DBQ Essay: It's Time To Legalize Prohibition

670 Words2 Pages

Al Capone once said, “Prohibition has made nothing but trouble”. Many people, including Capone, viewed prohibition as an utter failure of the law. Criminals, law-abiding citizens, and governing officials opposed it, eventually leading to its repealment. Prohibition was enacted with the 18th amendment, discontinuing the legal use of alcohol. The prohibition era was inspired by the late 19th century “progressive movement.” Why did America change its mind about prohibition? America changed its mind about prohibition because crime spiked during prohibition. There was virtually nothing that could be done to enforce prohibition, and states and the federal government alike needed money.
America changed its mind about prohibition because crime increased dramatically. Document B shows exactly how crime went up during prohibition. In document B, the homicides per 100,000 population is portrayed in a graph format. Before prohibition in the year 1919, the murder rate was seven people murdered per 100,000 population. At the height of prohibition in 1933, that ratio grew to ten people per 100,000 population. Finally in post-prohibition 1940, six homicides were committed for every 100,000 people. Thus prohibition sparked a rise in crime. Document A shows a political cartoon created during the …show more content…

“Before prosperity can return in this country the budgets of local and national governments must be balanced. If the liquor now sold by bootleggers was legally sold, regulated, and taxed, the tax income would pay the interest on the entire local and national debt and leave more than $200,000,000 for urgently needed purposes”(Document E). If alcohol were legalized again, the government could collect an excise tax on it. The tax would solve the national debt problem and provide the nation with a surplus of funding. Overall, the eradication of prohibition could have provided more money for the federal, state, and local

Show More
Related

  • Assess The View That The Policy Of National Prohibition Case Study

    1972 Words  | 4 Pages

    The decline of alcohol consumption was partly an illusion due to the fact that it sharply increased by the penultimate years of Prohibition, suggested that the demand of alcohol was so strong, which led to the rise of organised crime, such as bootlegging, speakeasies and criminal gangs. Ultimately, Prohibition was not a healthy move because many people decided to turn to more dangerous substitutes such as heroin, hashish and cannabis. This had serious health consequences, such as addiction and shortened life expectancy. Due to the immense geographical size of America, prohibition was difficult to enforce, which also led to corruption. The limited number of underpaid police officers were usually bribed by illegal establishments to remain silent. Willoughby’s point is agreeable that the failure of prohibition was largely due to the fact that it was over-ambitious, resulting in many problems in America, that led to its repeal in

    Read More

  • Prohibition: Why Did America Change Its Mind?

    549 Words  | 2 Pages

    The final reason America changed its mind about the Prohibition was because repealing the Amendment would create economic opportunities. If the liquor that was being sold by bootleggers was legally sold it could be taxed. The tax income could pay the interest on the entire local and national debt, and the US would be able to save the rest of the money (Doc E). Since at the time the US was in a depression, the money was in dire need. Repealing Prohibition seemed like the best solution to help the people and the

    Read More

  • How Did The 18th Amendment Change America

    632 Words  | 2 Pages

    In 1920 following the ratification of the 18th amendment the country became dry. The 18th amendment made it illegal to manufacture, sell, import, or export drinking alcohol. It would stay this way for a little more than a decade, which became known as the prohibition. Prohibition was a way to clean up the cities and improving the conditions of the US. Prohibition was approved because drinking was thought be a drag on the economy and the leading cause for some of the country's problems such as corruption, child abuse, crime, and unemployment. Fourteen years later in 1932 America had changed its mind and it was repealed. So what changed? The American people had changed their minds about the 18th amendment because crime had increased,

    Read More

  • American History: Boom to Bust: 1920-1929

    903 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the beginning of the twenties America was in the midst of an economic boom, people were happy- World War I was over and Americans were rich. But by the end, because of prohibition, and in large part because of the stock market crash, the American economy quickly declined into the Great Depression. During this time the 18th Amendment- prohibition- was passed. Prohibition's supporters were initially surprised by what did not come to pass during the dry era. When the law went into effect, real estate developers and landlords expected rents to rise as saloons closed and neighborhoods improved. Theater producers were expecting an increase in customers as Americans searched for new ways to entertain themselves, ways that did not involve alcohol. But this did not happen. Instead, there was a decline in amusement and entertainment industries all over the United States. Some restaurants even failed, as they could no longer make a profit without legal liquor sales. On the whole, the initial economic effects of Prohibition were largely negative. The closing of breweries, distilleries and saloons led to the elimination of thousands of jobs, and in turn thousands more jobs were eliminated for barrel makers, truckers, waiters, and other related trades. One of the most profound effects of Prohibition was on government tax revenues. Before Prohibition, many states relied heavily on excise taxes in liquor sales to fund their budgets. Almost 75% of New York’s revenue came from liquor taxes, but with prohibition in effect, all that reven...

    Read More

  • Prohibition DBQ Essay

    790 Words  | 2 Pages

    During the late 1800’s and early 1900’s, many saw alcohol as a cause of instability among communities. To counteract the effects of alcohol on American society, The Temperance Movement, Prohibition Party and many others sought to enact anti-liquor laws that would prohibit the sale, manufacture, and transportation of alcohol. On January 19, 1920, the Eighteenth Amendment had taken effect and a nationwide ban on alcohol was enacted. This was thought of as a solution to the many problems that America had at the time, but it only made matters worse. The American society had been greatly affected by the Eighteenth Amendment in many negative aspects such as increasing crime and violence, worsening the economy, and much more.

    Read More

  • Prohibition Synthesis Essay

    1504 Words  | 4 Pages

    Although both the coming and the arrival of the Great Depression did have some influence over the decision to repeal the Eighteenth Amendment, other factors played a part – most importantly the simple fact that prohibition didn’t work. In the early 1920s and throughout the 1930s America suffered through a period of economic decline, and because of this, the government in particular, was in need of funds to fuel its weakening economy. Taxation on alcohol would contribute towards the resources for relief, and prevent higher taxes in other areas of business which would only compound the situation. Each year the government was missing out on a sum of around $500 million which would be brought in by a tax on alcohol, and would significantly help America during the crisis. As well as this, an end to prohibition would eliminate the costs required to enforce it – an extra expenditure the government could not afford at this time. Economically, an end to prohibition would help strengthen the unstable situation in America: ending unproductive government spending as well as bringing new money into the system. Repeal of the Eighteenth Amendment would also meet social demands brought about by the crisis. Those facing hard times wanted to drink, and wanted an end to the law to allow them to do so more easily; thus the Great Depression added to the support for social groups already campaigning for its repeal. Both the economic and social effects of the Depression make it an important reason for the repeal of the Eighteenth Amendment, a concept supported by historian Joseph Gusfeld. However, this aspect, rather than directly causing the repeal of national prohibition, was the accelerating factor which catalysed the passing of the Twenty-first Ame...

    Read More

  • The Backlash of Prohibition

    807 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...ment. In addition, the government lost the tax revenue generated from these business enterprises as well as from the sale of alcohol. The revenue generated from alcohol had amounted to one-third of the yearly tax revenue collected prior to prohibition. Actually, it is a fallacy that drinking increased during prohibition, though the middle class exposure to drinking did increase. The major argument to prohibition was the power it created for organized crime and the need for tax revenue in the throes of the Great Depression. With the country in dire need of revenue, in 1932 politicians supported a platform calling for the repeal of the act. The anti-prohibition platform became the death knell for prohibition. (Two changes needed in this sentence.) In1933 the 21st amendment to the Constitution was ratified, which repealed the 18th amendment and the end of prohibition.

    Read More

  • Prohibition - 'The Noble Experiment'

    884 Words  | 2 Pages

    Prohibition was designed to rid the country of businesses that manufactured, sold, and or distributed alcoholic beverages. The eighteenth amendment made it a violation of the constitution to do and of the before mentioned. This was a crime punishable up to the Supreme Court. The original idea was that Americans as a whole were unhealthy, there was too much crime and corruption, and that people were being burdened by excess taxes that poorhouses and prisons were creating. What happened? The cheap alcohol being illegally produced killed more Americans, crime and corruption went up, taxes were raised to fund the law enforcement needed to enforce prohibition, and the prisons became overcrowded.

    Read More

  • Economic and Social Effects of Prohibition

    1180 Words  | 3 Pages

    “Prohibition did not achieve its goals. Instead, it added to the problems it was intended to solve.” On 16th January 1920, one of the most common personal habits and customs of American society came to a halt. The eighteenth amendment was implemented, making all importing, exporting, transporting, selling and manufacturing of intoxicating liquors absolutely prohibited. This law was created in the hope of achieving the reduction of alcohol consumption, which in turn would reduce: crime, poverty, death rates, and improve both the economy, and the quality of life for all Americans. These goals were far from achieved. The prohibition amendment of the 1920's was ineffective because it was unenforceable. Instead, it caused various social problems such as: the explosive growth of organized crime, increased liquor consumption, massive murder rates and corruption among city officials. Prohibition also hurt the economy because the government wasn’t collecting taxes on the multi-billion dollar a year industry.

    Read More

  • The Success and Failure of the Prohibition

    978 Words  | 2 Pages

    America chose to drop the support for the Prohibition because of all the negativity it brought about. The Prohibition had good intent, but it ultimately failed. Criminal activity rose rapidly and the economy fell harshly. America originally supported the Prohibition, but it eventually turned against it. The Prohibition lasted nearly fifteen years, but its legacy lives on.

    Read More

  • The Hopes and Realities of Prohibition

    806 Words  | 2 Pages

    The hopes of the prohibitionist were dreams of a healthier and more successful nation. Their dreams were spun from the idea of shutting out the alcohol industry and enforcing large industries and stressing family values. The eighteenth amendment consisted of the end of sales, production, transportation, as for importation and exportation of intoxicating liquors. Their imaginations were large and very hopeful. The prohibitionists felt that alcohol is a slow poison of their community. They felt that if the liquor industry was shut out that Americans would spend their hard earned money in the clothing, food, and shoe industries therefore boosting the American economy. Many felt, “Seeing what a sober nation can do is indeed a noble experiment and one that has never yet been tried, (Crowther, 11) Prohibition was a test of the strength of the nation and an attempt at cleaning up societies evils. These reformers denounce alcohol as a danger to society as well as to the human body. Some ethnic hopes of prohibition was to regulate the foreigners whose backgrounds consisted on the use of alcohol for religious purposes. And try to enforce an American valued society upon them. Many reformists felt that ending the use of alcohol would protect American homes and families. They felt that alcohol use was the root of their family’s destruction. Many women felt that their husbands would waste a lot of their income on the purchase of alcohol and not on family needs. Alcohol was often known as a “poison, or sin”. Another hope for the eighteenth amendment was to reduce the crime and death rate. Many people felt that drunkenness was the cause of many of the nations crimes. Prohibitionist felt very passionately on their cause and were often called “dry’s.” They felt their battle was justified and that, “it is manifest destiny that alcohol will not survive the scrutiny,”(Darrow and Yarros, 20).

    Read More

  • Prohibition in the Great Gatsby

    1346 Words  | 3 Pages

    Prohibition was passed to eradicate the demand for liquor but had the inadvertent effect to raise the crime rates in American. Robert Scott stated, “Prohibition was supposed to lower crime and corruption, reduce social problems, lower taxes needed to support prisons and poorhouses, and improve health and hygiene in America” (Scott 2). As the demand for alcohol increased, people began to find new methods to mask the production and consumption of liquor. It became easier to break the rules. Organized crime blossomed and many law-abiding citizens turned into criminals. Court and prisons systems became over run and the drinking habits of American's changed for the worse.

    Read More

  • The Cause And Effects Of The Prohibition Era

    719 Words  | 2 Pages

    Due to the causes above and consequences of Prohibition precisely its unpopularity, FDR promised to repeal the 18th Amendment as a way to gain more supporters. The want for the repealing of Prohibition led to his win in the 1932 election in a landslide. The main long-term effect was the creation of organized crime. Prohibition indirectly created a secret network of criminals that were able to sell and distribute the material illegally. Before this period there was no such thing as organized crime, but ever since then, it has existed. This journey of the country through the ban of alcohol actually led to more people drinking alcohol. Another short-term effect of the revoking of Prohibition was the increased revenue gained as a result of taxation on alcoholic beverages. Although the barring of alcohol was arguably a good idea, failed enforcement and little long-term, after the 18th Amendment’s ratification, support made Prohibition a detriment to the US economy and the country in

    Read More

  • The Prohibition Amendment

    1823 Words  | 4 Pages

    Prohibition was positive because it helped to reduce alcohol-related consequences. The amendment was influential in reducing deaths and illnesses caused by the consumption of alcohol. Between 1915 and 1925 the death rate from cirrhosis, a chronic liver disease caused by alcoholism, declined by almost fifty percent (Dills and Miron). Additionally, Prohibition caused death rates from alcoholism to fall by eighty percent from pre-war levels by 1921 (McNeil and Mintz). This decrease in deaths and illnesses was important because it meant that the negative effects that alcohol had on the health of the country were diminishing because of Prohibition. Despite this positive impact, the lack of regulation on alcohol increased the amount of poisonous industrial alcohol that was distributed resulting in over fifty-thousand deaths by 1927 as well as hundreds of thousands of paralysis cases (Lieurance 65). Even though Prohibition was helping to reduce deaths and illness, it was also...

    Read More

  • Failure Of American Prohibition In The 1920's

    1391 Words  | 3 Pages

    When the 18th amendment was implemented into American society in January of 1920 organized crime went through a major boom. This was mostly because in this time people who drank any sort of alcohol were considered criminals. During the early 1920’s jobs were scarce and people needed money to support their families.A lot of American

    Read More

More about DBQ Essay: It's Time To Legalize Prohibition

Open Document