Overtoun Bridge Pathos

1345 Words3 Pages

There are things in this world that are simply beyond explanation; Like the fact that hundreds of dogs have jumped to their deaths from the same exact spot on the Overtoun Bridge since the last sixty years. It is reported that an average of one dog per month jumped off the bridge since the 1960’s and some of them would jump again after surviving the 60-foot fall. The documentary “Overtoun” directed and written by Samuel Horta, informs its viewers about the Overtoun bridge in Dumbarton, Scotland and tries to bring light to the occurrences happening there. The director tries to persuade the audience that the events occurring on the bridge have no connection to the supernatural through the use of pathos and logos. The documentary also implies …show more content…

The research Horta based his conclusion on is flawed in my opinion, in the experiment conducted by a canine specialist, ten dogs from different breeds were used to determine if the scent of male minks would make them sporadically chase them, during the test eight out the ten dogs blindly ran after the scent. According to me the sample size of ten dogs used in the experiment is too small to validate its claims. According to Jane Fryer from thedailymail.co.uk, the dogs have always jumped from the same side of the bridge, dogs shouldn’t care about which side to jump from considering that minks could potentially live on both sides around the bridge. The dialymail.co.uk is one of first newspapers to catch onto the story of the Overtoun bridge and over the years have published sevral articles about it. Furthermore, there are twenty-six thousand minks in Scotland and quite a few other bridges as well if the director’s conclusion was accurate we would be seeing similar occurrences throughout Scotland and the world. Another oddity about the mink theory is that the dogs who survive the jump climb back up the bridge and jump down again, the scent of the minks should be strongest at ground level why would the dogs need to climb back up just to be back in the same area they were in. Although the director offers a reasonable explanation behind the occurrences happening at the Overtoun bridge he does not provide enough evidence for me to accept his conclusions as there have to be other factors at

More about Overtoun Bridge Pathos

Open Document