What Is Arthur Schopenhauer's Response To Suicide

1524 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Arthur Schopenhauer essay on suicide

Arthur Schopenhauer argues that the overall value of life is negative at all times. This stems from the notion that humans live in an internal realty governed by a universal will which drives constant desire from all things in existence. Desires are the products of suffering from the lack of something. While happiness is only a neutral relief from life’s torment. However, an objection stems from Schopenhauer’s reluctance to endorse suicide as a means of escaping this fate of pain. It argues that if life is better than nonexistence then it must have positive value at some point. Thus, things cannot be negative at all times.
Schopenhauer’s believes that the ultimate reality of life is a unified metaphysical will that controls the actions of …show more content…

By killing oneself an individual denies the possibility of completely renouncing the will and being relieved from the turbulent pressures in life.
However, I argue that for this salvation to be worth forgoing death it must break Schopenhauer's argument that life is a constantly negative. Nonexistence after death is eternal neutrality. The decision to forgo this eternal neutrality would have to mean that salvation from the will in life must be of higher value. Therefore, life during that period must be positive. For example, Schopenhauer argues that contemplating and appreciating art is an act free from will and desire. Therefore, since it gives some pleasure and does not stem from suffering it must be positive in value.
This brings a further objection to Schopenhauer’s claim that all happiness stems from a suffering from a lack of something. This premise does not hold true in two scenarios. The first is when we feel happiness from something we did not expect to happen. For example, bumping into an old friend unexpectedly. We could not have been urging for it in the moment, therefore that happiness must be positive. Second, when we receive happiness in places where we only expected bad things. For example, when someone does not study for a test but does well anyway they receive unexpected

Show More
Related

  • Concerning Thomas Nagel and Permanent Death

    732 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the beginning of Death, Nagel presented the question of whether it is a bad thing to die. He furnished two positions on the subject. The first position is that life is all one possesses and to lose life is the greatest loss one can encounter. The second position is that death is a blank, not an unimaginable condition, that has no positive or negative value whatsoever. Stating his aim to be considering whether death is in itself an evil, Nagel clarified that the state of being dead, or nonexistent, is not in itself evil for several reasons. First, death is not an evil that one is able to accumulate more of. A person cannot receive a larger portion of death no matter how long they have been in that state. Secondly, one would not regard temporary life suspension as harmful. In the case of long-term suspended animation or freezing, one can view this as a continuation of their present life. Thirdly, few people regard the long period of time before their birth as a misfortune. From these points, Nagel concluded that humanity does not object to death because it involves indeterminable periods of nonexistence. He then proposed that if death is an evil at all, it can only be because of what it deprives us of, since it has no positive features. He did not, however, agree with the idea that death is bad because it brings an end to all the good things in life. Nagel formulated that if all good and bad life experiences were removed, what i...

    Read More

  • Happiness: Enough Already, By Sharon Begley

    1153 Words  | 3 Pages

    People push being happy on society as a total must in life; sadness is not an option. However, the research that has conducted to the study of happiness speaks otherwise. In this essay Sharon Begley's article "Happiness: Enough Already" critiques and analyzes societies need to be happy and the motivational affects it has on life. Begley believes that individuals do not always have to be happy, and being sad is okay and even good for us. She brings in the research of other professionals to build her claim that extreme constant happiness is not good for people. I strongly agree that we need to experience sadness to build motivation in life and character all around.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Happiness Is A Glass Half Empty

    844 Words  | 2 Pages

    Oliver Burkeman, author of The Antidote: Happiness for People Who Can’t Stand Positive Thinking and column writer for The Guardian, explores the human need to seek for happiness and its connection to the Museum of Failures in his article Happiness is a Glass Half Empty. Burkeman’s purpose to writing this essay is to give readers a new view on how to seek happiness – embrace negativity and expect the worst. Burkeman’s use of a friendly, almost informal tone to help relate to his readers is a brilliant attempt to catch his reader’s attention and hold it, therefore enabling the delivery of logic seem almost effortless.

    Read More

  • Lady Macbeth Suicide Analysis

    475 Words  | 1 Pages

    From first day of life till last, whatever a person strife for is nothing, but the end of all findings be death, that is inevitable. “If according to Freud, the subject pursues its own death, or is steered towards it by a drive for inertia, why not say suicide or masochism lies at the heart of life?” (Smith 67) If one is bound to die, than death with bravery and courage is better than death at the hands of enemy, which may even include nature or fate. “In this state and when confronted with hardships that makes life seem intolerable, suicide becomes a possibility.” (Lester 17)

    Read More

  • Utopian Society in Aldous Huxley's Brave New World

    941 Words  | 2 Pages

    Huxley implies that by abrogating dreadfulness and mental torment, the brave new worlders have disposed of the most significant and brilliant encounters that life can offer also. Most remarkably, they have relinquished an abstruse deeper joy which is intimated, not expressed, to be pharmacologically out of reach to the utopians. The magical foundation of this assumption is dark. There are clues, too, that a percentage of the utopians may feel a poorly characterized feeling of disappointment, an irregular sense that their lives are trivial. It is suggested, further, that assuming that we are to discover correct satisfaction and importance in our lives, then we must have the ability to contrast the great parts of existence with the awful parts, to feel both euphoria and despondency. As vindications go, it’s a great one.

    Read More

  • Hobbes Justification Of Absolute Authority Analysis

    1986 Words  | 4 Pages

    ...ish existence. Assuming such a scenario, it is not evident whether one would rationally prefer bare existence over nonexistence—. It can be argued that the— demarcation between a slavish life and nonexistence itself is at least psychologically nonexistent. Furthermore, a slavish life may reflect a position that is qualitatively worse than that of a life within—a state of nature. In the latter scenario— one retains his freedom, which may be valued or be in our rational interest more than the uncertainties

    Read More

  • Socrates's Views On Happiness And The Reality Of Happiness

    2078 Words  | 5 Pages

    The human capacity for positive and negative feelings is shaped by the forces of evolution. These forces have also been involved in the way philosophers viewed their philosophical perspectives on life, death, the world and most importantly on this paper, the importance of the appearance of happiness from the reality of happiness comparing Socrates views on others. This paper will also attempt to identify the more pertinent innate qualities of the human brain with happiness, Socrates views on the appearance/reality of happiness and how we might live our own life according to Socrates defense and Euthyphro’s failures from Captain Picard’s “tapestry”.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Jeremy Bentham

    1055 Words  | 3 Pages

    As a result, three general characteristics were constituted as the basics of his philosophy: the greatest happiness principle, universal egoism and the artificial identification of one’s interests with those of others. The first discusses about producing the greatest amount of happiness for the greatest number of people. Therefore, the utility principle is completely dependent on the amount of happiness brought about. It can be inferred that actions which don’t produce a content amount of happiness is morally

    Read More

  • Human Mortality According to Heidegger

    3649 Words  | 8 Pages

    ...eave one with a similar "air of tragedy". However, if we can gather the strength to adopt an authentic way of being, if we can see that we have a self to find and overcome the repression for selfhood, we can at the very least be freed from the mistaken view of death and thus, be freed from the irrational fear that normally accompanies it. The role of mortality in Heidegger's philosophy may be methodological and catalytic, but the import of mortality to Human Being, whether authentic or inauthentic is and always has been significant in conjunction with our cultural overlays and traditions. Heidegger's phenomenological view of death as a way-of-being is significant to us because it provides a workable alternative to the common dogmatic views of death and it can help to guide us through a profound existence, that is laden with the traps and pitfalls of inauthenticity.

    Read More

  • Why It Is Better To Never Come Into Existence Analysis

    2125 Words  | 5 Pages

    Bad things happen to all of us. It is an unavoidable feature of humanity. When we are born, we are born to suffer. So what if we had never been born? What if we had never been introduced into this world of inevitable hardship? Would we be better off? Such thoughts are entertained by David Benatar in his essay ‘Why it is Better Never to Come into Existence’ (Benatar, 1997)- who, rather unsettlingly for his readers, argues that it is rational to think that it is not better to exist than to have never come into existence.

    Read More

  • The Pursuit of Happiness in Fahrenheit 451

    2866 Words  | 6 Pages

    Before we look into specifics, we’ll examine the history and development of “happiness” as a philosophy. Of course, the emotion of happiness has always existed, but it began to be seriously contemplated around 2,500 years ago by philosophers like Confucius, Buddha, Socrates and Aristotle. Shortly after Buddha taught his followers his Noble Eight Fold Path (which we will talk about later), Aristotle was teaching that happiness is “dependent on the individual” (Aristotle).

    Read More

  • Suicide In Society: Suicide And Society

    1229 Words  | 3 Pages

    Individuals in society experience many changes that can make them feel overwhelm or feel accepted by their friends, family members and the rest of society. But there is times when people feel that they do not fit or feel welcome in their social group. Many people face their difficulties and achieve success others are do not have such luck. The individuals that are not lucky finishes their life committing suicide. Suicide is an act of taking one’s own life voluntarily and intentionally that affects not only immediate family and friends but indicates factors in society that are influencing individuals to commit this act. Is important to understand what aspects in society are making individuals to take their own live? And if

    Read More

  • Emile Durkheim's Theory Of Suicide Case Study

    1183 Words  | 3 Pages

    Suicide is possibly the most personal action an individual can take upon oneself and yet it has a profound social impact. A large Hungarian population views an act of violence that one commits toward oneself as an act of bravery for freeing themselves and others around them of their misery. It’s also consider to be the least understood crime even though sociologist and psychologist are expected to know the answers to questions such as why people kill themselves but often these questions go unanswered. Emile Durkheim was instrumental in bringing a new understanding of suicide, “when in a sociological study he conceived his theory of suicide, and it 's relationship with society. Perhaps put more accurately, his theory was about society, and

    Read More

  • Jean Paul Sartre Philosophy

    1310 Words  | 3 Pages

    “Life has no meaning a priori. Life itself is nothing until it is lived, it is we who give it meaning, and value is nothing more than the meaning we give it” (Satre 51).

    Read More

  • Suicide Prevention

    1876 Words  | 4 Pages

    Committing suicide probably sounds like a foreign idea to most people, but to the people who think about it, they deal with it every day. More importantly, the question is what leads people to kill themselves? In general, most people do not want to actually kill themselves, even though many people joke about it on a daily basis. Being a human, we all have a certain amount of will to live. Depression is the major cause for suicidal thoughts and ideas. After a long enough period of time, people become worn down and become less and less happy.

    Read More

More about What Is Arthur Schopenhauer's Response To Suicide

Open Document