Was He Responsible For Doodle's Death?

733 Words2 Pages

Doodle was a boy destined to die from the beginning of his life. He was born with an unknown heart defect so almost everyone thought he would not live to be more than one year old. Even his own brother (the narrator) didn't think he would live long at first. One day he saw Doodle smile and then he realized that he was sane. From then on, all he tried to do was help Doodle be normal by giving him lessons on things like how to walk and swim. At the end of the story the narrator runs away from Doodle after one of the lessons because he is angry that he will not be ready for school. When Doodle is alone and far away from his brother he dies. The brother felt bad and blamed himself for Doodle's death, but it was not his fault. The narrator was not responsible for Doodle's death because he was only a young boy when Doodle was born, Doodle’s death was an accident and no one wanted him to die, and because Doodle …show more content…

Doodle was born with a heart defect that could not be fixed with the technology they had at the time, so the doctor nor the ofamily did not expect him to live more than a year, “Daddy had Mr. Heath, the carpenter build a little mahogany coffin for him” (2). When Doodle was first born, the narrator did not even believe in him. One day he tried to smother him with a pillow because he was embarrassed to have a brother that was not normal. When they were training at Old Woman Swamp or doing any other rigorous physical activity, Doodle could have died any moment. The narrator cannot be blamed for Doodle’s death because he was destined to die anyway. The narrator was not responsible for Doodle’s death. He was too young to understand Doodle’s limitations and had no help from adults when he was teaching him. Doodle’s death was an accident because no one wanted him to die or tried to go out and kill him. In the end, Doodle was going to die anyway because he was destined to die from the beginning of the

More about Was He Responsible For Doodle's Death?

Open Document