I believe that it should not be banned on the fact that Holden is a character that epitomizes the struggle against external pressure, and because banning books, whether it is for profanity or not, violates the First Amendment of the Bill of Rights (Gould, 2010). J.D Salinger was a literary genius in the fact that he was able to create stories and character that the mass public could relate to in one way or another. The Catcher and The Rye is a book about a boy named Holden Caulfield who is torn between being a teenager and facing adulthood. It is widely accepted that Holden suffers... ... middle of paper ... ... that go against conventional society, but are important to literature because those same morals and meanings are relevant in the lives of every American citizen at that point in their lives. Censoring material and banning books go against the First Amendment of the Bill of Rights and should not be permitted under the court of law.
It earned strongly mixed reviews and a lot of negative feedback upon its publication, and was accused of “promoting immoral values” ("J.D. Salinger"). The narrator of the story, Holden Caulfield, has become one of the most iconic male characters of rebellion in history (Feeney). Consequently, The Catcher in the Rye is filled with characters that serve as bad role models, and the story’s explicit and inappropriate remarks can cause too much damage to leave it uncensored. The Catcher in the Rye has been highly criticised for its profanity, lying, violence, and vulgarity, as well as mentions of suicide, drugs and alcohol.
A classic American novel can be classified as one that is relatable, and immortal. Teenagers experience many problems, such as getting bullied, suffering from depression, and from having stress, which provide a connection for them on many different levels when they absorb the message from the novel. To this day, many classic novels are widely enjoyed although they were established in a different time. Therefore, The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger is considered to be a classic American novel because it is immortal.
The theme of The Catcher in the Rye is simple. J. D. Salinger uses this novel to draw a clear distinction between the purity of childhood and the wickedness attained when one reaches adulthood. Salinger uses multiple literary devices including diction, symbolism, tone, and even the title of the novel to drive home his ideas about the innocence of children and the corruption of the world. The form of diction used in The Catcher in the Rye is a topic on which many people are strongly opinionated. Because the narrator speaks solely in the vernacular, the novel is ripe with vulgar language.
Through these factors, it is very clear that The Catcher in the Rye is an American classic and indeed a significant piece of American literature. Salinger and his writings have truly made an impact on the readers of his book. The influences of the theme and his background have made this book into an American classic. The journey he went on as a child influenced his story that he wrote through the eyes of Holden Caulfield. The themes of rebellion and self-containment are portrayed through the story, leaving kids idolizing Holden for his attitude as well as teaching them lessons at the end of the story.
To me, the death happened yesterday. Over a period of weeks, I had grown to know a kindred spirit—a kindred spirit that Nazis violently and slowly extinguished. I realized what it means to hate, for I gained a true hate for Hitler and his thugs. I read as many Anne Frank biographies as I could find. At the end of my study, I literally cried for around an hour.
The night after he died, Holden punched out all of the windows in the garage and even broke his hand. The signs don?t stop there, though. After Holden ordered a prostitute in New York and decided he didn?t want her services, he was feeling rather depressed. He said, ?I felt so depressed you can?t imagine. What I did, I started talking, sort of out loud, to Allie.
World.edu, 11 Jan. 2011. Web. 8 Nov. 2013.” The controversy that surrounds the book focuses on a young boy by the name of Holden... ... middle of paper ... ...is book it is their right to do so. However it is clear here that The Catcher clearly has a right to be one of the most controversial books in the history of writing, weather it may be just coincidence or this book really is an explicit brain washing book it is up to the reader to decide this. Works Cited Wolf, Baldassarro R.
This work is similar to other famous and influential works of the same nature. For example, Maxwell Geismar sums up the novel as “…an eminently readable and quotable [novel] in its tragicomic narrative of preadolescent revolt. Compact, taut, and colorful, the first half presents in brief compass all then petty horrors, the banalities, the final mediocrity of the American prep school” (Geismar 195). Holden can not understand the purgatory of Pency prep, and futilely escapes from one dark world into darker world of New York City. The second half of the novel raises the intriguing questions and incorporates the deeper meaning of the work (Geismar).
Holden’s excessive cursing was seen by the public as inappropriate however, Donald P. Costello states, “Most critics who looked at The Catcher in the Rye at the time of its publication thought that its language was a true and authentic rendering of teenage colloquial speech” (251). The Catcher in the Rye, encouraged a social revolution. Robson, L. (2010). To have and to Holden. New Statesman, 139(4987), 50.