Similarities Between Dr Jekyll And Mr Hyde

902 Words2 Pages

Though very different in terms of tone and genre, Robert Louis Stevenson’s The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde and Oscar Wilde’s The Importance of Being Earnest are similar in that they provide meaningful commentary on the conflict between social identity and personal desires through their depictions of characters who experience great difficulty in conforming to the responsibilities and expectations of high class Victorian society. In their respective literary works, Robert Louis Stevenson and Oscar Wilde use Henry Jekyll/Edward Hyde, and Jack Worthing and Algernon Moncrieff as vehicles to convey the trivial and or ever-changing nature of social identity when it is confronted with one’s inescapable personal desires.

The Importance …show more content…

While this lifestyle would be quite desirable for the average person, Jack Worthing seems to view the pressures of upper class society as overwhelming. He expresses this in the following passage: “When one is placed in the position of guardian, one has to adopt a very high moral tone on all subjects… who lives in the Albany, and gets into the most dreadful scrapes” (Earnest 1738). In an attempt to escape his responsibilities and the stress that comes with them, Jack adopts an alternate identity, allowing him to change his name (to Ernest), his personality, and by extension his social image. For a while, this works marvelously. However, Jack’s deception eventually begins to catch up to him when Cecily insists on meeting the alter ego he has created. This leaves Jack with the need to find a feasible way to make his alternate identity disappear. It seems however, Jack experiences the most pressure through Lady Bracknell and her insistence on denying Jack the privilege of marrying her daughter, Gwendolyn, unless he can produce proof of his high class origins. The pressure is specifically applied when Lady Bracknell says “... I feel …show more content…

Jekyll creates his alter ego, Mr. Hyde, as a means to introduce much more excitement and pleasure into his life, albeit with vastly different results. However, the critical difference between Dr. Jekyll’s and Algernon’s situations lies in Dr. Jekyll’s internal battle for dominance. Throughout the course of The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, Dr. Jekyll experiences great difficulty in balancing the responsibilities that come with his highly respected social image with the dark desires that constantly haunt him, but ultimately Dr. Jekyll succumbs to the pressures set on him by society and to his urges, despite the potential risks they pose. In Dr. Jekyll’s full statement of the case he writes, “I knew well that I risked death;... But the temptation of a discovery so singular and profound, at last overcame the suggestions of alarm” (Strange Case 1710). This passage highlights Stevenson’s idea that one’s social image should come second to his or her personal desires. This is supported by how Dr. Jekyll had full knowledge that indulging his desires presented the possibility of death, yet he continued with the experiment anyway and deemed this risk to be “worth it,” leaving its potential effects absent from his mind. While Dr. Jekyll’s situation is an extreme example, the internal struggle for dominance he experiences shows the potential effects that bottling up one’s desires and having too much focus on social image can have on a

Open Document