Captain Jonsen's Bad Choices

903 Words2 Pages

“It is in your moments of decision that your destiny is shaped” (Tony Robbins). Indeed, the decisions you make on a daily basis affect your destiny. Good decisions lead to a good destiny, but bad decisions leads to a tragic destiny. Furthermore, Captain Jonsen who is the tragic hero in Richard Hughes’s novel A High Wind in Jamaica makes a good example of how bad choices lead to a tragic destiny. Jonsen’s decisions that he made after the children aboard his ship cause the “…nail[s] in the coffin...” which is his final destiny (page 117). Throughout the tragedy, the three most damning choices Captain Jonsen makes are, not following the Clorinda so he can return the children to Captain Marpole, caressing Emily’s face, and leaving Emily alone in …show more content…

In the beginning Captain Jonsen had the right idea when he wanted to return the children to the Clorinda. The narrator claims, “…Captain Jonsen looked his way again, the Clorinda, with every stitch spread in the starlight, was already half a mile leeward,” he reveals that while Jonsen was distracted the Clorinda was already long gone leaving him with the children (85). In addition, Jonsen could have turned around and followed the Clorinda to return the children, but Jonsen says that it “…was out of the question” (85). Little did Jonsen know this decision would cost him his life. Furthermore, these previous statements from the narrator creates the idea that Jonsen had no idea that this decision would cause so much chaos. Ultimately, once the children were aboard the schooner they caused one problem after another which effected Jonsen tremendously. Jonsen’s decision not to follow the Clorinda to return the children led to tragic events resulting in Jonsen being hung for the children’s …show more content…

The pirates decided to tie the Dutch Captain up and put him in the cabin with Emily for her to watch. In addition to Emily being injured she now is expected to watch over a man. The narrator claims, “She screamed and screamed: but there was no awakening from this nightmare,” reinforcing our belief that Emily fears men after the incident with Jonsen (174). Also, makes clear that Emily is terrified of the Dutch Captain as well. Captain Jonsen’s mistake was that he left Emily alone with the Dutch Captain defenseless and scared. Therefore, when the Dutch Captain came after her, she got scared and killed him. When the narrator says, “Emily lay in the bunk below, her eyes shut—conscious again, but her eyes shut,” he suggests the idea that Emily was pretending to be asleep so that the pirates would not think she was the one who killed the Dutch Captain. Ultimately, since Captain Jonsen put Emily and the Dutch Captain alone in the same room, Emily becomes scared and murders him. Eventually, leading to Captain Jonsen taking the blame for the murder of the Dutch Captain. Captain Jonsen taking the blame for the death of the Dutch Captain makes him the tragic hero. Jonsen being a tragic hero is a result from him making choices that caused his destiny though he didn’t directly commit the crime that he was punished for. Although Jonsen tries to good he never succeeded in making

Open Document