Brief Comparison Of C. S. Lewis And J. K Rowling

1913 Words4 Pages

C. S. Lewis and J.K Rowling are two very popular authors that are acknowledged worldwide as great scholars and creative thinkers. They have written several books that appeal not only to children, but people of all ages. Lewis has been widely acclaimed for his fictional work, The Chronicles of Narnia and Rowling’s for her Harry Potter Series. Though Lewis and Rowling have two completely different writing styles and create their own unique storylines and characters, they tend to overlap on ideas and themes, such as creating a secondary world and incorporating the use of magic. Through characters such as, Petunia Dursley, Hermione Granger, Susan, Lucy and Edmund in Lewis,’ The Chronicles of Narnia and Rowling’s, Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s …show more content…

She is too young to take on the roles of a traditional housewife. She is instead, seen to be gradually developing into the category of “women.” When Hermione is first introduced in the text, she is portrayed as annoying and very smart. The minute she meets Harry and Ron on the train, she asks them several questions, such as where they will be living then confidently leaves telling them that they “better change” as she “expect[s] that [they] be there soon’” (Rowling 113). Instead of being shy and innocent like most young girls, she is strong and very independent. She defies female stereotypes and is not afraid to speak her mind or act when necessary. It is the same with the White Witch in The Chronicles of Narnia, as she says to the dwarf, “do as you’re told. Tie the hands of the human creature” (Lewis 119). In the White Witch’s kingdom, the rules are reversed, as she controls the dwarf and in a sense “owns” Edmund. Women in Lewis’ stories are generally expected to submit to their role as wives or else give up their own femininity in order to partake in the more “masculine” tasks, such as battle. The White Witch challenges what it means to be a woman and does not fall under the category of “man” or “woman” and because of this, she is viewed as an outsider. Overall, both novels prove that there are consequences to defying societal gender norms, as Hermione is friendless and disliked by her peers and the White Witch ends up being killed by

Open Document