James Frey, Oprah and A Million Little Pieces - Case Study

759 Words2 Pages

"Veterans Affairs Head Robert McDonald Lied About Serving in Special Forces" - Katie Pavlich | Feb 24, 2015 Lying is not really newsworthy, it happens every day. The problem to be investigated by this essay is WHY individuals deliberately say things that are not true. This problem relates to the basic virtue of honesty. In the book, Business Ethnics, the author Jennings (2009) has identified various categories of ethical dilemmas one of which being, Saying Things You Know Are Not True. This paper examines the ethical dilemma of honesty by analyzing Case 2.10, James Frey, Oprah and A Million Little Pieces. The analysis of the case focus on the qualities of truth and lessons learned in decision making and conduct.

The case, James Frey, Oprah and A Million Little Pieces, is a prime example how an individual’s actions can conflict with the basic virtue of honesty. In this case, the results of the Smoking Gun’s investigations of James Frey memoirs depicted in the book, A Million Little Pieces, revealed that facts were embellished. Oprah’s initial reaction to the quality of the truth was to believe that Frey’s actions were just. Despite Frey’s admission of inflating events, Ms. Winfrey felt that because the important facts were true then he was being truthful (Jennings...

... middle of paper ...

...issue is not falsification of facts but the detection of false information before it impacts the organization. When it’s all said and done, Ms. Winfrey took away an unavoidable lesson from her experience with Frey which is not to trust everything you read and verify the facts before supporting them. As, Ms. Winfrey continues to be a public icon, it is more than likely she will be confronted with issues of ethical dilemmas and the best solution is to verify the details.

Works Cited

Jennings, M. (2009). Business ethics: Case studies and selected readings (6th ed.). Mason, OH: South-Western Cengage Learning.

"Veterans Affairs Head Robert McDonald Lied About Serving in Special Forces" - Katie Pavlich | Feb 24, 2015 Web: http://townhall.com/tipsheet/katiepavlich/2015/02/24/new-va-head-lied-about-military-service-n1961369

Show More
Related

  • Robert Mcnamara Analysis

    789 Words  | 2 Pages

    This unfortunate legacy of failure in Vietnam carried far past the end of his service as Secretary of Defense. For years after, there have been ongoing debates as to what factors led the outcome of the Vietnam War. It wasn’t until 1995 that Robert McNamara contributed his own viewpoint on where the responsibility for the result of the war fell. McNamara’s memoir, “In Retrospect”, chronicles his perspective on the role he played as Secretary of Defense. It is apparent in his memoir that the public image associated with McNamara is vastly different from the McNamara he presents. Ironically, this infamous war he was so commonly know for may have been a war that privately he did not support.[1] This raises the question—was this hawk actually a

    Read More

  • Ideas Of Truth In Tim O Brien's The Things They Carried

    1664 Words  | 4 Pages

    Its all about the person 's experience, and their perception of the experience. There can be many different sides to a story, and very well be each individual 's truth. Tim O’Brien is a perfect example, he explains his truth about the Vietnam War in his own way and how he felt through his experiences. You get to see Tim O’Brien explain his own personal truths, and although he may have had different ways of explaining the Vietnam War it is his own truth. Whether it was about Jimmy Cross and his love for Martha, or the horrific experience of Ted Lavender being killed. He did a great job telling the story, whether it metaphorically meant something else or a figment of his imagination. It was his truth of the Vietnam

    Read More

  • Unraveling Lies: A Comparative Analysis of Deception

    1075 Words  | 3 Pages

    A person once said “the truth does not cost a person anything, but a lie costs a person everything”. The aim of the study is to take an in depth look at how the kinds of lies and sex differences in lying demonstrated in the scientific article are related with Pamela Meyer's tedtalk.

    Read More

  • Analysis of Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara's Famous Quotation

    1619 Words  | 4 Pages

    First, it is necessary to plunge into the life of Robert McNamara. In her book, Promise and Power: The Life and Times of Robert McNamara, Deborah Shapley described McNamara as, “a devious tactician and a man of sincere and noble goals” (xvi). He was born in San Francisco, California on June 9, 1916 (6). His father, western regional manager of a shoe company, was a man of rigid self-discipline and routine (6). His mother, a devout Protestant, was a homemaker who kept unusual statistics of Roberts’s early development (6). From his parents, McNamara learned “moral purpose and raw ambition” (11). His mother was extremely motivated to nurture her children in a way that would motivate them to climb the social and economic ladder (9).

    Read More

  • The Government Should Provide Assistance for Sexually Assaulted Victims in the Military

    630 Words  | 2 Pages

    The corruption around sexual assault in the U.S. military is overwhelmingly devastating. Many women would report cases of rape just to be told that they were lying, or that there was not enough evidence or that their rape kit had been lost.7 In some cases, the attackers would be the victim’s commander; these officials did 25% of sexual assaults.6 The military has huge power in this nation and have been using their power to cover up their own criminal acts. It is difficult for the victims to come forward for these horrible assaults. Women that do come forward either lose their ranking or nothing’s done because the person they go to is friends with the assailant. It is believed that over 85-90% of rapes in the U.S. military go unreported. Over the years, floods of people have come forward, yet the number of unreported cases remains the same.6 The documentary Invisible War did a tremendous job on bringing this problem into the eyes of the public and to our government, which recently passed legisl...

    Read More

  • The Scarlet Letter

    1306 Words  | 3 Pages

    portrays that a person should not lie, even when drastic consequences such as death threaten

    Read More

  • Examples Of Lies In The Great Gatsby

    833 Words  | 2 Pages

    The society that we live in today is built around lies. Banks lying to customers in order to feed the capitalist mindset, politicians lying to citizens in order to gain power, and charities taking donations with open arms however are stingy when giving back to the cause. The common reason why these organizations lie is to hide what they truly are. People also deceive others in order to hide who they truly are. From a young age, lying becomes engraved into one’s mind, we are taught to walk, talk, and lie.

    Read More

  • Robert Deshaun Peace Honesty

    392 Words  | 1 Pages

    Many of us are most likely familiar with the well-known quote- “honesty is the best policy,” and to a certain level of consent, I agree. Robert DeShaun Peace was a man of two different worlds, born and raised in Newark, NJ, and then later attended an Ivy League institution. He possessed character, something the BugerBoyz were truly privy to, immense intelligence, and mystery. Throughout the course of his life, he came into contact with thousands of diverse human beings. He was considered a friend to “Yalies,” South Americans, and the people of Newark; and yet, not until his utterly tragic and unexpected death, did they all realize exactly how little they really knew of him. “None of us had actually known Rob as well as we thought we did.” (Jeff

    Read More

  • Hester Prynne and Abigail Williams in The Crucible by Arthur Miller

    668 Words  | 2 Pages

    Adultery was a significant part in these women’s lives. As any reader can see, even people with the same traits have many different faults. Such as their ability to speak the truth.

    Read More

  • Oprah Winfrey’s Influence on Philanthropy

    1210 Words  | 3 Pages

    Winfrey, Oprah, and Bill Adler. The Uncommon Wisdom of Oprah Winfrey: A Portrait in her Own Words. New York: Carol Pub. Group, 1997. Print.

    Read More

  • Essay On Military Enlisting

    1204 Words  | 3 Pages

    The act of enlisting in war has been seen as an honorable task since the establishment of the military and its different branches. To take pride and to fight for one’s nation is the true meaning of being an American citizen. Like with every decision made in life, enlisting in the military has consequences. The act of war is often unpredictable and many measures are taken into count. These soldiers therefore, entrust their life to the military. However, what most soldiers never take into consideration before enlisting is the fact that a majority of them will be subjected to a form of sexual abuse or sexual harassment. Sexual abuse and harassment that occurs within their own respected military group. These soldiers get in trouble for reporting

    Read More

  • Deception

    537 Words  | 2 Pages

    Deception exists in media, among prestigious universities, and perhaps most commonly in the workplace. According to Dunleavy (2010), reasons for deception in the workplace include: competitiveness, conflict, or a response to a supervisor or fellow employee (p. 241). Dunleavy develops hypotheses’, conducts experiments, and collects data to determine what is considered acceptable and unacceptable behavior as it applies to deception in the workplace. Ultimately, the reason for deceiving and the method in which one deceives, through either withholding (omission) or distortion (commission), directly effects the perception of coworkers’ credibility, power, and trustworthiness (Dunleavy, p.241).

    Read More

  • Stephen L Carter's The Insufficiency Of Honesty

    660 Words  | 2 Pages

    Traditionally, it is agreed that any and every form of telling the truth is always the best thing to do. In the essays of Stephen L Carter and Stephanie Ericsson, this ideal is not exactly true. It is expressed in "The Insufficiency of Honesty" as well as "The Ways We Lie" that honesty is hard to come by and that there is more to it than believed. The authors convey their views by first defining what the concept is, picking it apart, and then use common occurrences for examples of the points they had made.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The (Honest Truth About Dishonesty By Dan Ariely

    1301 Words  | 3 Pages

    We lie a lot, says behavioral economist Dan Ariely. The central thesis of Dan Ariely’s The (Honest) Truth About Dishonesty is that human behavior is driven by two conflicting motivations, and that most human values are not compatible all of the time. On one hand,

    Read More

  • The Effects Of Lies And Truth In Lois Lowry's Number The Stars

    330 Words  | 1 Pages

    In “Number the Stars”, by Lois Lowry, Annemarie got lied to by the adults a few times. They did that to Annemarie for a good reason. Sometimes lying to a kid is a good thing, but sometimes it is not. An example of a good time is when you lie to a kid for their safety.The effects of lies and truth on Annemarie’s story, are good. Annemarie was told that her sister Lisa, died in a car accident, and that her Great Aunt Birte died. Annemarie knew there was no Great Aunt Birte, but she went along with it, wondering why nobody ever told her about Great Aunt Birte, or why she had never seen her.

    Read More

More about James Frey, Oprah and A Million Little Pieces - Case Study

Open Document