Differences Between Bread Giver And Yentl

1074 Words3 Pages

As America began to industrialize and the American Dream became a reality for some, immigrants flocked to the New World. As they transitioned from the Old World to this New World in the U.S., many new issues arose surrounding the breaking away from old beliefs and discovering gender equality. Although the female protagonists in both Bread Givers and Yentl, the Yeshiva Boy come from different backgrounds, both women struggle to break away from the traditional role of Jewish women. From the Old World, Yentl, from Yentl, the Yeshiva Boy, was blessed to have a father that encouraged her education but a society that did not. Oppositely, Sara, from Bread Givers, had many opportunities in America, but had to gain footing in the New World without her …show more content…

This is especially true for their fathers because as Sara’s father points out: “it says in the Torah: What’s a woman without a man? Less than nothing—a blotted out existence. No life on earth and no hope in heaven” (Singer, 205). Their society teaches them that women are nothing if they are not serving a man, whether that be their father or husband. However as Yentl and Sara are exposed to new ways of seeing the world, both women choose to challenge this way of thinking. Through Yentl’s religious education and Sara’s American education, they begin to rebel against this ideal that a man is the only factor which determines a woman’s worth in society. Yentl’s father surprisingly supports his daughter’s craving of religious education, but this is only because he believes that she has “the soul of a man...Even Heaven makes mistakes” (Yezierska, 141). Neither woman gets the respect that she deserves as a mature, self aware young lady whose existence is as worthy and strong as any man’s. Sara, oppositely from Yentl, does not receive this intimate nurture due to her father’s overbearing stubbornness to modernize his thinking about gender. Regardless, both females have to face an entire culture that says females should conform to the gender boundaries that their religious society places on

Open Document