G. I. Jane: Women In The Navy Combines Reconnaissance Team

684 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The issue of gender inequality

Issues Paper Rough Draft In today’s world, there is ever increasing pressure for further equality in many areas, particularly gender equality. In many ways, this is very good. People should not be judged by their race, ethnicity, gender, religion, political standing, or background; but rather, by their character, actions, and who they are as a person. Despite the importance of gender equality, is there a line that should, in fact, limit gender equality to some degree? In Ridley Scott’s film, G.I. Jane, the United States Navy is facing political pressure to integrate women into those occupations previously unavailable to females. Lieutenant (LT) Jordan O’Neill is chosen to serve in the Navy Combines Reconnaissance Team (a fictional special …show more content…

Jane brings up an issue of equality that has been a topic of discussion for decades: whether or not women should be allowed to serve in military ground combat and special forces roles. A history of women in the United States military dates back to the American Revolution. It was not uncommon for women to disguise themselves as men and fight alongside the males. More women served in World War I and World War II, primarily in nursing, administrative, and communications support roles (McGraw, et al., “Women in Combat: Framing the Issues of Health and Health Research for America’s Servicewomen,” 7). In 1948, the Women’s Armed Services Integration Act was signed, allowing women to serve as permanent members of the military, though in gender segregated units with a majority of occupations still closed to women. In 1976, the Department of Defense began gender integration of the service academies. (Wechsler Segal, et al., “The Role of Leadership and Peer Behaviors in the Performance and Well-Being of Women in Combat: Historical Perspectives, Unit Integration, and Family Issues, 28). In 1993, women were allowed to serve as fighter pilots, but in 1994, the Department of Defense excluded women from ground combat roles. The topic of gender integration continued to be a heated issue, sparking the release of G.I. Jane in 1997. The role of women in combat has drastically changed during recent conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan. Modern warfare no longer has a true “front line,” and many women have actually been “in combat.” This has necessitated recent changes in the military. Women were allowed to serve on board submarines beginning in 2011. In January 2013, then Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta removed the 1994 ban on women in combat, with intentions for full integration as of January 2016 (McGraw, et al., 8). Current Secretary of Defense, Ash Carter, declared in December 2015 that all combat roles would be open to women beginning in January 2016. Despite the move

Show More
Related

  • Women in the New York Navy Yard During WWII

    494 Words  | 1 Pages

    Beginning with the aggressive recruiting methods utilized to bring them in, and ending with the return of men from the war -- especially veterans -, women became extremely active in the working force during World War II. This was evident at the Brooklyn Navy Yard, where four thousand and six hundred women were employed. Even though they remained employed for up to six months after the war, eventually men did return to their positions, leaving only women veterans still qualified to hold a position there. However, the focus of a speech on this matter by Dr. Sparr was the activity that occurred during these women's employment.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Megan H. Mackenzie's Essay 'Let Women Fight'

    986 Words  | 2 Pages

    Within Megan H. Mackenzie’s essay, “Let Women Fight” she points out many facts about women serving in the U.S. military. She emphasizes the three central arguments that people have brought up about women fighting in the military. The arguments she states are that women cannot meet the physical requirements necessary to fight, they simply don’t belong in combat, and that their inclusion in fighting units would disrupt those units’ cohesion and battle readiness. The 1948 Women’s Armed Services Integration Act built a permanent corps of women in all the military departments, which was a big step forward at that time. Although there were many restrictions that were put on women, an increase of women in the U.S. armed forces happened during

    Read More

  • Rebecca Zissou Women Warriors Analysis

    628 Words  | 2 Pages

    This is because women have proved themselves to be of equal capability as men, and they have already been serving in combat positions alongside men, though not legally. Fortunately, the Pentagon was able to see this and on December 3, 2015 Secretary of Defense Ashton B. Carter announced that they would be officially allowing women to serve in all combat positions in the U.S. armed forces. This change in military policy will allow more representation for women in the armed forces but it also represents a major leap towards gender equality, further closing the gap between men and

    Read More

  • Women in Combat: The World War II Experience in the United States, Great Britain, Germany, and the Soviet Union

    744 Words  | 2 Pages

    Thousands of men enlisted and were sent to fight during World War II. However, many people are unaware of the role that women played in the war, not only in taking over the jobs that would have previously belonged to men at home, but also in combat. D’Ann Campbell’s article “Women in Combat: The World War II Experience in the United States, Great Britain, Germany, and the Soviet Union” explores this topic. Campbell argues that the role of women in combat has been overlooked in the study of the Second World War. She states that, in fact, “the history everyone has learned about the greatest and best-known war of all times has airbrushed out the combat roles of women” (323). In the article, Campbell compares the methods of the four major powers involved in the war, the Unites States, Great Britain, Germany, and the Soviet Union, of involving women in combat, and what those methods used say about gender roles in that particular country.

    Read More

  • Women and the Draft

    813 Words  | 2 Pages

    With society’s past and present it is apparent that women are still not equal even if they have the title. Men are observably stronger and have a different mentality in situations than women. This is not to say that women should not be in the military but they should have the choice that way they can accept the responsibility and train themselves mentally and physically to achieve the responsibility and respect needed to fight for our country.

    Read More

  • The Role Of Women In The Invisible War

    735 Words  | 2 Pages

    Since the resolution of World War II, the United States has been involved in over fifteen extensive military wars. Recent wars between Iraq and Afghanistan are being fought over several issues which affect women in both the United States and the other nations. While the military is often thought of a male dominated institution, women are present and affected all throughout the system as soldiers, caretakers, partners, and victims. Transnational feminists often fight against war due to the vulnerability that is placed on women during times of war. Despite often being overlooked, there is no doubt that women are heavily included in the devastating consequences of war.

    Read More

  • Women in the Military: The Combat Exclusion Law

    1366 Words  | 3 Pages

    In 1973, women began to grow in numbers in the All-Volunteer Force implemented under President Nixon. “In February 1988, Department of Defense (DoD) codified the Combat Exclusion Policy by adopting the ‘Risk Rule’”, (the DoD Combat Exclusion Policy) pg. 21, 22. The change of the feminine role in the civilian population has forced a review of their presence in the Armed Forces. These roles reviewed after the onset of the Exclusion Law in “1967 when the statutory strengths and grade limitations were lifted” (…GOA, pg 4) as well as in 1978 when positions available to women were expanded (…GOA). In 1992 and 1993 when the “Defense Authorization Acts were implemented, congress revoked the prohibition of women’s assignments to combat aircraft… and in January 1994 the ‘Risk Rule’ was rescinded” (the DoD Combat Exclusion Policy) pg 22. With the 1994 change in the “Risk Rule”, assignments were available for females in all services to participate in all available positions. Exceptions of “assignments to units below the brigade level whose primary mission is direct ground combat” (the DoD Combat Exclusion Policy) pg 22(ibid) were put in place.

    Read More

  • Women During World War II and Beyond

    1520 Words  | 4 Pages

    Women played a crucial role during World War II, both with the production of war materials, and keeping our country from sliding back into a depression. Since the 1940s, women have continued to struggle to prove that they can do the same jobs that a male worker can do, and should get paid the same amount for it. Equal pay for women has continued to be an intensely debated subject since World War II, when women stepped up to fill the void in the workforce that men left behind when they courageously fought to defend our country.

    Read More

  • Women and the Draft

    984 Words  | 2 Pages

    "Update: Women in the Military." Issues and Controversies. Facts On File News Services, 29 May 2007. Web.

    Read More

  • Empowerment and Recognition: A Look into WASP

    508 Words  | 2 Pages

    Sherri Smith had several purposes in writing the novel. The first one is to recognize the women who were a part of the Women Airforce Service Pilots (WASP). In the author’s note, she actually addressed this was indeed one of her purposes. They became a part of the army in 1942, and had many valuable accomplishments to it.One that they wrote about being B-29 Superfortress, that two women test flew. The men called it a ‘Widowmaker.’ They made several trips before having to stop by a male commanding officer. Eventually the WASPs were allowed to become officers. The next purpose was to prove that you may have hurdles to achieve your dreams. Ida Mae, the protagonist, was both black and female ‘two strikes against her,’ as the book puts it. However,

    Read More

  • Women In War By Carol Cohn

    734 Words  | 2 Pages

    The purpose of Carol Cohn’s article “Women in War” is to explain why there is a divide between women and the military regardless of their contributions to and key roles in war. Cohn argues, because of the gender coding of characteristics, institutions such as the military have been established in such a way that not only rejects characteristics of femininity but also preserves masculinity. Cohn employs logic, fact, and the reasoning of experts in their own respective fields to answer why such a separation between the military and women exists.

    Read More

  • Women In War Industries Summary

    975 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Women in War Industries” provides the perspectives of two women who worked in industry during WWII. Inez details her background, describing her family’s wealth and that before the war she had neither the need nor desire to work. She stated that when her husband’s rubber-matting business closed, she and her children moved from Ohio to Seattle to live with her parents (Sauer and Lewis 229). The interview then continues to describe her experience while working as a tool clerk at Boeing, stating that she worked seven days a week and was exposed to all sorts of new people (Sauer and Lewis 230). She also explained that her parents had deep disdain for factory workers, and that she had to overcome their judgment in order to work (Sauer and Lewis).

    Read More

  • Women in the Military

    1465 Words  | 3 Pages

    The story of America’s military woman can be traced to the birth of our nation. During the American Revolutionary War, the 18th and 19th centuries, where women served informally as nurses, seamstresses, cooks, and even as spies and were subject to Army’s rules of Conduct. Though not in uniform, these women shared soldier’s hardships including inadequate housing and little compensation. Women have formally been part of the U.S Armed Forces since the Inception of the Army Nurse Corps in 1901. In 1973 the transition to the All-Volunteer Force marked a dramatic increase in the opportunities available for women to serve in the military. As of September 30, 2009, the total number of active duty women in the U.S was 203, 375, and women made up 14.3 percent of the U.s armed forces (Robinson). Women are a crucial role in c...

    Read More

  • Masculinity In Military

    1234 Words  | 3 Pages

    This paper has thus far outlined how not only the United States’, but militaries in general, are inherently gendered and favor men and masculinity. These structures have been used in the past and today to keep women out of the military and/or out of combat positions. Even though Secretary Carter opened up all combat positions in the U.S. Armed Forces to women in December 2015, there are still gendered mechanisms in the military preventing women from achieving equality with their male counterparts, in more ways than one. This paper will now address just one of these current effects, arguing that the gendered military institutions are preventing women from the ability to register for the draft.

    Read More

  • Women in the Military

    1113 Words  | 3 Pages

    Should women be allowed in the military? My answer was at first a resounding “no.” However, once I started my research, my opinion changed. In 1948, Congress passed the combat exclusion law that prohibited women in the Air Force, Marines, and Navy to hold combat positions; however, the Army can assign these duties as they see fit (Schroeder). Some people assume that Americans are not ready to see a woman wounded or killed in war; however, there are female police officers that are wounded or killed daily (Schroeder). How can we rationalize that a woman has the right to die protecting our local communities but not our country? If a person chooses to be in a combat field, and can pass the physical demands required, gender should not be an issue. The arguments of physical differences and cohesion among the troops are valid arguments but not substantial enough to prevent women from serving in frontline combat roles within the military.

    Read More

More about G. I. Jane: Women In The Navy Combines Reconnaissance Team

Open Document