Anatomy of a Murder: Four Expert Witnesses Essay

Anatomy of a Murder: Four Expert Witnesses Essay

Length: 1469 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In Anatomy of a Murder, there were four expert witnesses, Dr. Smith, Dr. Harcourt, Dr. Raschid, and Dr. Dompierre, who testified during the trial and gave their respected opinions based on their expertise about the evidence and stipulations raised. An expert witness is defined as a witness who has special knowledge or training in a specialized area (Gardner & Anderson, 2013, pg.123). The opinion of an expert witness may be admissible if the opinion is being given about a subject that can clear issues in the court. To determine whether or not the expert witness testimony is admissible, it must meet the requirements of the Federal Rules of Evidence 702-704. In addition to reviewing each of the three Federal Rules of Evidence, I reviewed each of the four expert witness testimonies and analyzed whether or not each testimony complied each Federal Rule of evidence.
According to the Federal Rule of Evidence 702, A witness who is qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education may testify in the form of an opinion or otherwise if: (a) the expert’s scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue; (b) the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data; (c) the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods; and (d) the expert has reliably applied the principles and methods to the facts of the case (Gardner & Anderson, 2013 pg. 523).
According to the Federal Rule of Evidence 703, an expert may base an opinion on facts or data in the case that the expert has been made aware of or personally observed. If experts in the particular field would reasonably rely on those kinds of facts or data in forming an opini...

... middle of paper ...

... this sense is not admissible, and therefore his testimony is objectifiable in this sense did not comply with the federal rule of evidence 704.
Identifying if an expert witness testimony has complied with the Federal Rules of Evidence 702-704 must be closely analyzed because not all parts of the testimony may comply. It is important that an expert witness testimony adhere to these rules because it forms the basis for what testimonies are actually of expertise (i.e. knowledge, training, education) and what opinions from the experts may be admissible in to court.

Works Cited

Fed.R.Evid 702 (a-d)
Fed.R.Evid 703
Fed.R.Evid 704 (a-b)
Gardner, T. J., & Anderson, T. M. (2013). Criminal evidence: Principles and Cases (8th ed.).
Belmont, Calif: Wadsworth Cengage Learning.
Preminger, O. (Director). (1959). Anatomy of a Murder [Motion picture].U.S.A: Columbia

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Synopsis of Anatomy of a Murder Movie

- Anatomy of a Murder takes place in small-town in Michigan, where a murder has taken place. Lieutenant Frederick Manion (Lt. Manion) murdered Barney Quill a local bar and inn owner, after Mr. Quill raped his wife Laura Manion. Mrs. Manion contacts former state district attorney Paul Biegler to represent her husband, who is facing charges for first degree murder. Knowing nothing about the case, Mr. Biegler is convinced by his friend Parnell McCarthy to take the case. After two visits to Mr.Manion in jail and discussing things over with Mr....   [tags: lt manion, anatomy, murder, barney quill]

Powerful Essays
1814 words (5.2 pages)

Anatomy Of A Murder Reading Response Essay

- Anatomy of a Murder Reading Response Literature commonly depicts lawyers as justice-seeking protagonists, and though this is done in Anatomy of a Murder, when analyzed, Paul Biegler’s actions did more to subvert justice than to achieve it, and because of this justice is not achieved. Biegler does this in two ways. First, he coaches Manion into taking up an insanity plea, and continues to pursue this argument, despite knowing Manion was in control of his actions at the time of the murder. Secondly, he adopts the persona of a “small town country lawyer,” while in court in order to make the jury sympathize with him, and get in certain arguments he might not be able to present conventionally....   [tags: Law, Judge, Prosecutor, Lawyer]

Powerful Essays
723 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on The Murder Of Criminal Homicide

- On February 14, 2013, South African Olympian, Oscar Pistorius shot and killed his girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp. The incident took place at their home in South Africa, where Steenkamp was hiding in the bathroom, when three out of the four shots hit her. Pistorius claims that it was an act of self defense, mistaking Steenkamp as an intruder. During his trial, experts questioned the Mental Health of Pistorius. Steenkamp parents added that he had a history of anger problems and breakdowns during the relationship....   [tags: Murder, Homicide, Manslaughter, Law]

Powerful Essays
1060 words (3 pages)

Death Penalty A Legal Murder Essay

- Death Penalty A Legal Murder This search paper will explain why death punishment should be abolish throughout the nation. Moreover that it should not be on states to decide whether they will practice death penalties or not. Eventually, the honest question around capital sentence in America has less to do with if those convicted of violent crime deserve to die than with whether state and federal governments deserve to those to death penalty those whom it has imprisoned. Currently there are 31 states that still allow death penalties, and there are 19 states who have chosen abolish the death penalty....   [tags: Crime, Capital punishment, Prison, Murder]

Powerful Essays
1482 words (4.2 pages)

Human Anatomy And Physiology And The Understanding Of It Has Come A Long Way

- Human anatomy and physiology and the understanding of it has come a long way. Our bodies has many different parts to it. Due to advances’ in medicine and technology we have a more scientific understanding of what our bodies are made of and the functions/ roles our body parts have and also the effects of medicine on our bodies. Most of us has a basic understanding of what our body is made up of including cells, organs, tissues, and other systems . There are also other “common” knowledge’s and facts about the human body such as the skin is the largest organ....   [tags: Human anatomy, Human body, Anatomy, Galen]

Powerful Essays
1129 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on The Murder Of The United States

- In a case that has spanned more than 20 years and drew so much media attention, there is just as much intrigue today as it then. Did he do it or did he not do it. The entire world was captivated by the case. It took over a year for a trial and a conclusion that stunned the world with the verdict (Boyes). They were many household names that came out of this trial (Pitts). In 1995 one of the most puzzling criminal cases triumph in America. This double assassination actually occurred on June 14, 1994 in Los Angeles, California....   [tags: O. J. Simpson murder case, O. J. Simpson]

Powerful Essays
1118 words (3.2 pages)

Anatomy Of A Jury Essay

- Seymour Wishman was a former defense lawyer and prosecutor, and the author of "Anatomy of a Jury," the novel "Nothing Personal" and a memoir "Confessions of a Criminal Lawyer." "Anatomy of a Jury" is Seymour Wishman's third book about the criminal justice system and those who participate in it. He is a known writer and very highly respected "person of the law." Many believe that the purpose of this book is to put you in the shoes of not only the defendant but into the shoes of the prosecutor, the judge, the defense lawyer and above all the jury....   [tags: Seymour Wishman]

Free Essays
1696 words (4.8 pages)

Anatomy Of A Brand Essay

- Anatomy of a Brand Harry Potter Brand Wizard To some, Potter-mania seems like a fad, but it contains lessons that are relevant to the entire marketing community July 18, 2005 Harry Potter is one of the most remarkable brand stories of recent years. So much so, that there can't be a single person anywhere who hasn't heard of "the boy who lived" and the best-selling books that bear his name. To date, six books in the seven-book series have been published and approximately 250 million copies have been sold worldwide....   [tags: Business Marketing]

Free Essays
1601 words (4.6 pages)

Anatomy of Criticism Essay

- Anatomy of Criticism   Introduction In his Anatomy of Criticism, Northrop Frye offers a complex theory that aspires to describe a unifying system for literary criticism. It can be argued, however, that in attempting to delineate such an all-inclusive structure, Frye's system eliminates identity in literature. The present essay takes up this argument and offers examples of how identity is precluded by Frye's system as outlined in Anatomy of Criticism. Structure Vs. Identity In Frye's system, the organizing principles that give literature coherence and structure are derived from the myths of ancient Greece and the archetypal imagery found in the Bible....   [tags: Anatomy of Criticism Essays]

Powerful Essays
1252 words (3.6 pages)

What is an expert? Essay

- Currently the most prevalent is that an expert is a person who has some skill or knowledge in some domain that is matched by only a few other people. These people are thus extraordinary in some way. Anders Ericsson, probably the best known of the researchers on expertise defines expertise as Relatively stable outstanding performance.Experts are often labeled as such. People called exceptional, superior, gifted, talented, specialist, expert, etc. tend to belong to the set of experts. There is no doubt that there are large differences in the quality of performance of different people on different tasks or in different domains....   [tags: essays research papers]

Powerful Essays
1566 words (4.5 pages)