Analysis Of Martha Minow 's Five Unstated Assumptions About The Dilemma Of Difference

Analysis Of Martha Minow 's Five Unstated Assumptions About The Dilemma Of Difference

Length: 1978 words (5.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview



PART A: Martha Minow’s Five Unstated Assumptions About The Dilemma of Difference

In Making All the Difference: Inclusion and Exclusion in American Law, Martha Minow outlines five unstated assumptions about the dilemma of difference and special privilege. The dilemma of difference is based on the idea that the identity of recognizing differences threatens the idea that we are all the same. In other words, the idea that everyone is the same leads to formal equality. The dilemma of difference is also about the “unstated point of reference,” which is when there is a failure to recognize difference as a problem. For example, Mari Matsuda’s experience of not being allowed into the store illustrates how it is problematic to recognize difference as a problem.
Minow discusses how difference among people exposes them to discrimination. Minow’s article examines the “sources of difference” in order to define differences and structural inequality. According to Minow, the first unstated assumption is that “difference is intrinsic, not comparison.” Minow provides that difference is part of nature and that there can be compared even if it is not noticeable all the time. For example, everyone is the same despite all the stereotypes and assumptions. Sherene Razack provides that the concept of race tends to “other” those who do not belong to the dominant white group. Similar to Minow, Razack used the term “other” to challenge everyone to question why people are categorized to belong “the other” group. Differences are intrinsic because people view others from their own set of assumptions.
In “Race, Racism and Racialization: Contested Concepts,” Vic Satzewich discuss the asymmetrical issue surrounding race as there is a hierarchy that exists in ...


... middle of paper ...


... quail’s call to illustrate how human rights is not always “attractive.” In short, human rights can at times be brutish, nasty and messy. This is especially true when human rights law deals with the issue of racism. Barb Thomas acknowledges that there are underlying issues that need to be addressed.
Sherene Razack argument is premised on learning about cultural difference and how at times it is inadequate and misinterpreted. Razack also talks about appropriation, intersectionality, cultural relevance and essentialism in regard to human rights. She is very critical about the issue of racism and uses the term intersectionality to describe how people belong can be identified with more than one social identity based on race, gender or disability. Consequently, she provides that “we are not in any position of criticizing another culture because we belong to a culture.”

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Martha Stewart Living : Advertisement Analysis

- Martha Stewart Living - Advertisement Analysis Are women still seen as being homemakers in modern-day society, and are they being sold a domestic lifestyle. It appears that Martha Stewart believes so and desires to continue a trend. For example, in the July/August 2014 issue of Martha Stewart Living, one could argue that women are stereotypically represented as being homemakers in a KitchenAid advertisement, which shows a woman placing a dirty pan in a KitchenAid dishwasher. Moreover, the eye-catching, bold headline, shown on the ad of the American home appliance brand is “cook like you don’t have to clean.” The ad goes further with promoting an ideal familial status of women by using subl...   [tags: Woman, Female, Martha Stewart]

Better Essays
1042 words (3 pages)

Maud Martha, by Gwendolyn Brooks Essay

-      Black women's experiences and those of other women of color have never fit the private -public model.  Rather than trying to explain why Black women's work and family patterns deviate from the alleged norm, a more fruitful approach lies in challenging the very constructs of work and families themselves. ("Native") Maud Martha Brown had strong ideas regarding marriage.   She set out to conquer the role as wife, in spite of and because of her insecurities and personal hardships.  Unlike the rose-colored images that enveloped the minds of many traditional (white) women during that period of the 1940s and 50s, Maud Martha set her sights on being a bride under the simplest conditions. ...   [tags: Maud Martha Essays]

Better Essays
2920 words (8.3 pages)

Memo to Martha Stewart, CEO of Martha Stewart Omnimedia Essay

- Memo to Martha Stewart, CEO of Martha Stewart Omnimedia Dear Ms. Stewart, I am writing to address some concerns I have about the future of your company, Martha Stewart Omnimedia (MSO). Perhaps the one issue that you are grappling with at present is about the Imclone scandal. You have been accused of selling $227,000 worth of Imclone stock based on inside information. Because of these charges of insider trading, your critics have summarily associated you with other disgraced company directors: Kenneth Lay of Enron and Bernard Ebbers of WorldCom....   [tags: Letter Martha Stewart Business Essays]

Better Essays
1577 words (4.5 pages)

Essay on Martha Stewart's Insider Trading

- Martha Stewart's Insider Trading      Martha Stewart, the countries top icon for homemaking has been in the eye of the public since June 2002, but not for her craftiness or culinary abilities. Stewart instead has the spotlight on her for crimes of insider trading. A tip from her former broker Peter E. Bacanovic, persuaded her into selling her IMClone stock after sharing information about a close friend of Stewart’s getting rid of his shares. Stewart’s companion, Sam Waksal, was also the chief executive of IMClone Systems Inc....   [tags: Business Martha Stewart Essays]

Better Essays
1073 words (3.1 pages)

Essay Martha Stewart's Insider Trading

- From being a very successful businesswoman to calling a prison cell home, Martha Stewart has definitely had an interesting past couple of years. She started her career about 30 years ago with a catering business and has since built from that becoming the CEO and Chairman of Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia, Inc. Her success also includes the publication of her magazine Everyday Living, being the commercial spokeswoman for K-Mart, and having her own popular television show, From Martha’s Kitchen. She had built the reputation of being a public figure with how-to advice on creations in the kitchen to gardening....   [tags: Financial Crime Insider Trading Martha Stewart]

Better Essays
1537 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on Making A Difference Within My Community

- Making a Difference in My Community Without culture, uniqueness would be rare. Without uniqueness, society would be dull. In a dull society, there would be no more imagination or new, outstanding ideas. Culture is the reason why everyone is different in their own way, making each and every person, no matter who they are, unique. In order to make a difference, you have to be different. Not many realize how much everyone’s own, personal culture affects their lives and the community they live in. It not only defines one another but brings out new ideas and understandings of the world around them....   [tags: Culture, Difference]

Better Essays
711 words (2 pages)

Essay on Martha Stewart

- Martha Stewart, founder and CEO of her own multimillion dollar corporation, Martha Stewart Living Omni media was indicted, on charges of lying to investigators, securities manipulation, and obstruction of justice. She was sentenced to five months in a West Virginia state woman’s prison and 5 months on house arrest. Originally it was said that Ms. Stewart was indicted on charges of insider trading, however obviously those charges could not be proven. After a year and a half investigation, she was indicted on totally different charges....   [tags: Martha Stewart, Case Study, solution]

Better Essays
1502 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on Tim O'Brien and Martha Stout

- Tim O’Brien describes the way that war stories are told and their reliability in his work “How to Tell a True War Story.” As a Vietnam War veteran O’Brien describes the nature of a war front and how people perceive the experiences in the war front differently. In her essay “When I Woke Up Tuesday it Was Friday” Martha Stout discusses regarding self-dissociation from case studies of her patients. Dissociation is the disruption of psychological functioning; trauma is one of the main causes of dissociation....   [tags: Reflections on War, Self-Esteem]

Better Essays
1460 words (4.2 pages)

The Difference Between Men and Women Essay

- The Difference Between Men and Women The fact that men and women are different is well known. Some of these differences are constant and some are not; some have changed in the past and some are about to change in the future. While some physical differences are obvious, some of them are controversial; in addition, psychological and cognitive differences are always divisive. Men are considered to be physically stronger than women. First, the physical duties of a household always seem to be a job for the man of the house....   [tags: Gender Difference Human Development Essays]

Better Essays
666 words (1.9 pages)

Essay about Martha Washington

- Martha Washington Martha Washington lived a life full of love and sacrifice. She was born as a simple little girl Martha Dandridge to her plantation home in New Kent; she was married at 18 to become Martha Dandridge Custis. Still yet she was widowed at the age of twenty-six with two children and a land of over 17,000 acres to run on her own. Then she met a gentleman by the name of George Washington and Martha became the figure we know today as Martha Dandridge Custis Washington or Martha Washington....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1565 words (4.5 pages)