Summary Of Criminalization Of Poverty By Dennis Prager

590 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Effects on being homeless

Dennis Prager presents many valid points to consider on the topic of poverty causing crime, but I disagree with him because homelessness is being criminalized and that does not necessarily mean the person has no moral self control. We are all raised in different ways which can ultimately define our morals, but sometimes desperation can lead to neglecting our morals.
Dennis Prager makes an interesting claim in which he states that poverty does not cause crime, and uses his personal experience as an example. He goes on to explain how his grandparents made little to no money as the Great Depression emerged. The data Prager presents tell us how about 99 percent of people who live in an apartment or residency have refrigerator, television, and a …show more content…

The half of the 1 percent of the homeless who live in shelter fortunately has a place, but he says nothing about the other half who have no other choice than to sleep on benches outside in the cold, and ask people for spare change. Those people are not doing anything morally incorrect, yet they are being criminalized for trying to survive. In the video “Criminalization of Poverty” I learned that one third of the U.S. cities have banned homeless camps, yet impose laws to keep them off the streets, then where are they supposed to go? For the other people who, according to the U.S. Department of Energy have refrigerators in their homes, do those numbers reveal the amount of food inside? Prager says these people don’t suffer from material poverty, but it doesn’t seem like they are able to use the materials adequately to feed themselves, or their families. The numbers are simply a shell; they don’t tell us the actual situation of the person. The belief that poverty causes crime does not mean we at some level in our conscious would consider it, or think others are morally inferior, it simply means we can imagine the frustration that drives them to commit such crimes. Either way, if they rob, or if they sleep on a bench they will still be committing a crime in certain states that make it illegal to sleep on

Show More
Related

  • The Problem Of Homelessness In San Antonio, Texas

    1193 Words  | 3 Pages

    It is true that some individuals are homeless not because of bad habits one might have, but because of financial reasons. A lot of society that is part of this problem is because they simply do not make enough at their low

    Read More

  • Brother Don T Spare A Dime Summary

    737 Words  | 2 Pages

    In “Brother, Don’t Spare a Dime,” L. Christopher Awalt says that homeless people are homeless on their own accord. He believes “many of them seem to have chosen the lifestyles they lead” (Awalt))).. This article states that most homeless people would prefer to escape responsibility rather than fix their social and economic problems. Awalt uses an example of a man who had been on the streets for about 10 years. He provided this man with resources to improve his life and within four months he was making progress. By the sixth month the man had checked himself out of the hospital and was back on the streets drunk again. Awalt does show a few people are the victims of tragic circumstances and will bounce back in a short period of time. Awalt believes homeless people have become dangerous to the public, and they do not deserve our money to help them out of their predicament. We do not agree with Awalt’s assumption that the majority of the homeless people in the United States are there because of their lack of responsibility. There are many causes of homelessness that cannot be avoided, and the majority of the people that become homeless will not be on the streets for long.

    Read More

  • Capitalism And Homelessism

    949 Words  | 2 Pages

    In order to be radical about poverty, we need to understand the difference between wealth and income. Income is a transfer of money by working or by gifts. On the other hand, wealth is more of a total of accumulated assets that has been stored for a period of time (Conley, pg. 253). Wealth is not distributed equally among the public. (NCH, 2016, http://nationalhomeless.org/about-homelessness/). Declining wages has also caused a lot of stress and increase people’s inability to pay for their housing or other needs. If there are affordable housing, it’s usually in an unsafe and polluted environment or it’s extremely overcrowded that people have a higher chance of being homeless or inadequate housing arrangements than getting their applications accepted (Why Are People Homeless Research, 2016, NCH). Also, privatizing housing will increase the accumulation of wealth of the power elite or those that own property and lands by their pricing in rents. Most people go through depression because of loss of home, jobs, or a sense of self. Often times, the lack education about health and they don’t receive adequate support for medical care if they are homelessness. Poverty is also treated as a criminal offence and if people were to ask for public assistance, they have to prove their eligibility. If they have a criminal record, they are

    Read More

  • The Social Stigma of Homelessness

    742 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the early hours of the morning on Thursday, January 3, 2013, James G. Fulmer was found frozen to death on the steps of a Nashville Church. James Fulmer was 50 years old, homeless, and physically handicapped (wsmv.com). His tragic story is just one of almost 1,000 homeless men and women will suffer death caused by hypothermia each year. (nationalhomeless.org). Every night in the United States, over 600,000 people encounter homelessness. Their stories are diverse and their paths to homelessness, varied. Many have found themselves on the streets due to domestic violence, job loss and mental illness (npr.org). Some were teachers, accountants, musicians, painters, and even doctors. So many of the homeless population once lead normal lives. Yet, there is a social stigma that views the homeless as lazy, unwilling to work, uneducated and even untrustworthy. In a Capitalist society that places the highest value on image and the almighty dollar, there seems to be little desire to interact with these “outcasts”.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Dianne's Essay Framing Class, Vicarious Living

    1002 Words  | 3 Pages

    More often than not, the homeless are viewed as weak and helpless. They are seen in movies as street beggars, and are vehicles of pity and remorse to touch the hearts of the viewers. Moreover, the media trains its audiences to believe that homelessness comes from the fault of the person. They are “bums, alcoholics, and drug addicts, caught in a hopeless downward spiral because of their individual pathological behavior” (427). In reality, it is the perpetuating cycle of wealth that keeps them in at a standstill in their struggles. The media only condones this very same cycle because it trains the masses to believe that people are poor due to their bad decisions. This overall census that the poor are addicts and alcoholics only makes it easier to drag their image further through the mud, going as far as calling them “crazy.” This is highlighted in shows such as Cops, or Law & Order. With the idea that these people are bad news it is easy to “buy into the dominant ideology construction that views poverty as a problem of individuals” (428). Although some of the issues of the poor are highlighted through episodic framing, for the most part the lower class is a faceless group who bring no real value to the

    Read More

  • Effects Of Criminalization Of Homelessness

    1476 Words  | 3 Pages

    Laws that make the lives of the homeless more difficult are meant to decrease the amount of homeless people however they are counterproductive. Many of the cities enforcing these laws don’t have enough affordable housing available for the homeless. Also fines and criminal charges only make the lives of the homeless more challenging when applying for housing. Not to mention one night in jail costs on average three times as much as one night in a shelter. “The US Interagency Council on Homelessness has strongly advised local governments not to enact laws criminalizing homelessness as it fails to increase access to services and tends to create additional barriers for homeless people while also undermining the impact of service providers Building a Movement to End Homelessness).” Criminalization of the homeless sends the message to the public that homeless people are criminals and should not be helped. What needs to be understood is that

    Read More

  • Homeless In America Essay

    1583 Words  | 4 Pages

    One cannot judge the homeless lifestyle if there is no insight. No one can understand the life of poverty and homelessness unless there has been exposure and have lived through that. Homeless children are living in poverty because of mistakes their guardians or parents have made. These children go through unimaginable events in their life. Most of the time, Homeless youth are either abused physically and mentally. They are innocent humans who have to choice but to grow up and live a life they did not choose to live. Children all around the world are living in hunger everyday of their lives. People are not willing to help. Even some law enforcement, who are leaders in the community show no compassion or empathy towards homeless individuals. The people who are depended on for the safety of the community are being ruthless towards homeless people in the community. Homeless people in this case are very vulnerable. Money should not define a person, but it comes to show that money sadly, does to have a tremendous impact on how a person is treated. Veterans coming home from war to live on the streets is unfair and inhumane. People need to step up to give humans the opportunities they

    Read More

  • Functional Analysis Of Homelessness In America

    706 Words  | 2 Pages

    If the homeless do not have a function in society they cannot compete for the resources available, but if we give them back their purpose they will have an equal opportunity to the resources they are due. The homeless- and most people in poverty- are in an endless circle of disadvantage, since there are no jobs available they cannot establish a place of residence and with no place of residence they cannot get a job or show previous work experience. Even if they have the skills that qualify them for a job they will not be able to take the next step and become a valued member of society once more. Many of the homeless population are not homeless by choice, many have lost the only job in the household, many are military veterans that have not assimilated back to civilian life, and some are homeless due to natural disasters like Hurricane Katrina. "It can happen to anyone of us. A hurricane, earthquake or wildfire that is out of control can destroy our home within minutes. We must never say never when it comes to the possibility of being homeless, especially when we consider the impact that natural disasters have. Worldwide natural disasters render middle class people near poverty and the poor,

    Read More

  • Homelessness In Society: Alienation Of The Homeless In America

    1920 Words  | 4 Pages

    At any given time, approximately 600,000 homeless survive at the front door of America. They are sleeping in parks, living in cardboard boxes, sitting on street corners, and resting under bridges. Terrible hunger gnaws at their stomachs as they search for food. Society labels the homeless as useless and worthless, but they are not. They are children, grandmothers, grandfathers, mothers, and fathers that need a place to sleep, eat, and live. What does society do to help? Nothing. Society hurries home from work, shopping, and leisure, worrying about who will win the next football game. Society is not worried about where their next meal will come from, where they will sleep, or where they will be tomorrow. Although it is difficult for society not to feel discomfort at seeing homeless people, it is the homeless who pay for the way people feel about them. Alienation of the homeless in America is a direct result of injustice, health issues, and societal attitudes; however, solutions are available to society as they are obligated to all of their citizenry, including the homeless.

    Read More

  • The Homeless in Canada

    2623 Words  | 6 Pages

    “Homeless is more than being without a home. It is tied into education needs, food, security; health issues both mental and physical, employment issues, etc. Don’t forget the whole picture.” (“Boxed In” 2005 pg. 108)

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Anna Quindlen's 'Homeless'

    843 Words  | 2 Pages

    People in America tend to think that a shelter is best for the homeless, but most of these people do not go to shelters for a reason. For example, in paragraph 7, on page 191, Anna says, “certainly some prefer to do so because they are emotionally ill, because they have been locked in before and they are damned if they will be locked in again.” These homeless people can have emotional or physical problems preventing them from going. Also, people will criticize the homeless and not look at these people as humans. People do not see the homeless as regular humans, instead they just criticize them. Even if they do not know the situation. I also look at these people differently. I feel sorrow for them and think they should find a shelter to live in like most Americans. This is the stereotype of the homeless people. We all think that they aren’t normal and should find a shelter to get help. Finally, Americans always look over the fact that they need help, but we shouldn’t go to drastic measures to help them. I will pass hundreds of homeless people, and helping them will never even cross my mind. Sometimes I won’t even notice them when I walk past where they are sleeping. A lot of people are too selfish to help a person in need. Even if that person is begging for help, most people still won’t help them. People should just put the

    Read More

  • Misconceptions About Homelessness

    1778 Words  | 4 Pages

    ?Over the past year, over two million men, women, and children were homeless? in America. (NLCHP) Homeless people face an intense struggle just to stay alive despite the fact that society turns its head from the problem. The government makes laws that discriminate against homeless people, which make it, illegal for them to survive. The mistreatment of homeless people is an issue that is often ignored in our community. When you see a homeless person on the streets how do you react? Do you turn your head and ignore them? Do you become angry that they are living on the streets? Do you feel frightened and avoid the situation all together? Or do you see these people as human beings and treat them in that way? Homeless people are ?subjected to alienation and discrimination by mainstream society?. (NLCHP) Most alienation and discrimination comes from the lack of education about homeless people. There are numerous untrue myths about homeless people. Many people believe that homeless people ?commit more violent crimes than housed people.? (NLCHP) The reality is that homeless people actually commit less violent crimes than people with homes do. Dr. Pamela Fischer, of John Hopkins University, studied arrest records in Baltimore and discovered that even though homeless people were more likely to commit non-violent and non-destructive crimes, they were less likely to commit violent crimes against people. (NLCHP) The crimes that these people are committing are necessary to keep them alive. These crimes include sleeping, eating, and panhandling. Making it illegal to perform necessary daily activities in public when homeless people have no where else to go makes it impossible for homeless people to avoid violating the law. (NLCHP) Another myth about homeless people is that they do not work and that they get their money from public assistance programs. A study done in Chicago discovered that ?39% of homeless people interviewed had worked for some time during the previous month?. (NLCHP) Many of the people who do not work are actively trying to find jobs, but are discriminated against by the work force. In an interview done at the River Street Homeless Shelter I found many people who have experienced this discrimination. ?People can?t get a job without an address. When they use the shelter?s address they get turned down.? (Mike) Speaking...

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of The Restorative Justice System

    1320 Words  | 3 Pages

    Crime has always been associated with factors such as poverty, and research shows poverty leads to certain types of crimes such as organized crimes and robbery and in the process of committing these crimes people also land up committing assaults and murders. In a research of 34 studies of violent crimes 97 present of it turned out to be committed by individuals who are in poverty or who are in poor socioeconomic conditions. (…) we as a society fail to understand that the one of the main cause of crime is bad socioeconomic conditions. To reduce crime, we need to provide people who are living in poverty or bad socioeconomic conditions with jobs, food, housing and address their mental health issues or drug issues if they have any. But unfortunately instead of being helped they are retributed and incrated for their crime without addressing their issues and problems.

    Read More

  • Poverty And Homelessness

    596 Words  | 2 Pages

    Homelessness has been seen throughout the world for generations upon generations. The word homeless is usually referred to as someone who is without a home and typically living on the streets. This being said, they have no fixed address, without a roof over their head, nowhere to go, and/or are displaced. When talking about homelessness the term poverty also comes into play. Cleary these two things go hand in hand because poverty is known as the state of being extremely poor. When funds and resources are not readily available people have no choice but to be in poverty and thus may be some causes of homelessness. According to the national student campaign against hunger and homelessness, this problem in America is effecting affecting every age, ethnicity, religion and both urban and rural communities. Last year it was reported by this campaign that 3.5 million people were sleeping in parks, shelters or their cars (National Student Campaign against Hunger and Homelessness, 2013). The rising cost of food, rent, and other necessities is harming the well being of Americans and the choices...

    Read More

  • Solutions to Poverty

    1333 Words  | 3 Pages

    For economic factors, low wages would be the variable that would lead to poverty. Families that receive low wages can barely support their living expenses. Thus they would not have enough money for programs that would aid their children’s education. Some families think that crime has better incentives than working a low paying job and thus crime could be put in as an economic factor that leads to poverty. Not having enough money for programs like education leads to the ind...

    Read More

More about Summary Of Criminalization Of Poverty By Dennis Prager

Open Document