Nietzschean Genealogy and Hegelian History in The Genealogy of Morals

1729 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Nietzsche's on the genealogy of morality essay

According to Kain, he argued that Nietzsche was influenced by Hegelian history, even though many philosophers like Deleuze, Greene and Houlgate saying that Nietzsche is opposing Hegel master-slave dialectic (Kain, pg.123-124). Kain saying, that according to Nietzsche he was not trying to bring back master-slave dialectic, but Kain finds hard to believe, since there so much in common (Kain, pg 124). Kain is trying to investigate the relationship between Hegel’s master and slave and the clash between Nietzsche’s master and slave morality (Kain, pg. 123). Also Kain is trying to reject the view that “Übermensch “is created from the master rather than the slave ( Kain,pg 123).

According to Nietzsche, “the good” could be understood as” noble, the high-placed and the high-minded” and opposite of those would be “low-minded and plebeian” those would be ‘the bad” (Nietzsche, GM, pg. 11). According to Kain, this view was hold based on the class system (Kain, pg 124). If you are in the upper class and superior class it means that you are having more” power “and you are the one who everyone could “trust” therefore you are “the good” (Kain, pg.123). Kain is saying that this standpoint led masters to acknowledge their self (Kain, pg. 124). According to Kain, “the bad” were the others (Kain, pg 125). This viewpoint was not created by the slave but by aristocrats that had made such a notion who is “the good” and who is “the bad”, stated by Kain (Kain, pg. 125). According to Nietzsche, “the good” has nothing to do with being not egoistic (Nietzsche, GM, pg. 12). Nietzsche also adds, that ‘egoistic and unegoistic” actions started to become noticeable when aristocrats judgment of value degrade (Nietzsche, GM, pg. 12). Kain st...

... middle of paper ...

..., world and what they can do in order to become free and create their new world. However master - save dialectic even both master and slave realize their dependency on the each other and how the system works they are not able to change anything in their position. In my opinion Nietzsche picture is more optimistic because there is way out and there is chance to create a "new heaven" where in Hegel picture you have to just accept that if you are slave you will be there for long time it might gradually change and one stays in this " unhappy consciousness " in Hegel picture.

Work cited

Philip J. Kain, “Nietzschean Genealogy and Hegelian History in The Genealogy of Morals,” Canadian Journal of Philosophy, 26:1 (1996): 123-148.

Friedrich Nietzsche, On the Genealogy of Morals,trans CAROL DIETHE,Ed.

KEITH ANSELL-PEARSON,Cambridge University Press 1994,2007,GM

Show More
Related

  • Compare And Contrast Nietzsche And Martin Luther King

    560 Words  | 2 Pages

    Friedrich Nietzsche was a brilliant and outspoken man who uses ideas of what he believe in what life is about. He did not believe in what is right and wrong because if who opposed the power. Nietzsche was against Democracy because how they depend on other people to make some different or change, while Nietzsche believe they should of just pick the ones that were gifted and talent to choose what to change. Nietzsche also does not believe in Aristocracy because how they depend on an individual person to create the rules or change those benefits for him. As you see Nietzsche did not like how they depend on one person to decide instead of each person to decide for himself for their own benefits.

    Read More

  • Examining Good and Bad Conscience in Friedrich Nietzsche's Genealogy of Morals

    1631 Words  | 4 Pages

    Friedrich Nietzsche is recognized for being one of the most influential German philosophers of the modern era. He is known for his works on genealogy of morality, which is a way to study values and concepts. In Genealogy of Morals, Friedrich Nietzsche mentions that values and concepts have a history because of the many different meanings that come with it. Nietzsche focused on traditional ethical theories, especially those rooted in religion. Not being a religious man, he believed that human life has no moral purpose except for the significance that human beings give it. People from different backgrounds and circumstances in history bend morality's meaning, making it cater to the norms of their society. For example, the concept of what is "good" in the ancient Greek culture meant aristocratic, noble, powerful, wealthy, pure, but not in modern era. Meaning, in the past the term “good” was not applied to a kind of act that someone did but rather applied to the kind of person and background they had. Nietzsche’s project was to help expand one’s understanding by re-examining morality through genealogy of morality; helping one to be more aware of a potential confusion in moral thinking. He feels that the current values and concepts that have been instilled into a society are a reversal of the truth, forcing him to believe that one’s moral systems had to have been created within society. In the works of genealogy of morality, Nietzsche traces out the origins of the concepts of guilt and bad conscience, which will be the main focal point, and explaining its role in Nietzsche’s project against morality. It will be argued that guilt and bad conscience goes against Nietzsche’s role against morality because it can conflict with the moral co...

    Read More

  • The Controtorical Analysis Of Nietzsche's Moral Nihilism

    2660 Words  | 6 Pages

    At first we see “what is in it for us”. After that, we “take this effect as the intention”. At last, we “ascribe the harboring of such intentions as a permanent quality of the person whose behavior we are observing”. Following from these steps is how we can determine whether a person is harmful, beneficial or kind (102). Nietzsche claims that our judgment is always based on how the actions of the other relate to me “What harms me is something evil (harmful in itself); what is useful to me is something good (102).” From here, Nietzsche refuses the idea that we are able to morally judge the other. Nietzsche then questions that if we assess the right actions relatively then “we ourselves must constitute the principle of the good (102).” But how can we constitute the principle of good if we are ignorant about our actions, our ego, and our neighbor. The truth is that we are deceiving ourselves and we are shaping this principle of good in a manner that suits us. From here, our principle of good is conditional, and we don’t constitute the “principle of

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Freudis And Nietzsche

    862 Words  | 2 Pages

    Both Freud and Nietzsche presented almost the same interpretations of human nature and the society they lived in. Though, the societies in which they lived in were different. Freud and Nietzsche’s thoughts may be similar, but human nature constantly changes. Freud is more aware, he examines into the past to find reasons that make life more civilized, however Nietzsche is more doubtful, he sees that humans should be led by a hero.

    Read More

  • The Groundwork of the Metaphysic of Morals

    1055 Words  | 3 Pages

    Groundwork of the Metaphysic of Morals. Trans. H. J. Paton. 1964. Reprint. New York: Harper Perennial Modern Thought, 2009.

    Read More

  • On the Genealogy of Morality

    1185 Words  | 3 Pages

    While critical of the attitude found in the ressentiment of slave morality, Nietzsche’s includes it as an important factor contributing to the bad conscience of man. Even though Nietzsche dislikes the negative results of bad conscience – man’s suppression of his instincts, hate for himself, and stagnation of his will -- Nietzsche does value it for the promise it holds. Nietzsche foresees a time coming when man conquers his inner battle and regains his “instinct of freedom.” In anticipation of that day’s eventual arrival, Nietzsche views the development of bad conscience as a necessary step in man’s transformation into the “sovereign individual.”

    Read More

  • The Question of Free Will: Descartes, Hume, and Nietzsche

    2066 Words  | 5 Pages

    September 10, 2009. Cambridge Critical Guide to Nietzsche’s On the Genealogy of Morality, Simon May, ed., 2010. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1473095>. Nietzsche, Friedrich.

    Read More

  • Nietzsche Philosophical Ideas About The Nature Of Human Behavior Research Paper

    1224 Words  | 3 Pages

    Firstly, Nietzsche stated that life is death in the making and all humans should not be determined by an external force rather, he believed that humans should have the incentive to think for themselves. Nietzsche claimed the future of a man is in his own hands. Simultaneously, humans are phased with struggles in the attempt to self-create themselves. Nietzsche proceeded with his argument affirming

    Read More

  • History as a Theatre

    3309 Words  | 7 Pages

    P. 38-39, Friedrich Nietzsche, “Beyond Good and Evil” Cambridge Texts in the History of Philosophy, translated by Judith Norman, Cambridge University Press, 2002

    Read More

  • On The Genealogy Of Moralism In Joseph Conrad's Heart Of Darkness

    1324 Words  | 3 Pages

    In 1887, two years before succumbing to utter madness, existential philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche writes his ethical polemic, On the Genealogy of Morals, in search of a man with the strength to evolve beyond humanity:

    Read More

  • Essay on Mary Shelley's Frankenstein and Bladerunner

    933 Words  | 2 Pages

    Lastly both Frankenstein's monster and Roy Baty state what it means to be a slave, one to his envy and rage, and the other to a human race that spurns him. "..but I was the slave, not the master, of an impulse, which I detested, yet could not disobey...Evil thence forth became my good."

    Read More

  • Rhetoric vs. Truth

    2248 Words  | 5 Pages

    On Truth and Lies in a Nonmoral Sense, Nietzsche. United States of America: Bedford/St.Martin's, 2001. 1171-1179. Print

    Read More

  • THE SINFUL NATURE OF MEN IN WILLIAM GOLDING'S LORD OF THE FLIES

    1264 Words  | 3 Pages

    When anyone thinks of the word “evil” they do not think it is within themselves. In reality, without a structured and well-followed society, people are apt to follow their own corrupt desires and neglect the thought of consequence. In the allegory, Lord of the Flies, William Golding reveals that man’s selfishness and sinful nature will be unmasked when the structure of a society deteriorates.

    Read More

  • The Metaphysical Analysis Of Nietzsche's God Is Dead

    715 Words  | 2 Pages

    The church told them that they had original sin and that by focusing on God, Heaven, and one’s soul, the church can fix the sin inside one. This is Nietzsche’s theory called Metaphysical. The Metaphysical theory says that the church has one pay attention to their internal instead of having the followers focus on the life they live now. By focusing just on God, Heaven, and Soul, one is deemphasizing the importance of the religion itself. With the revaluation of values, Nietzsche focused on morality, more specifically, Master Morality and Slave Morality. Master Morality is when one is concerned with strength and competition, and achieving goals is an accomplishment. Slave Morality deals with concepts of good and evil with the Evil representing the Master morality. The slave morality lives within the master’s shadows and will reject what the master stands for, this morality will suffer from resentment also, both moralities can be found in the same person. In a person, the Master morality vision has gone beyond the concepts of good and evil and has looked into a deeper meaning in themselves, but the master morality is not an end

    Read More

  • Genealogy Of Morals, And Thrasymachus In Plato's Republic

    1780 Words  | 4 Pages

    Nietzsche’s Genealogy of Morals can be assessed in regards to the three essays that it is broken up into. Each essay derives the significance of our moral concepts by observing

    Read More

More about Nietzschean Genealogy and Hegelian History in The Genealogy of Morals

Open Document