Evolution of Nationhood and Nationalism in the US

1018 Words3 Pages

The definition of nationalism, according to Anderson, is an “imagined impersonal community, defined by common history and perceived by distinctiveness, that is believed to exercise the collective right to sovereign control over a given territory.” Over the last 200 years, the United States has grown larger and stronger with every change, and with that, the understanding of nationhood and nationalism in the US has changed within the constraints of this definition. In the beginning, nationhood was very different. It was elite driven. The united states was built on immigrants brought together with the idea of building a free nation. This could be described by the elite theory, which states that elites are aspiring to nationalism and lead the movements. …show more content…

Various races and ethnicities, while they may feel experience discrimination, don’t experience institutionalized discrimination. - they struggle against one another at times and against majority ethnicities, but there is never a legal hierarchy. The US is an unranked system, where honor and prestige are fluid, which is a key definition in an unranked system according to Horowitz. The United States has a unique quality in that it is made up of so many different types of ethnicities. An American can maintain that national identity without having been born in the United States, and still identify with various ethnicities. The United States is by no means made up of one ethnicity. The United States is accepting of all different types of attributes, categories,and dimensions that various groups may identify with and considers them all American (granted they are legally a citizen). Even though in practice there are certain ethnicities that have historically been ranked higher than others, the ranking has been fought against. Also, Horowitz states that “politics are always an issue and relative group worth is always uncertain,” which is a definite attribute in American society. We did experience segregation and institutionalized racism in the past against native americans, blacks, and the Japanese, but there has been a lot of change and that institutionalized racism was temporary and not something anyone is proud of. This is why I would argue that the United States has an unranked ethnic group system. The ethnicities may have conflicts against each other, but no one stays about the rest. On a side note, it is important to clarify that in the definition of ranked and unranked ethnic systems it states that just because a race or ethnicity is the majority, it does not mean it is ranked above another

More about Evolution of Nationhood and Nationalism in the US

Open Document