How Can A Streetcar Named Desire Be Read By Students?

1407 Words3 Pages

The play A Streetcar Named Desire written by Tennessee Williams is renowned for its controversial elements that cause many respected adults to question whether the play should be read by students. Some instances in the play that occur cross the line between raising awareness about and issue and corrupting the morals of the reader. Set in New Orleans in 1947, A Streetcar follows the story of Blanche as she is reunited with her sister, Stella, and meets her gruff, disagreeable, brother in law, Stanley. As Blanche is mentally and physically abused by Stanley, she also struggles with the burden of the death of her friends and family. Williams uses abuse, rape, patriarchy, homosexuality, and death to depict Blanche as the broken character he intended …show more content…

Towards the end of the play, Blanche is raped by Stanley, her brother in law. After this scene, time passes where the reader can infer that Blanche confesses to Stella about the rape, but is not believed. The play resumes as Blanche is being transported to a mental facility. “What have I done to my sister?” Stella states as Blanche is taken away, “Oh, God, what have I done to my sister?” (Williams 152). Williams includes this quote to show Stella's remorse on committing her sister to the facility. Because of this, the reader can infer that Stella is in denial about Stanley being guilty. Stella chooses to believe Stanley and betray her sister regardless of her true conscience that tells her otherwise. Additionally, in the last scene of the play, one can see Stanley lovingly comforting Stella as she sobs over Blanche. Here, Williams portrays Stella’s relationship as endearing and loving, regardless of Stanley's abusive nature. This would have a negative impact on students in a school curriculum because it encourages rape to go unreported. A study led by Richard Felton and Paul-Philippe Paré supported this idea when it came to the conclusion that “sexual assaults involving non-strangers are particularly unlikely to be reported” (Lotz 1). This relates to A …show more content…

For Ellen Sussman, a Californian mom and author, the decision to tell her teenage children about her past rape experience was a difficult and trivial one. While traveling, Sussman was raped by two foreign men who also beat her. It took her many years to overcome this tragic experience, and once her daughters came of age, she wanted them to be able to learn from her experience. She states, “Perhaps by telling them about my rape and my recovery I'm empowering them to venture out into the world with their eyes wide open” (Sussman 1). This relates to A Streetcar Named Desire because students reading about Blanche’s experiences can learn to identify the social cues of when they are in a dangerous situation, and become empowered. While this may be true for a small percentage of students, many teenagers reading Williams’ play could finish the last page feeling meek and defenseless. This occurs because of the stereotypical characterization of Blanche as weak and helpless. In the last scene of the play, Blanche is being taken away by a doctor to a mental institution. She grasps on to the arm of her doctor and wistfully states, “Whoever you are— I have always depended on the kindness of strangers” (Williams 153). This quote not only perfectly summarizes Blanche’s struggles throughout the play, but also shows

Open Document