Flower Garden By Shirley Jackson

1324 Words3 Pages

For humans, fitting in with the world around us is a necessity. We slowly change ourselves to become more similar to the people we spend the most time with or that have power over us. Sometimes this change is conscious, but many times is happens without us noticing until someone or something comes along and points out how different we are. The way human minds work makes us need other people in our lives; to keep those people around, we must have common beliefs or interests. We tend to change ourselves or attempt to change others until they are more like us. In Flower Garden, by Shirley Jackson, the character of young Mrs. Winning married into the Winning family 11 years prior to the time covered in the story. In those 11 years, she has become …show more content…

Winning to conform stems from the traditions of the Wining family that are upheld but her mother in law, the older Mrs. Winning. She has been conditioned for the last 11 years to think and act like a Winning woman. Shirley Jackson mentions young Mrs. Winning’s loss of personal identity in the first paragraph, in the first sentence even. She says that the two women, the two Mrs. Winnings, have started to look alike even though the younger one married into the family. Older Mrs. Winning starts to change her daughter in law by correct or reprimanding her emotions toward the weather. “I get so tired of the cold,” young Mrs. Winning says, commenting on the seemingly endless winter. The elder tells her that it has, “Got to be cold some of the time”. This small correction is what starts young Mrs. Winning’s loss of individualism. Eventually she starts to see herself as more of a laborer than a person that the family actually cares about. In keeping with family tradition, young Mrs. Winning names her son Howard, like his father, and his father before him. While getting lunch ready with her mother in law, Mrs. Winning though to herself that “she had at least given them another Howard with the Winning eyes and mouth, in exchange for her food and her bed.” She has forgotten the value of her own …show more content…

There is a reason a person believes one thing over another, or acts one way instead of the other and we must search for that reason and remind ourselves why we feel that way and why changing our minds simply to make someone else’s life a little easier or to make a new friend is not a smart decision. We are forced, either by ourselves or by peer pressure, to conform so that we don’t stand out from the rest of the group. In the story, this is shown through the racial challenge. No one in town would hire Mr. Jones because spending that much time with a black man was a deviation from the norms of the town. We need to be more confident in ourselves and learn to stand up for what we believe in. Mrs. MacLane and Davey are great examples not giving in to peer pressure. They do not see race as a barrier or a reason to isolate someone; it has no effect on them that the town wants her to be “one of the nice people again”. It is hard to put yourself out there with no one to back you up. Deviating from the group takes guts, but if we were no longer afraid to voice our real opinions, everything could be different. Imagine what would have happened the Nazis had told Hitler that what he was doing was terrible and wrong. If those that felt that what was happening was wrong had rallied together, the mass slaughter of 10 million people could have been avoided. If

Open Document