Essay Comparing The Seventh Man And The Man In The Water

570 Words2 Pages

Tragedy of Water This past week in English class we read two short stories: “The Seventh Man” by Haruki Murakami and “The Man in the Water” by Roger Rosenblatt. Both short stories are similar and different in many ways. The two stories are similar in ways like; the structure, settings, and moods of the two stories. The ways they are different are the characters, plot, the themes, the point of view, and resolutions. The two stories are similar in many ways. One way they are similar is the structure of the two stories. Both stories are told from mainly from flashbacks looking back on tragedy considering someone died from each story. The setting of “The Seventh Man” is on the beach during typhoon season in Japan while “The Man in the …show more content…

The plot setup was different for both short stories, for “The Man in the Water” the man in the water sacrificed his life to let others be rescued before him, and putting others before him shows he is a hero. In “The Seventh Man”, K. dies by being completely swept away by a tsunami, and although the seventh man could’ve helped him and possibly rescued him, he did not prevent K. get taken by the typhoon. The point of view were different in “The Man in the Water” and in “The Seventh Man”. In “The Man in the Water” it was third person omniscient and told by a narrator, meaning that the story is told from the authors point of view but get everybody’s thoughts not just one person. In “The Seventh Man” it is told in third person limited from the point of view of the seventh man, meaning that the seventh man’s mindset is used throughout the whole story since he is the one telling it. The theme is also different for both short stories. In “The Man in the Water” the theme is heroism because that man in the water showed a great deal of bravery and thoughtfulness toward others. In “The Seventh Man” the theme is fear and the best way to handle it is to face it instead of turning our backs on it. The resolutions in both the “Man in the Water” and “The Seventh Man” are different because in “The Seventh Man” the man gets over his fear of the water after his friend gets taken away by the tsunami, but in “Man in the Water” the man dies and nobody claimed to know who he

Show More
Related

  • Similes In The Seventh Man

    831 Words  | 2 Pages

    Fear is consuming. It can take over your mind and constantly prevent you from experiencing all life has to offer. Concurring your fear will take most, if not all the power away from it. “The Seventh Man” elucidates the effects of fear and how it keeps one from reaching their full potential. Whether you chose to fight or fly, the impact will be as great as you let it. In “The Seventh Man”, Murakami uses similes, foreshadowing and symbolism to develop the theme that it is better to face one's fears then to turn one's back on them.

    Read More

  • Epiphany

    820 Words  | 2 Pages

    Nothing, nothing about anything. He didn’t understand the reasons for things or for people, it was all senseless, absurd. And [he] started to laugh” (Calvino 1). The comparison between the epiphanies of both short stories reveals the relationship amongst the similarities and differences regarding theme, symbolism and setting. Most importantly, comparing the themes of both epiphanies reveals they can simultaneously be similar and different.

    Read More

  • True Grit Vs Old Man And The S

    985 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Old Man and the Sea, by Ernest Hemingway, a simply written novel of an old man's singular struggle, while trying to catch a fish, against forces of the sea overpowering him and True Grit, by Charles Portis, a gripping western, placing you in the middle of the action during a girl's quest with two other men to get revenge for her father's murder, are two works united in several ways. Many similarities throughout both works appeared evident. Plot, theme, and characterization categorize those similarities.

    Read More

  • New Beginnings in The Grapes of Wrath and Broken Ground

    936 Words  | 2 Pages

    Thus, both novels, full of tragedy and sorrow, began with the promise of new land, new beginnings and a better life, but all three were impossible to find within the pages of these novels. In the end, it was broken relationships, broken families, broken communities, but most importantly, broken dreams and broken hopes that were left on the final pages of both woeful, yet celebrated, stories.

    Read More

  • Comparing Short Stories “The Sniper” and “The Most Dangerous Game”

    1005 Words  | 3 Pages

    Both stories are one of a kind and deserve to be read. They share both common and uncommon ideas, but in the end, both are nice.

    Read More

  • The Man In The Water Summary

    592 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the article it talks about how it was a extremely ordinary day for the main character and he had no indications that today would be his last day on earth. With that in mind, this man chose to be courageous not knowing the consequences of his actions. "Every time they lowered a lifeline and flotation ring to him, he passed it on to another of the passengers". When the water was to take this mans life, it was unbeknownst to him, but he still had the courage to pass the rope to save another. Courage is not a attitude that one might claim in just a day. It is a characteristic that is made, created, and molded as you use it. With unfathomable courage, this heroic man passed the rope one last time, knowing he would never lay a hand on it again. Imagine the character he would have had to possess in order to utilize his agency, without hesitation, by passing on his chance of life to someone he didn't even

    Read More

  • Comparing The Sniper and Ambush

    425 Words  | 1 Pages

    Comparing The Sniper and Ambush There are many similarities and differences between the two short stories The Sniper and Ambush. Both short stories have very interesting settings that take place in different places. Ambush and The Sniper also have very similar characters but with very different outlooks and feelings. The two short stories have very intriguing but very similar themes. The settings in the short stories The Sniper and Ambush are very different but have a few similarities.

    Read More

  • The Seventh Man Essay

    529 Words  | 2 Pages

    Moral repair is a word of many meanings. One may say it's "restoring or creating trust and hope in a shared sense of value and responsibility". Others will say "Moral repair is the process of moving from the situation of loss and damage to a situation where some degree of stability in moral relations is regained." Others will have different perspectives on the true meaning of moral repair and whether someone has achieved it. In Haruki Murakami’s short story “The Seventh Man”, the narrator speaks of a tragic event that took the life of a close childhood friend leaving the narrator with a weight of guilt and need for moral repair. Murakami illustrates the narrator’s internal self battle and struggles throughout the story which gives the reader

    Read More

  • Compare and Contrast of “Journey to The West” and “Tartuffe”

    857 Words  | 2 Pages

    both stories shared similar ending and moral which is receiving enlightenment in first hand. "The

    Read More

  • Theme Of Guilt In The Seventh Man

    891 Words  | 2 Pages

    How would you feel if your friend died and it was believed in your mind that the death was your fault? It’s hard to forgive yourself. Even if it is not your liability, you feel guilty. You feel survivor’s guilt. The narrator of “The Seventh Man” should forgive himself for his failure to save K. K. was a young boy who didn’t hear the call of his name. The narrator should not be at culpability for the miscommunication between him and his best friend. If he tried to save K. for even a minute longer both of them could be gone. Then who would feel the guilt? His parents for letting them go down to the beach? There will always be someone who feels solely responsible for a death that was close to them personally. Many people

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Araby And A & P

    545 Words  | 2 Pages

    In this essay I will discuss the short stories A&P by John Updike and Araby by James Joyce which share several similarities as well as distinct differences between the themes and the main characters. I will compare or contrast two or more significant literary elements from each of the stories and discuss how those elements contribute to each story’s theme.

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Young Goodman Brown And Where Are You Going

    1272 Words  | 3 Pages

    These two stories hold components that are clearly differentiating, yet similar in the meantime. Having every story been composed in a third-individual account structure, the onlooker

    Read More

  • Summary Of The Man In The Water By Roger Rosenblatt

    937 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the article, “The Man in the Water” the author, Roger Rosenblatt, shows humans potential selflessness. After a plane crashes into the ocean, one man, the hero of the story, saves the lives of many before saving himself. As the rescuers were handing down the floaties to bring people to safety, every time one was given to this man he risked his life and handed it to someone else. Every time that he decides to save someone else he is one step closer to dying, and he knows that too, but instead he helps those in need around him. Although in the end he did not survive, what he did had effects on those watching. It showed people that any person could be a hero. The man in the water was a man with courage, and no fear, he sacrificed his life for the life of many who may not have survived if it wasn't for him or what he had done. While nature was against him and the people he fought against it to let those people live the rest of their life. In the article, the author, Roger Rosenblatt demonstrates the potential heroism and

    Read More

  • Click Clack And Rattle Bag And The Tell Tale Heart

    1166 Words  | 3 Pages

    They heard! I was certain of it.” The characters aren’t developed very much in both of the stories, however, their characteristics are different. The main characters in both of the short story are two people, but the protagonist is developed innocent and the antagonist is unrighteous in “Click Clack and Rattle Bag”, “I reached over and tousled his hair.” “I would have pulled away, then, if I could, but small, firm fingers pulled me forward, unrelentingly, into the dark.” show that the young man wants to take care of the kid, but the kid uses his good looks and tone and finally kills the man. And on the contrast, the

    Read More

  • Comparison of Araby and The Garden Party

    1260 Words  | 3 Pages

    The struggles both characters face demonstrate character development and contribute to the themes of the stories. Both short stories prove to be literally effective in that they disclose the main themes at the outset of each story. Although the themes may alter over the course of the stories, they are clearly defined in their respective introductions.

    Read More

More about Essay Comparing The Seventh Man And The Man In The Water

Open Document