PAY FOR GRADES? First of all, students shouldn’t acquire money for good grades as it can cause conflict and pressure. The NEA( National Education Association) states,” Many teachers also say paying students for grades leads to practical problems in their classrooms, including pressure to inflate grades and conflict with students and parent.” To paraphrase this, paying students for top-notch grades can cause conflicts and strifes with their parent. Also, they bear the burden for getting excellent grades. Moreover, this may cause kids’ mental stress and it can demolish the student and parent’s relationship. In any situation, students shouldn’t earn payment for satisfactory grades. In addition, students shouldn’t earn money for wonderful grades since it will take away their internal motivation. According to the psychologists Sam Goldstein and Bob Brooks, “ External motivators may be effective and well intended, but they clearly work against the continued development of a child’s intrinsic (innate) motivation. Intrinsic motivation – participating in school for …show more content…
As stated by Chang, “ In Dallas,Texas 10,000 students passed the advanced placement test for a reward of $400, compared to the year before when only about 6,000 students passed.” Undoubtedly this statement can be challenged. Even if grades skyrockets for a while it will gradually decline in the long haul. Sanford Dornbusch, director of the Stanford Center for Youth Development who said,” Students who receive money for grades will in the long run have lower academic performances than the students who are motivated by their own desire to learn.” Unfortunately, the opposite effect of what parents who pay their kids for grades expected happens. You may not realize this now, but when you do, it will be too late. To be sure, paying students for good grades is not an intellectual
“Beginning in 2007, his [Roland Fryer Jr.] project paid out $6.3 million to students in 261 urban schools...from low-income families” (Sandel 52). As a result, paying students for good grades has an impact on many people, not only students but teachers as well. Students should be paid for good grades because they will be able to save the money they earn for the future, it will motivate them to do well in school, and it will increase their scores on AP exams. With the money that students earn for their good grades, they can save it for their future. According to student Brett Upperman, “‘Kids need money so we can save it for college.
Many high school students have a job that they go to after school which takes up their time that they could be using for homework and studying. If we were to pay these students for their good grades then they would no longer have the need for a job and could get even better grades and would even be able to take harder classes because of the extra time they would have to study and for homework. With the extra time that students would receive they could progress their education even
The article “should kids be paid for good grades?” written by Amber Angel (2012), she discussed the disadvantages of should kids be paid for good grades. The author tone is philosophical and she supports the disadvantages because through the strategy which to reward students based on their result is not effective, it is only for a short period. It is not an effective motivator. Other than that, the students are being taught the wrong character that caused and confused themselves.
The general argument by author Arianna Prothero in her work, “Paying Kids to do Well in School?”, is that school authorities are trying to use incentives to help kids perform better on tests. More specifically, Arianna argues that educators have long used rewards to prod children into doing what they want. The rewards sometimes consist of items such as gift cards, scholarship money, and in some cases cold hard cash. Technically, anything that motivates a student to do something is an incentive. Therefore, an incentive could be as simple as putting a sticker on a test or even as extreme as rewarding perfect attendance with a brand new car, like Raytown did last year.
By paying them, they would learn many valuable lessons that will help them in the future. Students should be paid for good grades because it encourages them to work harder, it helps the economy and last but not least, it will allows students to gain more responsibility and would increase their self-esteem. Some responsibilities would include taking care of their own belongings and learning to spend money when it is only needed. Obviously, being paid for good grades will give a brighter future to students and they will always be confident in themselves at whatever they
People may say it is a bad idea to pay children for good grades . In some ways, this could be true like…. Kids will never just want to learn to be successful, their main focus will be to do the best they can and get rewarded. Another reason why some people disagree is because they
If students are to be paid for grades, it doesn’t give them their education which won’t help them in the future. According to Sanford Dornbush, “students who receive money for grades will in the long run, have lower academic performances than the students who
First of all students shouldn’t get paid for good grades, because it will give the students a lower academic performance in the long run. This information was found from Stanford Dornbush, the director of Stanford Center for youth Development. Stanford Dornbush stated, “Students who receive money for grades will, in the long run have lower academic performances.” This means if students receive money for good grades, then they will have a lower academic performance further on in their life. The effect of this is that the students will eventually have a lower academic performance in the long run.to sum it up, giving kids money for good grades will, in the long run, give kids a lower academic performance.
Which is said by Stanford Dornbush, director of the Stanford Center for Youth Development, “Students who receive money for grades will in the long run have lower academic performances.” If students receive money for grades they will not succeed in the long run because they are only motivated because of money. The effect of this is teaching kids to only accomplish stuff for money, which can cause them to become greedy. Obviously, students will not succeed in the long run academically if they are galvanized by
Students progress better when there is an award. Chan prepare evidence to support the claim of test scores. “ In Dallas, Texas, 10,000 students pass advanced placement tests for a reward of $400. Compared to the year before 6,000 passed”. Students are actually studying and learning to be more prepare for the test.
Some schools pay their children for good grades. By doing this they must think that the child will make better grades as a reward. I believe that it does help students make better grades. Some of the reasons that i think you should get paid for your grades are that it may help kids who are having trouble stay in school. It prepares them to when they get older so they know what it feels like to have a job., and it makes them work harder.
Although learning has its own rewards, some students respond better to money. This essay explains how students will be paid and the reasons that they should receive money for getting good grades. Some reasons that students should be paid are: if students received rewards for having good grades, fewer students would drop out, graduates would be better educated, people would seek higher education, less crime would be committed, less people would rely on the government, and graduates would be more qualified for better jobs. In 2009, an experiment by MDRC was conducted in two community colleges in Louisiana State for low-income students. One group of students was offered $1,000 each semester if they could attend college at least half time, and maintain an average above a C while another group did not receive the supplement.
They will not care about the knowledge that they hold, they will simply throw it away and ‘learn’ new subjects. As you can see, paying students for good grades is bad because children should learn it only if they want to, not because they want the
If I was given money for good grades, I would jump at that chance, I think a lot of kids would be more motivated to get something out of it. Along with motivation, this would actually help the kids in later life, and in a way the parents also. Giving the students a cash bonus, could help them immensely in later life, financially. Especially
Theorists believe that motivation within the classroom has its benefits when able to produce work from students. Some students have the ability to work without much motivation. This is known as intrinsic motivation. Intrinsic motivation is where students are able to motivate themselves and produce work at high standard. The students have to be determined to strive and have the self-ability to do the work that is needed (Brewer, Dun, Olszewski, 1988). Students who need more praise and encouragement to produce work come under the category of extrinsic motivation. Extrinsic motivation is about rewarding the students for their work. If a student is able to get done what they have been asked, they will be rewarded with for example a sticker or a lucky dip. Extrinsic motivation for some students means the reward is...