American Women: Can They Have It All? Essay

American Women: Can They Have It All? Essay

Length: 1786 words (5.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

For years there has been the continued debate of whether women, and in some cases men, can have it all; that is defined as the general assumption is based on the Western model of what and how having it all is defined. For some, the idea of having it all can be defined in the simplest of measures, family, health, and wellness to the American model that is defined so often towards women which would include family, career, health, wealth, and sometimes many more variables. The article, “Can’t Have It All? Blame Our Extreme Work Culture” by Rana Foroohar specifically addresses the challenges that working American women and men face in determining whether or not to attempt to break the glass ceiling, or to “settle” for compromises and balance within their daily lives of family, work and culture. There are many parameters in which the dilemmas outlined in the article can be addressed. Specific focus will be emphasized in how Marx’s theory of the “dynamics of capitalism” and how it relates to our extreme work culture, gender inequality and the invisible labor of women in the home, and Gilman’s method’s of incorporating evolutionary theory to the roles of women; reproduction, economics, and the divided self.
Marx
Society has seen the male dynamic of superiority, designation as the “bread winner”, or head of household for centuries. Women were specifically assigned to the roles of wife, mother, and nurturer through the process of the sexual or gendered division of labor. However, that has not always been the case. Over centuries of change and shifts in economic development, the roles of women have changed to adapt to their specific roles in society. The status of the individuals in society was defined by sex, age, physical trai...


... middle of paper ...


...dult males. There is also a direction that children would benefit if there were more of an equal or egalitarian participation between both parents, allowing the child to develop and benefit from interaction by both parents. This could have transcended into the government environment by emphasizing the roles of women whose abilities were more directed towards professional and public life. She arduously agreed that women were more suited to raise children, however that they should not be confined as their drive was at risk of being stifled as the result of not being able to publically express their creativity and intelligence. In applying these ideas today, and to the desire to “have it all”, Gilman would most likely see a necessity of change on the part of the male hegemony that is still present in modern society regarding the roles of the women in the labor force.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

American Women Leaving the Home and Going to Work Essay

- One of the most significant sociological changes in the nation's history began in the last decade of the nineteenth century and the ramifications are still being felt today. This change consisted of the large numbers of women who entered the work force. This dramatic change in American society was accompanied by a great deal of controversy and prejudice directed towards women. It was predicted that female employment would bring about the downfall of society and the change of the American family....   [tags: Working-Women Joining the American Workforce ]

Better Essays
2198 words (6.3 pages)

Essay The Rights Of American Women

- Mandi Sellars Steven McCall Political Science July 10, 2015 The Rights of American Women Early in American society, women played the role as the primary caretaker of their children in their homes. The only purposes women served in society, back in those days, was to reproduce, care for their own children, and care for their homes. Men, at the same time in history, assumed the responsibilities of hunting, fishing, and producing crops to provide food for their families. They also bared the burden of fighting in times of war....   [tags: Women's suffrage, Women's rights]

Better Essays
1089 words (3.1 pages)

Struggle of American Women for Equality Essay

- To an onlooker, it may seem that the struggle of American women is essentially over. It is a fact of American Society, and also all functioning societies, that it will behave in such a way as to ensure its own continued existence. In accordance with post-modern Sociology, the system will move with us, against us, or in spite of us; instead of benevolence or malevolence towards individuals or groups, it is more interested with self-preservation. Therefore, when women as a group make an advance in society, they have done so in a way that benefits society as a whole, but not necessarily women as a group....   [tags: Women's Rights]

Better Essays
2012 words (5.7 pages)

Essay on The Evolving Role of Women in American History

- The Evolving Role of Women in American History The role of American women has changed significantly from the time the nation was born, to the modern era of the 1950s and 1960s. Many people, "... believed that women's talent and energies ... would be put to the better [use] in the new republic." (Clinton 3) Clearly showing that society has seen the importance of the women's talents and that their skills can be very useful, exploited this and thus, the change of the women's role was inevitable. Society has understood that the roles of women played an important role on all parts of life....   [tags: Evolution of Women's Roles American History]

Better Essays
2170 words (6.2 pages)

Essay on American Women in the Nineteenth Century

- Contrary to popular belief, ideas on femininity in the eighteenth century were not so much restrictive as in the nineteenth, at least not where sex was concerned. Catherine Clinton, a professor of American history, elaborates in her book, The Other Civil War: American Women in the Nineteenth Century, that it was even accepted for women to have a high sex drive. Clinton also reveals that it was not uncommon to see a pregnant bride (147). At the turn of the century, however, those free ideals morphed into strict guidelines....   [tags: women's role, sex drive, femininity]

Better Essays
1184 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on American Women in Society

- Throughout history women in the Americas have played a mayor role in society. In a time where women could take care of themselves, they could own property and enforce laws. Even after their rights were taken away by the arrival of the Europeans in 1462. Women did not have control over themselves, could not own property and did not have political rights. They continue to have a big influence on the construction of the US government. Today times have changed, women are fighting back and taking charge of their freedom....   [tags: History, Women's Rights Movements]

Better Essays
1792 words (5.1 pages)

Essay about Black American Women Writers

- Ques. Discuss the circumstances in which writing by black American women gained literary and cultural prominence in the last two decades and a half of the 20th century.What are the most dominant themes in their writings?Comment also on the stylistic innovations present in the writings of some of these writers. The year 1970 proved to be a watershed moment in the history of black women's writing and their struggle for emancipation.Many black women had distanced/were distancing themselves from the Feminist movement of the 60's.These women made their presence felt by drawing people's attention to their concerns which were different from those of white women.The black women's writing,which was...   [tags: American Literature]

Better Essays
2006 words (5.7 pages)

American Women’s Beginnings Essay

- What is a new world if can not expand it. It is nothing. According to the Records of Virginia Company of London, early Virginia lacked one essential element of English society and that was a stable family life1. For the English society to have stable family life, they need women to form these families to have stable family lifes. In early US history, men played a major role in developing the colonies in America, but the women also played a major role in America. They expanded the colonies by giving birth to the future Americans....   [tags: American History]

Better Essays
1032 words (2.9 pages)

American Women's History Essay

- 1. The American Revolution impacted almost every aspect of Native American, European American, and African American women's lives. The American Revolution severely affected Native American women, especially agriculturally. They were the farmers and gardeners of their tribes and the war damaged the soil so much so in some areas that farming was rendered impossible. Most Native Americans, including the women, sided with Britain during the war. Each tribal woman grew crops, when possible, for the British soldiers as well....   [tags: american revolution, racism]

Better Essays
1308 words (3.7 pages)

Native American Women Essay

- Native American Women On few subjects has there been such continual misconception as on the position of women among Indians. Because she was active, always busy in the camp, often carried heavy burdens, attended to the household duties, made the clothing and the home, and prepared the family food, the woman has been depicted as the slave of her husband, a patient beast of encumbrance whose labors were never done. The man, on the other hand, was said to be an loaf, who all day long sat in the shade of the lodge and smoked his pipe, while his overworked wives attended to his comfort....   [tags: American America History]

Free Essays
1160 words (3.3 pages)