Can Virtue Be Taught? Essay

Can Virtue Be Taught? Essay

Length: 993 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In this paper, I will exam Plato’s idea of “virtue is knowledge” to understand “can virtue be taught”. In my opinion, Plato does not strictly proves “virtue is knowledge”; instead, he believes that “virtue is the gift of God”.
“Can virtue be taught?” This is question Plato is trying to answer in Meno. This problem is important and serious, because its answer directly concerns a question about how we understand and position education. The reason for Plato making this question is related to his opposition to the wise men. It is well known in the times of Socrates and Plato, some wise men advocate “virtue can be taught” to recruit a large number of young customers. They pull out money from pocket; hope the wise men can teach them virtue However, from Plato’s and Socrates’s viewpoint, this kind of behavior ruins people’s virtue. Therefore, to criticism theses wise men, they must refute “virtue can be taught”.
Before Meno, Plato reflects “can virtue be taught” in Protagoras. In this dialogue, Plato selects Protagoras as Socrates’s opponent, the intention is obvious, if the wise men like Protagoras cannot provide sufficient and strong argument for “virtue can be taught”, then it is doubtful for the wise men to advocate “virtue can be taught”. That is only for questioning “virtue can be taught”, Protagoras cannot be considered as fail. Because in this dialogue, except in one or two places the requirements Socrates proposes to Protagoras seem quite unreasonable, even a little inconsiderate (Plato, Protagoras, 2002, pp. 27-31, 334c-338e),most of the time, Protagoras does not succeed in persuading Socrates. But the problem is that, although the argument “virtue can be taught" seems doubtful, but in the dialogue Socrates was not able to pre...


... middle of paper ...


...f his way of thinking; almost all of Plato's dialogues are not transcend this limitation. Confined on the way of thinking, Plato always trying to find a common definition of the concept and according to the definition starts analyzing and discussing. Although he stressed the overall concept, also pay attention to the semantics of the language, but he did not realize that the language system itself is whole organic and inseparable from human practice, the concept of universal knowledge and understanding cannot be separated from holding a special section. So, in Meno, he rejects virtue of a special category from discussing the issue is inappropriate.



Works Cited

Plato. (2002). Meno. In G. Grube., Five Dialogues (pp. 58-92). Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, Inc.
Plato. (2002, November 3). Protagoras. (C.c.W.Taylor, Ed.) Oxford: Oxford University Press Inc.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Socrates And Plato The Simple Question Of Whether Virtue Can Be Taught Essay

- Meno asks Socrates/Plato the simple question of whether virtue can be taught. Socrates/Plato makes an effort towards answering this question by using his dialectic, the Socratic elenchus. However, his main goal is not to answer the question, but to share his thoughts about the status of the soul. Socrates/Plato cared about the “care of the soul” (pg.6) and was a dualist who believed in two realities. One reality is higher than the other. The higher reality includes Metaphysics and Epistemology. Also according to Socrates/Plato the Soul is made of three parts, Reason, spirit, and appetite....   [tags: Virtue, Plato, Ethics, Metaphysics]

Strong Essays
1288 words (3.7 pages)

Can virtue be taught? Essay

- lthough today's society includes much technology and new things are supposedly being discovered every day, many age old questions still remain unanswered; questions such as: "Can virtue be taught?" This question is examined in detail throughout Plato's Meno, and although the play leaves the question as to what virtue is unanswered, Socrates attempts an answer to Meno's question. Although he is not particularly keen on answering whether virtue can be taught without first having a complete understanding of what virtue is, he attempts to please Meno by solving this in the way that geometers conduct their investigations, through a hypothesis....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
556 words (1.6 pages)

Protagoras' Answer to How Virtue Can be Taught by a Story About the Creation of Animals by the Gods

- ... Further, Zeus orders a law regulating social behavior: those who do not conform to social norms are to be killed. Certain types of skills (those relating to basic livelihood) are therefore possessed only by some, but the civic virtues (politike arete) are possessed by all. The Athenian political system, Protagoras concludes, is based on the recognition of just this fact. Having reached this position, Protagoras continues on the subject of punitive justice: to punish a wrongdoer for a past deed is illogical, for the punishment cannot undo the crime....   [tags: species, justice, philisophy]

Strong Essays
1017 words (2.9 pages)

Midterm : Virtue Ethics And Ethics Essay

- ... Moreover, Thiroux & Krasemann, mentions that society can distinguish and figure out which principles are to be applied our specific daily lives; by doing “what is right to us” (73). The author argues how that virtues template is not meant to employ everyone for personal selfish reasonings (Thiroux & Krasemann, pg.74). For example, some people didn’t get to experience the proper raising to have developed a moral compass or foundation; so viewing other’s who project themselves with virtuous behaviors may help someone else to become a decent human being....   [tags: Ethics, Virtue, Morality, Human]

Strong Essays
905 words (2.6 pages)

Virtue Ethics And The Great Role Model Of Folklore And Language Essay

- From several scholars point of view, it is believed that virtue will likely appropriate to be applied in public sectors. The virtue ethics was adopted first by Aristotle (Lawton 1998). Virtue ethics is not to questioning the consequences of an action nor the moral judgments obligations in the universal moral order. Virtue ethics prioritise the development of moral character, motivations, and intentions in every person (Trevino & Nelson 2010). Furthermore, virtue ethics emphasises the importance of history, folklore and puppet story....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Virtue ethics, Virtue]

Strong Essays
1316 words (3.8 pages)

Analyzing Meno 's Definitions Of Virtue And The Soundness Of Socrates Essay

- The theme of Meno is the argument on whether virtue can be taught, as discussed by Socrates and Meno. To reach a conclusion on whether or not virtue can be taught requires that the philosophers first define what exactly is being taught, or what is virtue. Socrates claims to know nothing about virtue, except that he is looking for it 's form. As a result, Meno provides many definitions for Socrates. This paper will analyze Meno 's definitions of virtue and the soundness of Socrates ' argument against them as he searches for the form....   [tags: Virtue, Plato, Definition, Aristotle]

Strong Essays
883 words (2.5 pages)

Is Virtue A Quality Of The Soul And Is Not A Kind Of Wisdom Or Prudence?

- “If then virtue is a quality of the soul and is admitted to be profitable, it must be wisdom or prudence since none of the things of the soul are either profitable or hurtful in themselves, but they are all made profitable or hurtful by the addition of wisdom or of folly; and therefore and therefore, if virtue is profitable, virtue must be a sort of wisdom or prudence?” (Socrates, Plato’s Meno) Throughout the complex and confusing book Plato’s Meno, one at the end of the narrative is left a bit dumbfounded....   [tags: Virtue, Plato, Good and evil, Knowledge]

Strong Essays
1036 words (3 pages)

Essay about Happiness Is Not A Virtue

- ... In chapter 7, Aristotle then brings up that happiness needs to be with the best activity and best virtue. These best virtues belong to our intellect which means that we need to think about it. We need to have pleasure in our lives to keep us going, which is part of the body. One of the best virtues is wisdom and the activity that goes with this is philosophy. Philosophers are able to distinguish what they want in their lives and what is good for them. Therefore, Aristotle believes that philosophy is key to a happy life....   [tags: Ethics, Virtue, Plato, Positive psychology]

Strong Essays
741 words (2.1 pages)

Women 's Theory Of Virtue Essay examples

- In The Republic Plato argues that some women have the ability to become philosopher-Guardians. This idea during that time wasn’t viewed as a normal idea to spring upon, therefor Plato argues this statement through questionings and contradictions to justify this radical idea. He does so by summing up his ideas and thoughts through his theory of virtue. Just as female guard dogs fulfill the proper guard functions, same as males, the same should apply to female guardians. Although women and men have natural powers and natural abilities if they are given the same training intellectually and physically, there is nothing to prevent women from fulfilling these roles....   [tags: Virtue, Plato, Nature, Woman]

Strong Essays
1656 words (4.7 pages)

Essay Aristotle 's Theory Of Virtue Ethics

- ... Aristotle also believed this is where hexis came into play, that part that is deeply rooted within us and cannot be taught. Although these cannot be taught per say, they can be worked on. Aristotle believed that “in the give-and-take with other people, some become just, others unjust; by acting in the face of frightening things and being habituated to be fearful or confident, some become brave and others cowardly; and some become moderate and gentle, others spoiled and bad-tempered, by turning around from one thing and toward another in the midst of desires and passions.” (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy) Often times when people hear the word virtue, they think of decency or righteo...   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Virtue ethics, Virtue]

Strong Essays
968 words (2.8 pages)