Fantasy Vs. Reality in Badlands, directed by Terrence Malick and If, directed by Lindsay Anderson

1651 Words4 Pages

A subjective experience is something experienced by the individual in their mind. The subjective experience is an inner life experience rather than a part of one’s external reality. These experiences can be ones made up completely in the mind or reactions to reality that are personal. Badlands directed by Terrence Malick and If…. Directed by Lindsay Anderson are two films that contain and represent the subjective experience. In the film Badlands the subjective experience is linked to Holly, who narrates the film and in if…. It is linked to Mick Travis character. In both of these films the subjective experience are events made up in these characters minds.

In the film Badlands the narration is provided by Sissy Spacek’s character Holly, a young girl in South Dakota. Throughout the film we get Holly’s reactions to everything happening in the story as well as her own thoughts and daydreams. It is even possible that the entire thing is a story she has made up in her own head. We know that she is telling the story from some time in the future since later in the film she tells us that she ended up marrying the son of the lawyer who had gotten her off on probation. In this case it is possible that she could change parts of the story to fit her desires. In the article “Coming of Age in the 1970s: Revision, Fantasy, and Rage in the Teen-Girl Badlands” the author Barbara Jane Brickman writes the Holly is above the viewer in “the hierarchy of knowledge, since she is clearly privy to more information and doles it out as she sees fit, sometimes even assessing the feelings and interior motivations of other characters” (27-8). There are numerous occasions throughout the film where Holly gives us information about things happenin...

... middle of paper ...

...ant to its story. These fantasies are subjective experiences for Holly and for Mick as they give focus on the inner life of these characters. The use of fantasy gives these films a unique structure to their stories. With it there can be multiple interpretation of each. In If… maybe it is not a fantasy and they really did open fire on the school. In Badlands it gives multiply possibilities for Holly’s role in the narrative with her narration.

Works Cited

Badlands. Dir. Terrence Malick. Perf. Sissy Spacek and Martin Sheen. Warner Bros., 1973. DVD.

Brickman, B. J. "Coming of Age in the 1970s: Revision, Fantasy, and Rage in the Teen-Girl Badlands." Camera Obscura: Feminism, Culture, and Media Studies 22.66 (2007): 25 59. Humanities International Complete. Web. 5 May 2014.

If.... Dir. Lindsay Anderson. Perf. Malcolm McDowell. Paramount Pictures, 1968. DVD.

More about Fantasy Vs. Reality in Badlands, directed by Terrence Malick and If, directed by Lindsay Anderson

Open Document