"Learning to Read and Write" Should Be on Adler's List of Great Books

657 Words2 Pages

"Anyone who desires to learn need only pick up the book and read, it is that simple", stated Mortimer J. Adler (...). This can be appliable though, in people who know how to read. Frederick Douglass, a black slave, desired to be educated and literate but he had to face many obstacles to achieve this. His essay "Learning to Read and Write" describes his attempts of getting literate and how he finally achieved his goal. Douglass' essay should not be included in Adler's list of Great Books, but instead it should be considered a good book, because it fullfils only one of the three criteria that Adler sets, this of "contemporary significance" (...) and does not fulfill the rest two, the one of "rereadability" and this of "relevance to a very large number of great ideas"(...).

Adler's list of Great Books consists of 443 "world's "classics""(reader), which all of them meet three characteristics. Adler's first criterion of including one book in his list is this of "contemporary significance." This means, as Adler explained it, that "they should be works that they are as much of concern to us today as the time they were written" (...). This is the only characteristic that Douglass' essay accomplishes and it does this by pointing out major problems that are today's issues as well, slavery and illiteracy. Slavery, in the first place, does not exist in most of the countries nowadays, but we can allude it to the economic condition of the fugitives. Fugitives are in a foreign country and are not as free as they were in their own one, having little opportunities to be literate and educated. Their primary goal is to have the minimum amount of money needed to survive so they do not consider education so much. Some of these fugitives, thought, try in order to learn how to read and write, dreaming of a better future, without having to work under hard conditions to survive.

Continuing with the first characteristic of Great Books, its important to mention that illiteracy has been a problem for many generations through out centuries. There are always people who do not have the advantage of being literate. The essay signifies that, no matter the circumstances, people must try as hard as they can to achieve their goals. Douglass is a great example of such a person who faced so many obstacles but never gave up his efforts.

Open Document