Descartes' Conception of, and Arguments for, the Real Distinction
A modern, casual observer on a skim of the Meditations may be simple enough to conclude that, by virtue of its rather appended appearances, curiously scattered throughout the sixth and final meditation, Descartes' concept of the real distinction is just that, an appended curiosity of little consequence in Descartes' argument. Yet, when we flip back to the front of the work, we realize that its full title is, in fact, Meditations on First Philosophy in Which the Existence of God and the Distinction between the Soul and the Body Are Demonstrated. Clearly, then, Descartes found a great deal of value in this seemingly tacked-on discovery. So what exactly did Descartes mean by the “real distinction?” Simply stated, it is Descartes' distinction between the mind and the body. The two, he believes, are substances that can be separated completely (at least in conception), such that a mind can persist without a body, and vice versa. Descartes elaborates tw...
... middle of paper ...
...the mind is completely non-thinking, then it is also completely non-existing. Without the body, the mind cannot exist. Additionally, according to Descartes own definition that substances that cannot be explained without recourse to another are actually the same substance, it is a natural conclusion that since mind cannot be explained without the body, the two are actually the same substance, and there is no real distinction. This means that, returning to the question of “At what point does the mind fuse with the body?” we can now see that the mind and the body come into being simultaneously by virtue of the fact that they are only one being, either casting doubt on Descartes' use of the principle of sufficient reason, or suggesting that God inseparably fuses mind and body at the exact moment of conception. Either way, there is no place for Descartes' real distinction.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Descartes’ Arguments for the Real Distinction of Mind and Body Descartes argues has three main arguments for minds and bodies being two different distinct types of substance. These are known as arguments for substance dualism and are as follows. * The Argument from doubt : Descartes argues that while he could pretend or think that he had no body and therefore did not exist in any place, he could not think or pretend he had no mind, as merely having a doubt that he had a mind proves that he does.... [tags: Papers]
1168 words (3.3 pages)
- Descartes and the Existence of Physical Objects In his sixth meditation Descartes must return to the doubts he raised in his first one. Here he deals mainly with the mind-body problem and tries to prove whether material things exist with certainty. In this meditation he develops his dualist argument; by making a distinction between mind and body; although he also reveals that the are significantly related. He considers existence of the external world and whether its perception holds any knowledge of this world.... [tags: Descartes]
669 words (1.9 pages)
- In Rene Descartes, Meditations on First Philosophy, he talks about the distinction between God and existence. This paper is going to argue that in Rene Descartes, Meditations on First Philosophy, Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan, both are contrasting how we know that God really exists and how we know what we perceive in this world actually exists as well. This essay will start by talking all about Rene Descartes and his ideas around the existence of God and life itself with everything living in it. Rene Descartes is putting forward an argument that everything we perceive in life is true when he says; “And thus I now seem able to posit as a general rule that everything I very clearly and distinctly p... [tags: literary analysis, rene descartes]
1125 words (3.2 pages)
- Rene Descartes, often times referred to as the father of modern thought, believed that our philosophy as humans should be based solely on reason. This meaning, that if something cannot rationally be explained, then it must be false. Descartes argued that by using reason to establish philosophy, two types of existents were present, necessary and contingent, and that one must first call into question their previous beliefs in order to gain a proper philosophy. This questioning of beliefs came to be known as the methodic doubt.... [tags: Epistemology, Mind, Rationalism, René Descartes]
1242 words (3.5 pages)
- Rene Descartes was a French Philosopher who wrote the book, Meditations on First Philosophy. There are six meditations, the last one is named, The essence of material things, and the real distinction between mind and body, in the sixth meditation. In the previous meditations he already conjectured that he had a mind because he is a thing that thinks and to think is to have a mind and to think is to also exist. Descartes believes that physical things exist because they are pure mathematics, and he can see them clearly and distinctly.... [tags: Mind, Ontology, René Descartes, Consciousness]
1055 words (3 pages)
- Descartian dualism is one of the most long lasting legacies of Rene Descartes’ philosophy. He argues that the mind and body operate as separate entities able to exist without one another. That is, the mind is a thinking, non-extended entity and the body is non-thinking and extended. His belief elicited a debate over the nature of the mind and body that has spanned centuries, a debate that is still vociferously argued today. In this essay, I will try and tackle Descartes claim and come to some conclusion as to whether Descartes is correct to say that the mind and body are distinct.... [tags: Cartesian Dualism, Mind-Body Problem]
1632 words (4.7 pages)
- Evaluate the argument that Descartes makes based on clear and distinct perception for the distinction between mind and body In arguing for the distinction between mind and body, Descartes seeks to show that the two are independent substances and can exist separately. It will be useful to outline Descartes’ argument based on clear and distinct perception by listing his premises and conclusion. The essay will then analyse each premise in turn, arguing that the argument fails because his premises are faulty.... [tags: Psychology]
2176 words (6.2 pages)
- ... Even if my body were to be only a product of my senses alone, I know for a fact that my mind, or soul, must exist in this universe. This leads to Descartes’s belief that he must exist. Because he has the ability to think he exists, that proves he has something of existence in at least the non-physical world. “I have convinced myself that there is nothing in the world – no sky, no earth, no minds, and no bodies. Doesn’t it follow that I don’t exist. No, surely I exist if it’s me who is convinced of something,” (Norman 341).... [tags: doubters, trustworthy, truth, inaccruate]
616 words (1.8 pages)
- Rene Descartes's View on God In 1996, songwriter Joan Osborne performed a song called "One of Us" that was nominated for three Grammy Awards. What made this song so successful and interesting were the powerful lyrics that basically asked, "What if God were a human being?" As she was writing the lyrics to "One of Us," she was wondering about God and how the world would be different if God did exist in real life and not just a supernatural force. You may be asking yourself, "What does this have to do with the seventeenth century?" Well, in the seventeenth century, there was a man, named Rene Descartes, who was interested in God and wondered about His existence. After an unforgett... [tags: Philosophy essays]
1315 words (3.8 pages)
- Foundation In Descartes Meditation VI Of the existence of material things, and of the real distinction between the real soul and body of man, he explains he reasoning for believing that the mind is better known than any body. Descartes states his reasoning through various assumptions that he has made in his search for knowledge. Descartes is a philosopher, who through thinking comes to these conclusions. In the reading of Descartes he interprets his understanding of how and why the mind is better known than the body.... [tags: essays research papers]
872 words (2.5 pages)