Dmitri Karamazov Analysis

518 Words2 Pages

Dmitri Karamazov is the first-born son and the only child from Fyodor’s first marriage with Adelaida. Like Fyodor, Dimitri waste large amounts of money on evenings occupied with champagne, women and whatever amusement he can buy. He contacts his family when he discovers himself in need of his inheritance, which he believes is with his father. He resides a life between sin and redemption and unlike his father, he sincerely senses remorse for his sins and steadily begins to hope that his soul can be liberated through suffering. When he’s arrested for the murder of his father, Fyodor Pavlovich, the interrogation of his guilt and innocence becomes a essential question about his identity - whether he has a good nature or not. Not only is he innocent of the crime, he …show more content…

According to Ivan, all adults, through one way or another have lost the innocence they had as a child and it can never be regained again. Ivan is distressed with losing his innocence; he believes that if he consents to a complex agreement of the unfair suffering of children, he will be giving up the last of his innocence. Dostoevsky’s theory is that if one can overcome a difficulty, one could see pure honesty within them. In The Brothers Karamazov, Ivan doubts his faith in God due to the suffering of children. Ivan tells Alyosha about an illegitimate child who ends up working for shepherds who don’t even allow him to eat the mash for the pigs. They overwork him until he becomes into a bitter human being. Ivan continues with a story about a seven-year-old girl, a "poor, defenseless creature"(Brothers Karamazov, book 5/ch 6) who is constantly beaten by her mother. I think Ivan is scared of another person becoming like his father. He doesn’t want anyone to go through what he went through as a child because he doesn’t want anyone to deal with the pain or neglect that he

Open Document