A Comparison of Two Methods Used to Rank Business Articles Essay

A Comparison of Two Methods Used to Rank Business Articles Essay

Length: 1510 words (4.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The ranking of journals plays a major role in the overall ranking of colleges and universities; it is important to ensure the articles in those journals are being ranked fairly and accurately. Business articles are ranked by editorial board members of universities using various types of methods; this research will cover citation analysis and acceptance rates. The purpose of this research is to expand the knowledge of UHV’s business school students and faculty over the rankings of articles for business journals. The difference between the two methods along with any problems that can occur within each will be discussed first. Then the research will cover why the methods are valuable but not always accurate. Lastly, the consequences or affect business journal rankings can have on business schools at universities if they are not properly ranked will be discussed.
The Two Ranking Methods Explained
Articles in business journals can be ranked using citation analysis and acceptance rates; knowing how these two are used to determine the rankings is very important. A citation is when one author uses another author’s work within their own research but gives credit to the rightful owner. Citation analysis is observing the pattern and frequency of citations used in articles written by scholars; it can help determine how valuable a scholar’s work is to the person who is ranking it. The number of citations the author uses can be used to compare the quantity of the article and can also increase its overall value (Cahn, 2010).
Acceptance rates have to do with the overall review process and the number of articles that are accepted by editorial board members. Acceptance indicates that a scholar’s work was found to be of value to the reviewer. A...

... middle of paper ...

...ers, Sonke. (2009, August). Misleading rankings of research in business. German Economic Review, 10(3), 352-363.
Bean, David, Richard Bernardi, Michael Melton and Scott Roberts. (2008, September). Fostering ethics research: An analysis of the accounting and marketing disciplines. Journal of Business Ethics, 82(1), 157-170.
Cahn, Susanna. (2010). Journal reputation, citation and acceptance rates. Proceedings of the Northeast Business & Economics Association Rankings: Comparing, 692-695.
Davis, Barbara, Roberta Krapels and Jeanette Martin. (2012, January). A comparison of the top six journals selected as top journals for publication by business communication educators. Journal of Business Communication, 49(1), 3-20.
Urbancic, Frank. (2011). The gatekeepers of business education research: An institutional analysis. Journal of Education for Business, 86(5), 302-310.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Methods Of Assessment Of The Corporate Market Position Essay

- 2.1. THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK As already stated in the first introductory chapter, the goal of this research is to use several methods of assessment of the corporate market position, or in other terms the competitive position of the company, apply them to LLC “United Confectioners” and design a marketing strategy plan. Currently there is no generally accepted method of assessment of company’s competitive position or, in other words, company’s competitiveness. There are many methodologies used in business or proposed by different authors....   [tags: Marketing, Strategic management]

Powerful Essays
1080 words (3.1 pages)

Essay Rank's Analytical Tool for Advertising

- 1.) Rank’s easy-to-use, analytical tool is called the intensify/downplay model, and its goal is to help you to become more critical and analytical receivers. It defines and gives examples of four major persuasive strategies and six associated tactics that are often used by persuaders today. (Larson, 2007 page 31) Ranks major strategy is to either intensify certain aspects of the product, cause or candidate. His other strategy is to downplay certain aspects of their brand, cause or candidate. (Larson, 2007 page 31) The intensification and downplay strategies include, to intensify their own good points, intensify the weak points of the opposition, downplay their own weak points, and downplay t...   [tags: rank, advertisements,]

Powerful Essays
638 words (1.8 pages)

Performance Management Systems Essay

- Introduction Performance management systems are effective when they are based on goals that are jointly set and are driven by an organization's business strategy. The use of competency models that are based on business strategy is strongly associated with organizational effectiveness. When they drive salary increases and bonuses, they are executed better. Often absent but critical to the success of performance management systems is senior management leadership and ownership, much less important is ownership by HR....   [tags: organizational business strategy]

Powerful Essays
2288 words (6.5 pages)

Characteristics Of Good Business Research Methods Essay

- Reflect on your study over the last 7 modules/weeks. Provide a workplace example of how you will apply the concepts explored in this course. In addition, provide an example of how a biblical character failed to apply the concepts explored in this course. Concepts learned in this course of study translate well to varied areas of my current workplace. Whether the concept of research has to do with employees, customers, processes, or procedures, utilizing the scientific method for generating systematic, empirically based information and data is proving to be the favored approach to research methodology (Cooper & Schindler, 2014, p....   [tags: Scientific method, Research, Science, Hypothesis]

Powerful Essays
821 words (2.3 pages)

Effective Business Marketing Methods Will Be The Controlling Factor For Small Business Growth

- Effective business marketing methods will be the controlling factor for small business growth. The point of this venture will be to identify probable techniques for marketing CJ Salon. This will be accomplished through surveying other small businesses concerning organizational practice and effectiveness of business marketing. Economic pitfalls have caused a decline in clientele at CJ Salon. By means of investigation, this study will provide an effective blueprint for small business marketing strategies which support growth....   [tags: Marketing, Business, Small business, Research]

Powerful Essays
806 words (2.3 pages)

Characteristics of Qualitative and Quantitative Methods Essay

- Qualitative and quantitative researcher’s exhibited conflicting ways of approaching a research. Some researchers prefer qualitative over quantitative and vice-versa. Also, it is common for qualitative and quantitative to be used together in a research. But, both methods when carried out correctly provide good research. Plus, both methods have their own unique differences and characteristics. In this paper I will define three of these characteristics in a quantitative and qualitative research design and discuss and compare their differences....   [tags: Research Methods]

Powerful Essays
931 words (2.7 pages)

Business Research Methods Essays

- You are required to evaluate the in terms of purposes, audiences and general strengths and weaknesses. The essay will account for 40% of the overall mark. Indicative word count: 1500 words. Note that you will need to submit your coursework to the Business School reception by 12pm (noon). "Research – an investigation involving the process of enquiry and discovery used to generate new ideas" (Hall, Jones, Raffo, 1993, Business Studies, P. 204) Research is vital in all business environments, and put into practice far more than most people presume....   [tags: Business]

Free Essays
1587 words (4.5 pages)

Methods of Business Research Essay

- Methods of Business Research According to the American Marketing Association, marketing research is the systematic gathering, recording, and analyzing of data about problems relating to the marketing of goods and services. Marketing research is not a perfect science. It deals with people and their constantly changing feelings and behaviors, which are influenced by countless subjective factors. To conduct marketing research you must gather facts and opinions in an orderly, objective way to find out what people want to buy, not just what you want to sell them....   [tags: Business and Management Studies]

Powerful Essays
1014 words (2.9 pages)

Business Theory Comparison Essay

- 1. What is the purpose of business. This question can have an endless amount of answers and they all can be correct. The goal will not be to find a definite answer but to explore four main business ethics theories to get a better understanding of what the purpose of business is. 2. A solely profit based business model would define stockholder theory in which the paramount goal of the business is to produce the most earnings for their stockholders. Prioritizing profits over a positive public image Goldman Sachs becomes an excellent example of stockholder theory....   [tags: Business]

Powerful Essays
749 words (2.1 pages)


- BUSINESS METHODS PEST (Political, Economical Social and Technological environment ) Analysis The external environment of any organisation / university / faculty / department etc. can be analyzed by conducting a PEST analysis. The acronym PEST (sometimes rearranged as STEP) is used to describe a framework for the analysis a range of macro environmental factors including the Political, Economical Social and Technological environment. A PEST analysis fits into an overall environmental scan including the SWOT analysis and McKinsey’s 7S Model, which is briefly discussed below and also referred to in the document ‘Preparing a SWOT Analysis....   [tags: essays research papers]

Powerful Essays
1577 words (4.5 pages)