I believe that Adnan Syed is innocent. He may have had something to do with the crime or known of it but Adnan was not Hae’s killer. He won’t say if he is guilty or innocent so we will never know but I know he didn’t. My first point will be that the whole day was based on one person. His name was Jay Wilds. Jay Wilds and Adnan Syed were considered “friends”. People described their relationship in many different ways like great friends and will do anything for each other. Others said they only smoked with each other and wouldn’t ever do something like that together. Again we can never know but I am with the side that says they were smoking buddies and Jay turned his back on Adnan. His stories didn’t match up when he was told to tell the police …show more content…
Everyone in the community described Adnan as a super nice, caring, athletic young kid. He loved Hae but would never have it in him to kill someone. Jay meanwhile was known as the bad boy of town or the guy you could go to if you needed something. That already raised suspension to me that he was involved and the people that thought Adnan was good friends with Jay would believe Jay. I do believe that the murder the day happened Jay was with Adnan. He based his story off where they were that day smoking weed or whatever they do and he could make his story of of that. Adnan was very good friends with Jay’s girlfriend. I would get very jealous and many others would if your girlfriend had this guy bestfriend and they were always together. Adnan would always buy presents for Jay’s girlfriend before Jay and just be the better man. My theory is that maybe Jay got so mad that he had to do something to Adnan and that was kill Hae Min Lee and blame it on Adnan a liable suspect. Maybe Jay didn’t know it would go to the extent it did or maybe that’s exactly what he wanted. I don’t and nobody knows what goes through other people’s minds and it could be the worst thoughts in the world. Maybe Jay did it maybe he didn’t but I don’t believe Adnan did
First of all, if something monumental happens a person remembers the day it happened. In contrast, Adnan didn’t remember January 13. Yet, Jay remembers close to everything which points an arrow in his direction. However, Adnan says he didn’t ask Hae for a ride, but witnesses say he did. We can point that at Adnan for lying, but he may have failed
I can see where this could have the family thinking differently now that they know someone was outside that looked suspicious but the blood spatter on David’s clothes does in fact places him at the scene while Molly was being beat to death so I believe he did do the crime or was there watching her get murdered. So no matter what the family says David is right where he needs to be and that is behind bars with the other murderers and violent crime
Adnan's innocence away from him? Jay's story was documented, but his first story kept changing, which seemed off, if he was there shouldn't there be one story and only one story? But his final story, the story that never changes is the one after the mysterious session. Although even that story has flaws. Many to be exact. He says Adan called him after he killed Hae, but we know that they were never friends, only mere acquaintances. Theoretically, would you call an acquaintance after you you killed
Sarah Koenig’s riveting 2014 podcast series Serial investigates the muddled case of Adnan Syed, a teenager who was accused and convicted of murdering his ex-girlfriend, Han Min Lee, fifteen years ago. In order to do so she must speak to those whom were close to Adnan and involved in his day to day life. However, this yields a problem because whoever was close to him wanted to believe he was innocent but their intimacy may have tainted their statements about his character. When Koenig interviews Saad and Rabia, Adnan’s best friend and his older sister, they obviously take the viewpoint that he is innocent; however, through their curious phrasings and tendency to oversell his eminence, their doubt
based on the story of one witness, Adnan’s friend Jay, who testified that he helped
Jay had some big inconsistencies in the stories of what happened that day. (The Alibi) Also just the fact that Adnan agreed to do the whole Serial season with Sarah. An innocent man would not be able to do that without spilling some kind of information. Adnan had more things making him more suspicious of being the murderer. The main thing that points fingers at Adnan is the Nisha call. (“Route Talk”) There was a call from Adnan's phone the day of the murder to Nisha while Adnan said he was at track practice. He told the court Jay had his phone during that time, but Jay and Nisha did not know each other, so why would they talk to each other for two minutes and 22 seconds (Koenig, “The Case Against Adnan Syed”)?
It didn’t seem like what a healthy relationship should look like. First off Adnan had always felt a little guilty for dating her because she wasn’t Muslim like him. It didn’t really look good in their religion when people did things like that. Plus, if his parents found out he would be in A LOT of trouble because he was not supposed to be dating anyone in the first place. But his parents did end up finding out in a pretty bad way, at least that’s what I think. They found out because while Adnan and Hae were at a school dance, one of the parents called his parents and asked about Hae.This then led to Adnan’s parents coming to the school and embarrassing him in front of everybody by yelling at him and dragging him out (Koenig, “The Breakup”). I’m not sure if Adnan was embarrassed, but I know I sure would’ve been. One other example, for this reason, is that Adnan was mad because he thought Hae moved on from him too quickly like she didn’t even give him another chance for anything. Which was true, at least from what I think. Right after Hae had broken up with Adnan, she had started to see this other guy from work, Don (Koenig, “The Breakup”). Adnan didn’t take this very well. According to Reddit, Hae even wrote in her Diary that she felt Adnan was not accepting the breakup well, and that at times she was feeling menaced by his behavior. Plus, he also wrote “I’m going to kill” on a breakup note that he had gotten from
Soul-mate! not cellmate! Karim Lackey, Philadelphia, PA was acquitted last week of fatally shooting Phillip Shirdan, 42, after his lawyer claimed that Lackey had been the victim of "mistaken identity." Two of Lackey's alibi witnesses claimed they were with him watching the "Soul Train Music Awards" on TV at the time Shirdan was killed in a lounge.
The second reason is that Asia McClain can give an alibi for Adnan's after school activities, but she was never used to defend Adnan's innocence. Asia’s timeline of that afternoon was that, “She and Adnan spoke for about 15 to 20 min while she was waiting for her boyfriend to give her a ride around 2:40“, which completely contradicts everything Jay said about how he got a call from Adnan saying he has killed Hae when she supposedly was died by 2:36 pm. She wrote to Adnan right after he was arrested trying to help him in any way, because she honestly thought he was innocent, which can directly be shown from a quote in the letter, “Through your actions that day I have reason to believe your innocence. I went to your family's house and discussed
...ut we know he doesn't have many close relationships. `Dude' is considered very weak in this story, while they are traveling they are targeted, not even because they were driving a stolen vehicle, but because of how they looked and dressed.
Sean McEvoy was discovered in his car in a parking lot at Bear Lake, and the park ranger who discovered him came immediately after he heard the gunshot to find him dead. The investigators came up with the information that Sean had placed the gun inside his mouth and killed himself. Due to the high stress that Sean’s co-workers and therapist had experienced him in due to the current homicide investigation, the case was closed and it was ruled a suicide.
Adana also states he remembered seeing her there too. She then later wrote an affidavit and it stated that they spoke for about 15-20 minutes and then she left around 2:40. The murder ‘happened’ at 2:36 so Adnan couldn’t have been ‘murdering’ Hae at this time if he was at the library. The ones who believe Adnan is guilty will say she undermined her own story but her story has so much details, she couldn’t of had made that up. She also wrote him letters stating what happened that day without anyone knowing so Asia claiming she only did it because the family was ‘forcing’ her to do so is false. The parents didn’t even know she existed until Adnan mentioned the letters. This alibi shows Adnan is not guilty because he was at the library of the time Hae was
Rodney Alcala should have been in prison since his first crime against the eight year old. He should have never been released. There was finally justice after many people he had killed. A killer like Alcala should have been stopped after the
The consequences of Cory Goodine’s choices took an unfortunate turn for the worse in which he had been held accountable for something that he hadn’t done intentionally. All in all, it was unreasonable to even consider charging Goodine with accessory after the fact and/or aiding and abetting due to the circumstances of this homicide. Not only did he have no intention to harm Jason Boyd, but he was also forced to protect himself from Todd Johnston after being consumed by fear after having to witness the murder of Jason
This was something that honestly suited Adnan’s defense more than Jay’s. Remember when I said “He didn’t seem like some sort of assasinator?” Well, he really wasn’t. Why would he kill Hae anyway? Hae and Adnan had dated for about two years, but during the end, it’s like most high school relationships. Someone in the group, or both members, eventually lost interest and break up, which in this case, Hae was the one who broke up. She fell in love with another person, named Don. When they had a break up, Adnan was emotional, and upset. Now, that would make sense, but that was two months before Hae’s death. Why would Adnan kill Hae 2 months after they broke up? I mean, he was described as a player, and sometimes he’d cheat on her. Even after they broke up, many friends his said Adnan eventually got over it.