Essay on The Great Plains As A Middle Ground

Essay on The Great Plains As A Middle Ground

Length: 1046 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Kathleen DuVal, professor of History at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, contests long held beliefs about the historiography of native people and their place in America with her work, The Native Ground: Indians and Colonists in the Heart of the Continent. DuVal’s insightful book focuses on the Arkansas River Valley and the diverse group of both native groups and European powers that contented over the physical landscape, its resources, and the perception of control and power. The premise of Native is to show that native groups such as the Quapaws, Osage, and the Cherokee had the upper hand in almost every aspect from their economy, military might, and physical presence up until the 1800s.
DuVal boldly begins in the introduction by calling into question the concept of the Great Plains as a “middle ground” proposed by historian Richard White. This concept treats the interactions of the Europeans and the natives as an amalgamation of different accommodations with no group gaining significant ground. More importantly the concept of a middle ground is predicated on the natives wanting to compromise or be assimilated into Western culture. DuVal’s book shows that this idea of the region is simply not true because of the heavy dominance of the natives. DuVal uses the term “native ground” in place of middle ground to emphasize the point that all groups roaming the Arkansas River Valley believed to be the true natives of the region. This narrative employed by the natives, and then later the Europeans, helped establish legitimacy and cement power among other groups. DuVal’s first subjects are the chiefdom tribes along the Mississippi River and the Spanish Empire. This section of the book really shows the swing the native t...


... middle of paper ...


...ts causing mayhem. Vu Dal surprise readers by show how Osage view other tribes as savage, a term normal used by Europeans. The strategic placement of the Osage as being most civilized of the regional tribe was a huge advantage among the Europeans who valued such things.
Native Ground is a groundbreaking study that tries to establish a new framework to view colonial history. I feel that Du Vul does a wonderful job creating a successful argument of how the idea of a middle ground is just not valid when the Indians had such a large sphere of influence. In the end native groups would still fall to encroachment by Americans that did not understand or respect their way of life. Unfortunately, even with this new framework the outcome is still the same, the destruction of powerful culture and proud people by a group that know perceives itself a the native people.




Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Where Are The People, Animals, And Crops? Essay

- Desolate and barren landscapes can invoke a sense of melancholy when reflecting on the contrast of what is being observed versus what should be. With once glance, this sadness is evoked as the viewer is able to discern that something has gone very wrong in Mervin Jules’s work, Dust. The bleak portrait that the artist presents inspires questions as to what happened to the devastated landscape he chose as his focal piece. The artifact itself is a black and white lithograph part of the Wolfsonian-FIU collection....   [tags: Great Depression, Dust Bowl, 1930s, Great Plains]

Strong Essays
1228 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on The Great Plains

- If time could be reversed and polar bears saved from the melting ice caps, the idea that someone would not take advantage of that is preposterous. Rewilding the Great Plains may not save the polar bears, though it is a step in the right direction to take better care of our earth. Rewilding, as in bringing back mammals that have not been in their habitat for thousands of years and reintroducing the species to a freshly marked land. Rewilding the Great Plains has the potential to help bring back sustainable agriculture as well as have better reactions to the projected impacts that will occur due to the changing climate....   [tags: Great Plains, Dust Bowl, North America]

Strong Essays
2127 words (6.1 pages)

Essay on The Dust Bowl Of The Great Plains

- The dust bowl was a very tedious time to live in. It was also a time when money could be made very quickly and can be lost just as fast as it was gained. The problems of the dustbowl were caused by a cascade of events. The biggest of these events would undoubtedly be because of drought. There was no rain, no moisture and that meant that no farmer in the plains could plant any crop there to make a profit for his or her family. The drought, being the single most devastating effect on planting crops in the Great Plains, proved to be a force of devastation for many years....   [tags: Dust Bowl, Great Plains, Great Depression]

Strong Essays
1536 words (4.4 pages)

Essay about Ted Kooser: Great Poet of the Great Plains

- Thomas Jefferson, one of the greatest men in American history, described his vision for the United States of America as a land of agrarian people. However, now, over two centuries later, the US faces a very different reality dominated by the growth of the urban metropolis, by industry, by the stoic bankers of Wall Street. Despite this, the poetry of Ted Kooser immortalizes a quickly vanishing lifestyle of rustic America on the vast expanses of the Great Plains. Kooser was born in a small Iowa town in April 1939 and received a degree from Iowa State University....   [tags: american history, great plains, jefferson]

Strong Essays
800 words (2.3 pages)

The Dust Bowl Of The Great Plains Region Devastated By Drought Essay examples

- 1 Introduction The Dust Bowl was the name given to the Great Plains region devastated by drought in 1930’s when America was going through the Great Depression. The 150,000 square-mile area included Oklahoma, Texas and sections of Kansas, Colorado, and New Mexico. This area had little rainfall, light soil, and high winds, a destructive combination. When the drought struck from 1934 to 1937, the soil lacked a strong root system of grass as an anchor, so the winds easily picked up the loose topsoil and swirled it into dense dust clouds, called “black blizzards.” The dust storms wreaked havoc, choking cattle and pasture lands....   [tags: Dust Bowl, Great Plains, Agriculture]

Strong Essays
1034 words (3 pages)

Contested Plains by Elliot West Essay

- There are many ways in which we can view the history of the American West. One view is the popular story of Cowboys and Indians. It is a grand story filled with adventure, excitement and gold. Another perspective is one of the Native Plains Indians and the rich histories that spanned thousands of years before white discovery and settlement. Elliot West’s book, Contested Plains: Indians, Goldseekers and the Rush to Colorado, offers a view into both of these worlds. West shows how the histories of both nations intertwine, relate and clash all while dealing with complex geological and environmental challenges....   [tags: american west, indians, great plains]

Strong Essays
1191 words (3.4 pages)

Dust Bowl : The Southern Plains Essay

- In the book Dust Bowl: The Southern Plains in the 1930s the author, Donald Worster, makes the argument that the Dust Bowl was a mostly a direct result of farmer’s methods and misuse of the fragile plains environment. However, there were many other largely contributing factors to the Dust Bowl. While the farmer’s methods played a role, other factors such as economic decline, unusually high temperatures, an extended drought accompanied by and economic depression, and the resulting wind erosion were all factors that help explain The Dust Bowl....   [tags: Great Depression, Dust Bowl, 1930s, Great Plains]

Strong Essays
712 words (2 pages)

The Southern Plains Of The United States Essays

- The southern plains of the United States, was an area that encompassed in part, Northern Texas, Oklahoma, Kansas, South East Colorado and Northern New Mexico. The area was predominately made up of several hundred species of drought resistant grasses, and was sparsely settled. It was less desirable for agriculture due the lack of supporting systems. The lack of nearby timber for building, water sources, and location to nearby cities, did not lend itself in appeal to settlement of the area, to the common American farmer....   [tags: Dust Bowl, Great Plains, United States]

Strong Essays
1712 words (4.9 pages)

Essay on The Ogallala: Preserving the Great American Desert

- Long ago, the middle of the North American continent was a treeless prairie covered by tall grasses and roaming buffalo. When European settlers came, they called this area the Great American Desert. Today, this "desert" is covered with fields of wheat, corn, and alfalfa made possible by center-pivot irrigation. My grandfather used to sell center-pivot systems and when my family drove to my grandparent's home in Nebraska, we would count how many "sprinklers" were watering each section of land....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Strong Essays
1871 words (5.3 pages)

Essay about The Dust Bowl : The Southern Plains

- The “Dust Bowl: The Southern Plains in the 1930s”, was written by Donald Worster, who admits wanted to write the book for selfish reasons, so that he would have a reason o visit the Southern Plains again. In the book he discusses the events of the “dirty thirties” in the Dust Bowl region and how it affected other areas in America. “Dust Bowl” was a term coined by a journalist and used to describe the area that was in the southern planes in the states of Kansas, Colorado, New Mexico, Oklahoma and Texas, between the years of 1931 and 1939....   [tags: Great Depression, Dust Bowl]

Strong Essays
906 words (2.6 pages)