Comparing Shutter Island And The Babadook

637 Words2 Pages

Subduing ourselves from feeling certain emotions or feelings is something that all human’s subconsciously do as a way to escape from the reality of what is going on. Shutter Island and The Babadook portray the theme of crime through the main characters of the films. In Shutter Island, Teddy Daniels is a main character that has repressed emotions about his wife murdering his kids, and then him killing his wife. He has created an alternate reality that is more comforting to himself, where he is a US marshal solving a missing persons case on Shutter Island. Teddy has convinced himself that his wife died in a fire, which shows that fire is representative of the alternate reality that he has created for himself. At whatever point there is smoke …show more content…

Its apparent that whenever water is nearby, he gets closer to reality. Water seems to drip from everywhere in his dreams and throughout his whole adventure. His wife drowned his children, so water show’s what really happened instead of thinking that his wife died in a fire, which is the opposite to water. So fire and water are representative of the theme of exploring reality in that they are physically opposite and they represent he opposing sides between reality and fantasy. Near the end of the film Teddy says “Which would be worse, to live as a monster or to die as a good man?” This show’s that Teddy has accepted his crime and the proper reality of the situation. “To live as a monster” Is his way of saying that if he accepts his guilt and becomes sane, he will be living as a monster because of his crime. In his alternate reality he is a “Good man” and that’s why when he says “to die as a good man” If he chooses to believe in his alternate reality he will be lobotomised and effectively die believing in it. This show’s how Teddy’s crime has impacted his life, which cause him to repress his memories and end up with mental illness. The second text that shows the theme of crime is The

Open Document