Animal Abuse, By George Orwell And Dog Lab By Claire Mccarthy Essay

Animal Abuse, By George Orwell And Dog Lab By Claire Mccarthy Essay

Length: 960 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

At some point in your life, you will be put into a difficult situation. A situation where you will be found stuck in the middle; contemplating on what’s “right” or “wrong”. You will begin questioning yourself as an individual. It is your choice to be wise and make a decision you won’t later regret. Once a decision has been made, there’s no going back. There is much controversy on the topic of animal abuse. Many individuals question if it’s morally right or wrong to kill an animal or even use them for scientific testing. Some argue that animals have equal rights and protection as humans do. For this reason, people find that being in this position where you have to end a life is very difficult. Both essays, Shooting An Elephant by George Orwell and Dog Lab by Claire McCarthy explore the theme of right and wrong. Though both deal with individuals whom question right between wrong, they hold several differences in the way this theme is presented.
There is much similarity between Orwell’s Shooting An Elephant and McCarthy’s Dog Lab. Both Orwell and McCarthy experienced a situation, where they were tested in making the “right” choice. Even though both individuals lived in different parts of the world, they both carried similar responsibilities. Orwell worked as a police officer in Burma, while McCarthy was a student in medical school. These jobs involved taking care of people and possibly risking their life. In the beginning of Shooting An Elephant, Orwell expressed his anxious feeling with being “an obvious target” to the people of Burma (Kirszner, page 458). Similarly, McCarthy indicated feeling “a little scared” with her study in medical school (Kirszner, page 479). Both individuals had situations where they felt confused. In Shoo...


... middle of paper ...


...uppy that wiggled his tail (Kirszner, page 483). At the end, both individuals felt differently about doing what they did. Orwell indicated being glad with killing the elephant. To Orwell the elephant’s murder had been justified and legally right (Kirszner, page 463). In the other hand, McCarthy felt guilty and disappointed in herself. The dog lab hadn’t been that important for McCarthy to proceed with. McCarthy had found herself worrying too much and losing herself.
In conclusion, deciding the difference between right and wrong can be difficult. Both individuals experienced the difficulty of making the right choice. Their situations were very different, but similar at the same time. In the end, their decision did affect who they were and a lesson was learned. Often time’s people do things without thinking about the consequences and how it will affect them in the end.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Abuse of Power in George Orwell’s Animal Farm Essay examples

- Often times in a communist society, a leader’s use of language can lead to abuse of power. In George Orwell’s Animal Farm, the farm leaders, the pigs, use unknown language, invoke scare tactics, and create specific laws, thereby enabling them to control other animals, to suit their greedy desires, and to perform actions outside their realm of power. Because of the pigs’ use of broad language, implementation of scare tactics, and creation and manipulation of laws, they are able to get away with avoiding laws and convincing other animals into believing untrue stories and lies that are beneficial to the pigs....   [tags: George Orwell, Animal Farm]

Strong Essays
1350 words (3.9 pages)

George Orwell 's Animal Farm Essay

- Power has always been difficult to equally share. Humans have struggled for centuries to balance authority evenly and have created complicated systems to try to overcome the problem. The Russian Revolution is amongst many to have tried and failed to raise a fair government. George Orwell’s classic novel Animal Farm portrays this event in history into a smaller scale, making it easier to understand. Having so much power is not always a good thing. Animal Farm proves this to an almost scary extent where the characters are mainly animals, not people....   [tags: Animal Farm, George Orwell, The Animals, Novel]

Strong Essays
1086 words (3.1 pages)

Animal Farm By George Orwell Essay

- Max Pfeiffer-Frederick Pre-AP English 1 March 19, 2016 Outside Reading Card – Animal Farm by George Orwell MLA Citation: Orwell, George. Animal Farm (Penguin Modern Classics). New York: Penguin Books Ltd, 2000. 2. Provide a detailed plot summary: The story begins on a farm called The Manor. The farm is owned by a guy named Mr. Jones. He is a mean man who treats his animals cruelly, and uses them for profit. For example, he drowns old dogs when they are no longer of use and he slaughters anything thing that will make him money and buy him more whiskey....   [tags: Animal Farm, George Orwell, The Animals]

Strong Essays
1574 words (4.5 pages)

Essay on Animal Farm By George Orwell

- Arne Tiselius once said, “We live in a world where unfortunately the distinction between true and false appears to become increasingly blurred by manipulation of facts, by exploitation of uncritical minds, and by the pollution of the language.” Animal Farm by George Orwell is a satirical parallel to the Russian revolution, in which a small group of pigs use their heightened intellect to deceive the intellectually inferior. In doing this, they obtained and maintained positions of power after the successful revolution of Animal Farm....   [tags: Animal Farm, The Animals, George Orwell]

Strong Essays
1026 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Animal Farm By George Orwell

- In the novel Animal Farm, George Orwell shows the readers how language can used as effective weapon to control people.Orwell uses the animals in the Animal Farm to reflect the events that lead to Russian Revolution War in 1917. This book is about the animal’s life after rebellion and how totalitarianism was formed. The strong rhetorical skills and the manipulation of language in George Orwell’s Animal Farm grabs the attention of the readers very well and connects The Animal Farm starts when Old Major who is the oldest pig on the farm encourages other animals to rebel and take over the farm which is owned by Mr.Jones....   [tags: Animal Farm, Rhetoric, George Orwell]

Strong Essays
793 words (2.3 pages)

Symbolism and Literary Techniques in George Orwell's "Animal Farm" Essay example

- George Orwell’s Animal Farm is an allegoric fairy tale type novel that uses irony, satire, and allegory to portray the true identity of media censored Communist Russia. Because of the relationship between America and Communist Russia during WWII, Animal Farm was not originally received with warmth because it was thought of as harmful propaganda. But then, during the Cold War, when US-USSR relations soured, George Orwell’s novel was finally read. George Orwell, the pseudonym of Eric Blair, conceived the basis of Animal Farm during his tenure at Eden, a prestigious English boarding school....   [tags: Symbolism, George Orwell, Animal Farm,]

Strong Essays
1161 words (3.3 pages)

George Orwell's Animal Farm Essay

- George Orwell's Animal Farm George Orwell wrote ‘Animal Farm’ as an allegory, which is a simple story, with a more complicated idea running alongside it. In this case, it is a story about a group of pigs taking over a farm, and the story of the Russian Revolution is told underneath it. The main characters of the revolution are portrayed in the book as follows: Mr Jones is Czar Nicholas II, the last Russian leader before the revolution; Old Major is Karl Marx, the person who influenced the people into revolting and the idea of communism; Snowball is Trotsky, one of the early leaders of the revolution; Napoleon is Stalin, a cruel, selfish, and corrupt leader; and Boxer and Clover represent t...   [tags: George Orwell Animal Farm Essays]

Strong Essays
915 words (2.6 pages)

George Orwell's Animal Farm Essay

- George Orwell's Animal Farm Introduction:Animal Farm is a short story written by George Orwell in 1945. He had a lot of difficulty getting it published due to its underlying criticism of the political situation in Russia at the time. The story takes place on a farm somewhere in England. The owner of the farm, Mr.Jones, comes into conflict with the animals. The animals rebel, and finally scare him away. Two of the strongest animals, Napoleon and Snowball (two pigs), think that they can run the farm....   [tags: George Orwell Animal Farm Essays]

Free Essays
842 words (2.4 pages)

George Orwell's Animal Farm Essay

- George Orwell's Animal Farm George Orwell has used many techniques of writing such as irony and humour to portray significant events throughout Animal Farm. This extract, just after the slaughter of the 'disloyal' animals (one of the most emotive of the events in the book), is no exception and so I will be analysing and interpreting the response of readers as well as making links to other parts in the book. 'Loud singing' could be heard from the farmhouse, this is just after the pigs have come across a 'case of whiskey'....   [tags: George Orwell Animal Farm Essays]

Free Essays
976 words (2.8 pages)

George Orwell's Animal Farm Essay

- George Orwell's Animal Farm Mollie- Represents the rich and noble of Russia at the time (esp. the Czar and his family). Those who fled Revolutionist Russia, because they had had a better life beforehand, and were un-willing to accept change. The messages that Orwell is trying to express through Mollie are directly opposite to the actions which are displayed through Benjamin. Although they were both unwilling to accept change, their actions were very different. The message that Orwell is conveying through Mollie is that you shouldn't just quit because things get tough....   [tags: George Orwell Animal Farm Essays]

Strong Essays
2359 words (6.7 pages)