolescence to adulthood....   [tags: Case Study]

Term Papers
981 words (2.8 pages)

The Argument Of An Argument Essay

- In many lives people face others with different ideas and beliefs. Sometimes these opinions cause complaints that turn into arguments, however, these are never settled or reach an understanding. Making a complaint is creating a strong position that proves the point and defends the issue using a logical argument. To begin with, many arguments come from a discussion between two people that intensify and become more heated. These arguments explore the difference of opinions to prove which is per-say right or wrong....   [tags: Critical thinking, Logic, Argument, Psychology]

Term Papers
724 words (2.1 pages)