Escape from Reality: Melvin Burgess's Smack versus Holly Black's Valiant

1352 Words3 Pages

Escaping from reality is something that most humans desire. Some people cannot handle their existence and they revert to drugs or self-destruction as a way to escape for a short time or even permanently. In Smack by Melvin Burgess and Valiant by Holly Black, the main characters try to escape their reality through drugs and self-destruction. Teenagers need an outlet of hope when there is none in an endless sea of darkness. Valiant arguably offers a more hopeful outcome for young adults because of its message, character depth and likeability while Smack offers no hope for its far-fetched characters and oftentimes over-the-top storyline. Melvin Burgess forwardly says in the author’s note of Smack “The book isn’t fact; it isn’t even faction. But it’s all true, every word,” the reader’s first impression is of the book’s authenticity. The claim of truth in “every word” is likely more in the idea of the story, and the fact that yes, someone, somewhere went through this, but not this exact scenario. Teenagers may be able to sympathize with Tar’s reasons for running away, he is in an abusive situation, and has every right to want to get away from it. Gemma, however, is a rebellious teen with overprotective parents. Is this really a reason to run away from home and become addicted to drugs? It seems like a child who decides to protest against a D.A.R.E. (Drug Abuse Resistance Education) lesson to me. She is a fickle character, until she finds heroin, and then she becomes reasonable. This is backward, and irritating. Tar is a weak character that the reader can sympathize with at times because of his constant struggle with the drug. The reader then loses that sympathy as he fails at his fight to come clean. He begins as a nice, polite boy wh... ... middle of paper ... ... different abusive situations. Each story has a general message to teenagers that it seems to get across well; life is rough. I think that Tar should have been given a better chance at survival in Smack, but I think he should have had to work for it. I also think that Val should have had to work a little harder for her life to get back to normal in Valiant. She was able to come right back into her life like nothing really happened, when so much did. These books depict real problems and Val is rewarded and given hope for her good deeds, while Tar suffers for his bad decisions and given no hope at all. When dealing with situations such as these, teens should be shown a way out of the black hole. Works Cited Black, Holly. Valiant: A Modern Faerie Tale. New York : Simon & Schuster, Inc., 2005. Print. Burgess, Melvin. Smack. New York: Avon Books, Inc., 1999. Print.

Open Document