Essay on The Categorical Imperative, By John Stuart Mill

Essay on The Categorical Imperative, By John Stuart Mill

Length: 1263 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Essay #1:

In “The Categorical Imperative,” Kant makes arguments concerning moral value of an action (maxim/ rule of conduct), and urges that morality is the inborn quality, which determines actions. His argument is that motivation should determine action, without worrying for the results. His views suggest that if the motivation is moral, the actions would be morally correct, and that the results would be acceptable, regardless of others’ views and acceptance for such actions. Kant’s arguments, in addition to being complex and incoherent, sound very subjective and impractical.

John Stuart Mill’s arguments link happiness with morality. The author argues that individuals’ actions, moral or otherwise, aim to make them happy. If an action makes one happy, that action is moral, and such an argument may not be entirely true.

In "The Nature of Virtue," Aristotle talks about two types of virtues, with one relating to teaching and learning and the other with habit. Morality is a learning process. According to his arguments, morally ethical behavior is not a natural quality and that an individual is not born moral or otherwise.

In the "The Ethics of Care," Virginia Held talks about caring and emotions. The main point of the author is caring, suggesting that caring is value and moral. Fulfilling the needs of the cared ones and be responsible to the latter is moral. The author also talks about different emotions, including sensitivity and empathy, for instances. These arguments are also limit in terms of general application.

The arguments of Kant, Mill, Aristotle, and Help are dissimilar for several reasons. Yet, there is some overlapping. Differences wise, Kant’s and Aristotle’s views are nearly polar apart, as the former’s argument ...


... middle of paper ...


...h deeper. Mill’s ethical argument limits to happiness, and that happiness determines moral actions. This may not be entirely true. Likewise, Held’s argument of caring is also limited, in terms of application. On the other hand, Kant’s ethical arguments, if such are very deep thoughts, are also complicated and even incoherent. The applications of such thoughts may not be practical in day-to-day life and in diverse social composition. Relative to earlier mentioned three different philosophies on ethics and moral behaviors, Aristotle’s arguments on ethics and virtues, being reasonable and applicable even in today’s context, is truly remarkable, even if it may not be totally relevant to all the situations and social context.

Bibliography
Aristotle. Classics . Edited by W. D. Ross. 350 AD. http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/nicomachaen.2.ii.html (accessed March 07, 2015).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

John Stuart Mill And Plato 's Categorical Imperative Essay

- ... She knew her sister would have done whatever she’d asked and take the blame. This act not only earned her her father’s trust, it also weakened his relationship with her sister. Ridjie’s action were solely for her personal benefit. The possibility of how it could affect Sammy were the least of her concern. Additionally, Kant would also view Sammy’s action immoral. Although she lied to save them from a horrible punishment, she lied nonetheless. John Stuart Mill may not have shared Kant’s views....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Immanuel Kant, Philosophy]

Strong Essays
759 words (2.2 pages)

John Stuart Mill 's Morality Essay

- There are several ways of examining morality philosophically. John Stuart Mill provides some Empirical insight which focuses on consequences. Immanuel Kant views morality in terms of motives. These are the two I will be using to examine my moral dilemma. Before I can examine the implications of each moral view on the case, though, I must first define each view. Mill says you can find one thing that’s intrinsically valuable and all other values fall into place. That value, according to him, is happiness....   [tags: Immanuel Kant, Categorical imperative, Ethics]

Strong Essays
1149 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on John Stuart Mill 's Theory Of Morality

- Throughout the history of humanity, morals have been incorporated into everyday life. The first set of morals came from religion, which told people what to do and not do to go to heaven. To centuries, the morals established by the church had never been questioned. To analyze the kind of morals, present in humanities every day, philosophers identified the different types of ethical moral. Two of this philosopher 's theories would be defined to find the similarities and differences that impact humanity....   [tags: Immanuel Kant, Ethics, Categorical imperative]

Strong Essays
1319 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Immanuel Kant 's Categorical Imperative

- Immanuel Kant’s Categorical Imperative and John Stuart Mill’s Utilitarianism are two schools of thought that view morality differently. Both Kant and Mill understand and agree that some form of morality exists. They both recognize that the concept of morality applies to all rational beings and that an action can be deemed as moral or immoral based on reason. Despite being reasonably in agreement about what morality is; there are numerous important differences between Mill and Kant’s perception of morality....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Immanuel Kant, Utilitarianism]

Strong Essays
1759 words (5 pages)

The Universal Law Formula of the Categorical Imperative Essay

- ... Since everyone is lying to get what they want, communication becomes unreliable because people will no longer believe one another. In order for the man to deceive someone and get what he wants, the one he is deceiving must assume that he is telling the truth. However, the man is willing a world where it is impossible to deceive anyone, and therefore, deception cannot get the man what he wants. This is an example of a contradiction in conception. The maxim of deceiving others to get what one wants cannot be acted upon successfully when the maxim is universalized....   [tags: contradiction in conception, maxim]

Strong Essays
1053 words (3 pages)

Kant And Kant 's Categorical Imperative Essay

- Immanuel Kant was a famous German philosopher (1724-1804). His many philosophical writings influenced large population from all over the world. Even today, his works still form a major point of reference in research carried out in the modern world. His writings had a strong base such that they brought a new dimension in religion, law and history. Although all his writings were popular but Metaphysics of Morals was very influencing. Kant argued that our desires and emotions are categorically imperative, which means that they are conscience driven....   [tags: Ethics, Immanuel Kant, Morality, Philosophy]

Strong Essays
1165 words (3.3 pages)

Kant 's Categorical Imperative Essay

- Utilitarian thought and theory are based on the “Greatest Happiness Principle” which exclaims that actions are considered moral only when they promote universal happiness and the absence of pain. In this paper, I argue that Kant’s Categorical Imperative is superior to utilitarianism because Kant’s Categorical Imperative allows for actions to be judged case by case, as opposed of what’s considered to be the best for maximizing happiness. First and foremost, the Greatest Happiness Principle focuses on two main ideas: one’s actions and their resulting utility....   [tags: Morality, Immanuel Kant, Utilitarianism]

Strong Essays
1053 words (3 pages)

Kant 's Categorical Imperative Essay

- One constant between all cultures is the understanding that all lives will come to an end. Throughout one’s lifetime, virtue, character, and morality are sought, through different ideals and methods, with the overall endgame being the most ethical and desirable outcome possible. There are times, however, when an individual may feel like there is no hope of reaching a successful existence; therefore the act of suicide becomes a viable option. The decision to voluntarily take one’s life has always been a topic of discussion on ethical grounds....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Immanuel Kant, Philosophy]

Strong Essays
901 words (2.6 pages)

John Stuart Mill And Immanuel Kant Essay

- There has been an ongoing debate regarding torture and ethical reasoning to determine when or if its ever ok. Modern scholars such as Alan Dershowitz, Sam Harris, and Charles & Gregory Fried, have expressed different ideas on ethical torture. Ideas of ethical reasoning were established by John Stuart Mill and Immanuel Kant. Even though they did not specifically use torture as an example of ethical reasoning for decision making their rational can still be applied to this topic. Immanuel Kant believed our moral decisions are based on categorical imperative....   [tags: Ethics, Immanuel Kant, Morality]

Strong Essays
1202 words (3.4 pages)

Immanuel Kant And John Stuart Mill Essay example

- When you ask your friend what ethics means to them you may get a different answer. You may hear responses that reference religion, laws or whatever feels morally right. The framework for ethics suggest that feelings, religion, law, science, and cultural influences should not be considered when determining if what your about to do is ethical. Here is what you do consider ethical reasoning, • Utilitarian, do the most good or the least amount of harm. • Rights, treat people with dignity and not a means to an ends, if you can’t treat everyone ethically then it should be fair....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Deontological ethics]

Strong Essays
1435 words (4.1 pages)