To begin with, Somerville’s article is in response to the rise in news coverage of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide in Canada. Somerville wrote this article in defense of the anti-euthanasia movement, to reinforce people who are against euthanasia, and to inform those that are not familiar with the topic. This article could also sway those that are stuck in the middle. Somerville believes that euthanasia is absolutely morally and ethically wrong and completely unacceptable unless, in very rare cases, that someone is in excruciating and terminal pain and has zero chance of living a better life. Somerville supports this idea by using facts and statistics but some of them are not very well backed up or proven. One example is her quoting of Ruth Von Fuchs who is the presid...
... middle of paper ...
In brief, “Last Rights” by Gary Cartwright is a better article than “The Role of Death” by Margaret Somerville. Cartwright makes his argument incredibly applicable to the reader’s life by using well developed stories and terms that the reader can understand. On the contrary, Somerville uses short, almost hostile paragraphs, over the top vocabulary, and unsupported facts. Even though Cartwright’s article is better, neither of these articles proves one side right and the other wrong nor provide a compromise for each side to agree on. It will likely be a very long time before a solution is reached, if ever.
Cartwright, Gary. “Last Rights.” TexasMonthly. TexasMonthly, n.d. Web. 21 Feb. 2010
“Euthanasia.” ProCon. ProCon, n.d. Web. 11 Feb. 2010
Somerville, Margaret. “The role of death.” catholiceducation. catholiceducation, n.d. Web. 20
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Euthanasia is the act of intentionally ending a life to relieve pain and suffering. The House of Lords Select Committee on Medical Ethics of England defines euthanasia as a deliberate intervention undertaken with the intention of ending a life, to relieve suffering(Harris, NM. 2001)., in the Netherlands euthanasia is defined as the termination of life by a doctor at the request of a patient(BBC,2011). The right to die debate posses a great number of legal, moral and ethical issues. Proponents and supporters of euthanasia had presented valid arguments: people have the right of self-determination and that is why they should be allowed to choose their own fate; is a better choice to assist an i... [tags: Autonomy, Right to Die]
644 words (1.8 pages)
- Recently I have gone through the very difficult struggle of seeing my father come face to face with death. He was in the hospital, in a comatose state for nearly eight days. During that time, because he left me as his medical proxy, I was the one that made the decision about what course of action was to be take. It is my aim in this paper to address the question of whether or not it is ever permissible to actively aid in the death of another person. I will attempt to argue that active euthanasia can at times not only be permissible, but the correct action to take.... [tags: Assisted Suicide, Right to Die]
1797 words (5.1 pages)
- Euthanasia should only be used when it benefits the one who dies. It is a widely held belief that an act of euthanasia aims at benefiting the one who dies. It is morally wrong to engage in voluntary acts of euthanasia; it is morally wrong to engage in acts of non-voluntary euthanasia, and; it is never morally right to engage in acts of involuntary euthanasia. In situations where the patient is suffering when do you put the morally wrongs aside and help or get help in freeing yourself or a loved one from pain.... [tags: Pro Assisted Suicide, Right to Die]
1774 words (5.1 pages)
- Euthanasia - the termination of a person's life with the aim of getting rid of his pain and suffering with an incurable disease (Euthanasia).Currently adult euthanasia legalized in different forms in countries such as Colombia and Japan, as well as the U.S. states of Oregon, Vermont and Washington, and in some European countries: namely, Netherland and Belgium, Luxembourg and Switzerland(Belgium has taken the unprecedented law on child euthanasia).At this time, the topic of euthanasia is very relevant, as pass many debates on this subject and its resolution.... [tags: Pro Assisted Suicide, Right to Die]
896 words (2.6 pages)
- Physician assisted suicide should be a choice of the patient in Florida. There has long been a debate on Physician assisted suicide in the state of Florida, and in many other US states. The government has the burden on whether to pass an initiative on allowing physician assisted suicide. The Right to die initiative is decided on a state by state basis. Physician-assisted suicide is defined as a physician providing either equipment or medication, or to inform the patient of the most available means, for the purpose of assisting the patient to end his or her own life.... [tags: euthanasia, Physician assisted suicide, Argument]
777 words (2.2 pages)
- Carol Bernstein Ferry took her own life in June, 2001. She was diagnosed with emphysema and given between six months and a year to live. When she was diagnosed, she could only think of the pain and distress inflicted on her and her family associated with an impossible battle against her disease. Carol Bernstein ended her life in a dignified, peaceful and painless manner and believed strongly in the right for others to do the same. (Harris, 16) Euthanasia, or physician assisted suicide, is the painless killing of a patient suffering from an incurable and painful disease or in an irreversible coma.... [tags: Assisted Suicide, Right to Die]
1166 words (3.3 pages)
- What is euthanasia. The dictionary defines euthanasia as the act of putting to death or allowing to die painlessly, a person or animal from a painful incurable disease. Euthanasia is also known as mercy killing. The word euthanasia comes from the Greek word eu- meaning good and the Greek word thanatos which means death. There are two types of euthanasia: active euthanasia and passive euthanasia. Active euthanasia is the practice of ending the life of a person painlessly. While passive euthanasia is the practice of a patient refusing treatment or allowing a patient to die.... [tags: Pro Assisted Suicide, Right to Die]
869 words (2.5 pages)
- “A person has the constitutional right to request the withdrawal or withholding of a medical treatment, even if doing so will result in the person’s death” (Assisted Suicide). So why is there not, and should there not be a right in some states and countries for those who are near death and know they will die to want to end their life. Even during the Ancient Roman times, the idea of Assisted Suicide was accepted “If caused from pain or sickness, or by weariness of life” (Assisted Suicide). With today’s technology, it has become easier to keep a person who is terminally ill or in a “vegetative state” alive longer.... [tags: Pro Assisted Suicide, Right to Die]
1107 words (3.2 pages)
- One of the reasons I picked Euthanasia is a subject that I am unfamiliar with. I want to learn both sides of the argument and how people from each side thought about it. So in this paper I will talk about both sides of the argument, the people on each side, and the different types of Euthanasia. The subject of Euthanasia is a heated battle, in which lines have been drawn between warring social, religious and political groups. Many people want this controversial institution erased from the volumes of lawful medicine, but others say that we should be able to choose our fates in extreme cases.... [tags: Euthanasia Essays]
1489 words (4.3 pages)
- An Argument for Euthanasia Euthanasia is defined as, "The act or practice of putting to death painlessly a person suffering from an incurable disease." Euthanasia can be traced back as far back as the ancient Greek and Roman civilizations. It was sometimes allowed in these civilizations to help others die. Voluntary euthanasia was approved in these ancient societies. Today, the practice of euthanasia causes great controversy. Both pro-life groups and right-to-die groups present arguments for their different sides.... [tags: Argumentative Essays, Persuasive Essays]
2007 words (5.7 pages)