How Did The Donner Party Lead To Tragedy

2104 Words5 Pages

The Donner Party Poverty-stricken emigrants floated around America. In the East and Midwest, people had nothing. There were no jobs, no homes, and no money. But in the West, they had everything. California and Oregon were full of riches and opportunity; anyone could succeed there. So desperate pioneers sacrificed their livelihoods to move westward, and the Donner Party was no exception. The group of ninety travelled to Utah, only to have the cruel wrath of nature ruin their destiny when crossing into California. Forty-eight died during the winter of 1846 in the Sierra Nevada, an anomaly to the expected success of western travel. The Donner Party exemplifies how assumptions of mass prosperity can lead to tragedy. During the mid-1800s, …show more content…

The majority of the pioneers took the classic route to Fort Hall, and later made it safely to California. While logic drove most to Fort Hall, eighty-seven people, the Donner Party, chose to take the new route of Hasting’s Cutoff. The route was discovered by Lansford W. Hastings, and he encouraged settlers to take his new route through the publication of his book Emigrants Guide to Oregon and California. It was rumored that Hasting’s Cutoff shortened the trip by roughly three hundred miles. While the Donner Party was beginning their travel through the Cutoff, Hastings had been leading a group of sixty-six wagons through his trail. In August, the party discovered a letter left on the trail from Hastings. In the letter, Hastings warned them that the canyon roads further along the trail were in poor condition, and recommended the settlers followed the mountain courses instead. Curious for more information, the Donner Party sent three members, Reed, Pike, and Stanton, to catch up to Hastings. Hastings explained to Reed how to get the party through the mountains, and Reed then proceeded to follow the route himself to later guide the rest of the party. Once Reed returned, the “Donner Party unanimously decided to travel across the mountains in a more direct line to Salt Lake” (History of the Donner Party, a Tragedy of the Sierra, McGlashan). The trip through …show more content…

Everyone was suspicious of one another, and was willing to sacrifice the elderly and the weak to protect their own survival. The horses were weak and the food and grass scarce. When the tensions were high, tragedy struck. John Snyder was a popular member of the Donner Party, but when he began to beat one of Reed’s oxen, Reed snapped. Snyder repeatedly hit Reed with the end of his whip, but then Reed quickly “pierced [Snyder’s] left breast, severing the first and second ribs and entering the left lung” (History of the Donner Party, a Tragedy of the Sierra, McGlashan). Pioneers often inflicted their own justice when travelling, and the Donner Party was no exception. However, George Donner had gone ahead of the rest of the company, and he was the leader of the group. With no other option, the party settled on banishing Reed without his family. Reed left the company and caught up to George Donner, where he decided to advance to Sutter’s Fort with a teamster, Walter Herron. After Reed left the Donners, the rest of the party caught up to them. The party continued to endure terrible conditions, and after attacks from natives, the party finally finished crossing the desert. When the company reached Truckee River, they encountered Stanton, one of the men who had left earlier in search for assistance. With him he brought food, mules, two Native American guides, and news of Reed’s safety. Reed and Herron

Open Document