Ethical Issues In Savior Siblings By Virginia Bernhagen

564 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Legal issues with organ donation

Your ethics about how you handle your children is morally wrong, a child is a gift that is bestowed upon not a last option to save the life of its other siblings. Yes, as a parent it is understandable that you would do anything to save your child. To you it might have been seen as the right thing to do at the time but you may have not considered the after affects it would have on the family. In the article “Savior Siblings” by Virginia Bernhagen demonstrates cases similar to yours. Also, with information provided by lawyers Amber Kaimer and Daniel Kolmel to provide you with the facts of your wrongdoings. To begin with you can not force your daughter Anna to forcefully give up her kidney to her sister Kate if she is against it because, stated …show more content…

While this was what you were trying to do, you neglected your other two children by just being focused solely on Kate. “Although I am nine months pregnant, although I have had plenty of time to dream, I have not really considered the specifics of this child. I have thought of this daughter only in terms of what she will be able to do for the daughter I already have…Then again, my dreams for her are no less exalted; I plan for her to save her sister’s life.” (Picoult 119). Shows that from the beginning, that you’ve only seen Anna as Kate’s last hope to save her and that you really never considered anything more about her. When the author states, "My parents tried to make thing normal, but that's a relative term. The truth is, I was never really a kid. To be honest neither were Kate and Jesse. I guess maybe my brother had his moment in the sun for the four years he was alive before Kate got diagnosed, but ever since then, we've been too busy looking over our shoulders to run headlong into growing up. You know how most little kids think they're like cartoon characters -- if an anvil drops on their heads they can peel themselves off the sidewalk and keep going? Well' I never once believed that. How could I, when we practically set a place for Death at the dinner table?" (Picoult 9). Explains that you had neglected your kids and robbed them from the childhood that they should have had despite

Show More
Related

  • Symbolism In Sarah's Key

    259 Words  | 1 Pages

    In Sarah’s Key by Tatiana de Rosnay, there is a central theme of past choices determining future sorrow and loss created through the use of symbolism which appears multiple times in both Sarah and Julia’s individual journeys. Although Julia listens to the pleas of Bertrand pushing for the abortion of the fetus as a baby would ‘kill him,’and be the end of their marriage, Julia chooses to reject his request. She had the baby prematurely but nevertheless was happy.“This child meant so much to me. I had fought for her. I had not given in. She was my victory.” Her happiness came at a price however as shortly after the birth Bertrand summoned up the courage to tell Julia that he loved Améle and that there would have to be a divorce. The baby symbolizes

    Read More

  • Social Commentary in Blood Brothers by Willy Russell

    1241 Words  | 3 Pages

    The play, Blood Brothers by Willy Russell, is a twisted tale of two brothers born on the same day and from the same womb, yet they live in two entirely different worlds.

    Read More

  • Moral Reasoning by Laura Kaplan

    1218 Words  | 3 Pages

    The primary issue that was addressed in the Journal article, “Moral Reasoning of MSW Social Workers and the Influence of Education” written by Laura Kaplan, was that social workers make critical decisions on a daily basis that effect others. They influence their clients’ lives through giving timely and appropriate funding to them and their families, through deciding should a family stay together or should they have a better life with another family, or connecting the client with appropriate resources that can enhance their lives. The article addresses data from an array of students from various universities. The researcher posed these questions; “Would social workers use moral reasoning (what is right and what is wrong) more prevalent if it was taught through an individual class during your MSW graduate studies, or if you obtain any other undergraduate degree, or if the ethic course was integrated in the curriculum?”

    Read More

  • Blood Brothers Act 1 Essay

    1151 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Act 1 of the play Blood Brothers, we learn about the different circumstances certain characters are put in such as Mrs Johnstone, who is forced to give one of her twins away to her employer, Mrs Lyons. We learn throughout act 1 about how this decision impacts all of the characters in one way or another. We are also introduced to the two main characters, Mickey and Edward who are the twins which were separated at birth, and who soon become best friends, ‘Blood Brothers’, after meeting for the first time.

    Read More

  • Renada's Case Study

    1143 Words  | 3 Pages

    Dear colleagues, please note a sensitive case has been brought to us to deliberate on. David, who is a father, has requested to donate his second kidney to his daughter, Renada. What is more, she urgently needs to undergo a kidney transplant. As you know, the matter has gained the attention of the entire country, and it is our duty to ensure that we solve the case with utmost care using the applicable principles of bioethics. Renada’s case is very challenging and sensitive because we have to balance two critical aspects. Either we agree to grant Renada’s father his wish of saving his daughter and possibly harm his health in the process, or we go against the request and save his life and millions of taxpayers’ money that would be used for his dialysis after the operation. I would like to draw your attention to the respect of autonomy as per the principles of bioethics, which lays emphasis on the practice of informed consent. According to the case at hand, David Patterson, who has been sentenced to 12

    Read More

  • Patricia MacLachlan’s Sarah Plain and Tall - Comparing Book and Movie

    574 Words  | 2 Pages

    The complication between characters is especially shown in Anna and Sarah’s relationship. In the movie Anna is mad about Sarah coming to stay for a month. However, in the book she says “I wished everything was as perfect as the stone. I wished that Papa and Caleb and I were perfect for Sarah” (21). In the book Anna has no trouble liking Sarah, but in the movie Anna has a hard time letting go of her real mother and will not let Sarah get close to her. It is not until Sarah comforts Anna after a bad dream and tells her “when I was ten my mamma died” (which was not told in the book) that Sarah and Anna have a close relationship. After Sarah and Anna reach an understanding, Sarah tries to help Anna remember her mother by putting her mother’s candlesticks, quilt, a painting, and her picture back into the house. They also put flowers on her grave together. However, Anna and Sarah’s relationship is not the only one that takes a while to develop.

    Read More

  • Medical Ethical Case Study: Mrs. Noble And Abortion

    1597 Words  | 4 Pages

    In this medical ethical case study, there are two high-class parents with two normal children. Let’s call the family the Noble family. Mrs. Noble gave birth to a premature boy in the late fall of 1963. After the child was born, Mrs. Noble immediately and independently made a decision to not keep the child as soon as the diagnosed her newborn’s monogoloid (Down syndrome). Once the decision was final, the hospital did not attempt to override the decision or seek court order. Soon after, the child was separated into another room and was left for 11 days with no food. My purpose for gathering the information about Mr. and Mrs. Noble is to analyze her critical dilemma between keeping her child and having an abortion. Through the process of analyzing

    Read More

  • In Search of the Good Family by Jane Howard

    1043 Words  | 3 Pages

    A family is a group of people who love, respect, and help one another no matter the circumstances. Family members are not confined to people you are related to or have married; they can include friends, acquaintances, etc. In this second paragraph on page 283, Howard states, “If our relatives are not, do not wish to be, or for whatever reason cannot be our friends, then by some complex alchemy we must try to transform our friends into our relatives.” This shows that blood relatives should come first in the matter or family, but there are circumstances in which this is untrue. For example, there are several family members that my immediate family, consisting of my mother, father, and myself, no longer associate with, nor do we plan to. My aunt (my mother’s sister) recently started heavily drinking alcohol again. This causes her to become volatile and vicious, and consequently takes it out on everyone who tries to assist her. She began to yell at my mother for no reason and called her a plethora of rude names accompanied by several cuss words. I found out about this rampage on my own and wanted to make her realize what she was doing was wrong, so I told her that she had no right to call my mom any of these names. We got into a bit of an argument, and she took it all out on my mother yet again. My uncle heard of this news and took my aunt’s side, fully understanding the entire story. Needless to say, we refrain from speaking to them for fear of them causing more drama. As Howard suggested, we have made friends with our neighbors and have adapted them into fitting in with our definition of family. We love them, we respect them, and we help them on a daily basis.

    Read More

  • Divided Loyalties Case Study

    1030 Words  | 3 Pages

    This deontological ethical theories realizes that there is good and bad in every moral situation and focuses more on the outcome than actually doing the act. For the sake of this scenario the moral situation is going to be phrased as: Ought the physician to go around the father’s wishes to help the daughter’s medical situation? The relevant facts of this scenario is the effect it has on the father and the daughter, and how it will effect each one. The father could be devastated by donating a kidney he never wanted to donate in the first place, or the little girl could lose her life if the father does not donate his kidney. To sort the effects of the two people look at both of the outcomes of a decision. First, look at the two options and two outcomes of each. Option A is yes, tell the man’s family about his match, so the little girl will get her kidney transplant. The good in this situation is that more than likely the kidney transplant will save the daughter’s life. The bad in this situation is to break the dad’s option to make his own choice and give him complete control over his body. On the other side, Option B is to not tell the family, and look for a cadaver kidney. The good in this situation is the physician is not overstepping the father’s wishes to make sure his family pushes him into giving the girl his kidney. The bad in this situation is the little girl has a higher chance of not surviving. Deciding between the lesser of two evils saving the girls life becomes more valuable than overstepping the father’s wishes. Therefore, deducting an answer using Act Utilitarianism means that the physician will tell the rest of the family that the father is the correct tissue match, and they will pressure him into donating a

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Donating Children

    1550 Words  | 4 Pages

    Many people consider this process as unethical, but it should not be; it is in some way gruesome, but it also is sufficiently adequate. Some cons of having a donor baby are: the donor sibling is not able to give its consent, the procedures are at times painful, the donor child may feel unwanted, and the donor child can resent the sick sibling. On the other hand, some pros of having a donor baby are: the family will be happy to have a new sibling, the donor child can be treated better than the sick sibling, a bond is created between the donor and the sick child, the donor child could feel extra special for saving the sick child, and the sick child is eventually saved. People speculate that by having a donor baby, the donor baby will be an “accessory” to the parents and that the parents will love the child only when a donor is needed. Donor babies are human beings and they are usually loved even more because, in most cases, they saved the sick

    Read More

  • The Soul Game Monologue

    1661 Words  | 4 Pages

    Motherhood is a burden. A necessity, yes but still a burden. I have one person that makes it all better. And that’s my only child, Alyssa. She’s in sixth grade, 11. Which made me twenty years older than her. She was a generally happy child. And she stayed that way. Until Violet came into play of course. All I wanted was for Alyssa to be happy. But of course. We couldn’t even keep that to ourselves.

    Read More

  • Theme Of Innocence In The Hunger Games

    1517 Words  | 4 Pages

    We see this through the main protagonist Anna who states “I was engineered, born for a particular reason. A scientist hooked up my mother’s eggs and my father’s sperm to make a specific combination of genes. He did it to save my sister's life.” Because Anna is the only genetically able donor in her family, she goes through many serious medical treatments to help her older sister Kate, eventually she requires a kidney. Kate asks Anna to do her a favour, she asks Anna to set her free. “Tell them you’re important too, tell them you want to play soccer, tell them you want to cheerlead” Kate says to Anna “They’ll never believe me” Anna replies “Yeah they will. And you wanna know why? Because it’s the truth.”. This quote is from the scene where Kate helps Anna to feel comfortable making the decision not to donate her kidney just because her mother says she should. Cassavetes has done this to show us that Anna will no longer be undergoing surgeries blindly like a child would. Anna’s circumstances meant that she lost her childhood innocence earlier than she probably would have otherwise as she begins to think about herself, what she’s been through, and the repercussions it could have for her in the future. Another way of looking at this theme in relation Anna’s situation is through the possibility that she didn't have a childhood innocence to lose. Because Anna has always known that she was born to save Kate and because of all of the surgeries and emotional trauma that this knowledge came with, Anna has grown up with a heavy weight on her shoulders. This would mean that Anna never had any sense of naivety about the world around her because she has been dealing with very adult problems her whole life and therefore never had any ‘childhood

    Read More

  • Analyzing Maura Dickey's Article 'Who Will Save The Savior'

    438 Words  | 1 Pages

    Initially, using spare organs is ethically wrong because it is taking away from the infants life and health. In Maura Dickey’s artical it describes the scientific notation to the society of what a savior sibling and the use of taking gentically designed organs out of one and using them for an other. Out of context this violates human decencey and also is morlally wrongfull of doing to a person that isn’t able to state his/her own actions yet. By doing this action it is consequentally wrong doing of a person to have a savior but this also shows the reasoning being of infants that are being talked about and knowing that they can’t have a voice of opion for themselves. There for consequentally wrongfully done.

    Read More

  • The Qualities of a Good Sibling: An Evaluation Essay

    702 Words  | 2 Pages

    Siblings should always there for each other, willing to drop anything to help one another. Having a strong bond between siblings is one that can never be replaced. Even through tough times, siblings can overcome their differences. Most importantly, siblings provide each other with a built-in best friend. These are all important principles for a good sibling. I believe I am a good sister because I fit the criteria for what every sibling should meet.

    Read More

  • What Is A Memorable Day Essay

    1328 Words  | 3 Pages

    I took care of her for two years as if she was part of my family, with respect and compassion. The last week of her life, Alice was regretting quickly that she needed a hospice’s nurse coming to give medications and singing to her. Her son told me that she was ready to go, but wouldn’t let go because he was always around. So one day he told me that he needed to go to the dry cleaner. I ask him not to go, but he said to not worry. I was sitting by Alice’s bed side, watching TV, and while she was sleeping breathing heavily, I was holding her hands and singing the song: “You are my sunshine, my only sunshine….” I turned my head to watch TV for a second and turn back to her still holding her hands, and she wasn’t breathing. I jumped out of the chair and I started panicking and asking her: “please wait for Barry.” After few seconds he came and saw that I was agitated and he said: “don’t worry Anna, that’s what she wanted, I am ok with that.” He called the nurse that came to wash and prepare her. I was still in shock and afraid to touch her, but the nurse told me that we still needed to respect her, so I helped wash and dress Alice. For few days I slept with the lights on in the closet near my side of the bed. Alice’s son, Barry became a really good friend of our family. He became like a father to

    Read More

More about Ethical Issues In Savior Siblings By Virginia Bernhagen

Open Document