Sympathy for Derek Bentley in the Film Let Him Have It

1027 Words3 Pages

Sympathy for Derek Bentley in the Film Let Him Have It Peter Medak (Medak) chose to make this film because it had an interesting story line. Medak might have wanted to prove that the justice system makes. Sometimes such mistakes cannot be corrected as in the case of Derek Bentley (Bentley) and Christopher Craig (Craig) where someone was hanged for a misinterpretation of evidence. Film directors like Medak use bias as their strong point; it keeps the viewers' attention on the movie and begins to get the viewers to imagine what they would do in the situation. The film is set in the 1950’s Britain. Bentley and Craig, two teenagers, are on the roof of a factory in south London. Seen by local people, police are called. During the raid Bentley is caught and placed under custody while Craig attempts to fight the police. When Craig is approached by the police and asked to hand the gun over, Bentley purportedly yelled ‘let him have it’. The controversy lies in that Craig misunderstood Bentley and thought he meant that he should pull the trigger. Craig the one who fired the gun was given ten years, as he was only sixteen and underage. Bentley on the other hand was given the death sentence. Evidence was given to show Bentley was retarded and had the mental age of eleven. The story is very controversial, as the justice system had made a mistake. It is argued that the court did not take into account seriously Bentley’s mental age during the sentencing. I don’t think Bentley should have been hanged, as there was sufficient evidence to show that he had a mental age of eleven. Even when Bentley was in custody he did not attempt to escape which proved he had no intention of killing or harming anyone. Craig was more in the blame for killing the officer and should have got death penalty, as he pulled the trigger. Bentley’s life should have been spared as much of the evidence given was biased and did not see Bentley's point of view.

Open Document