Why the Dutch Failed to Save Their Jews During World War II

2045 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Effectiveness of Jewish resistance during the Holocaust

Synopsis
A single telegram ended the peace. This small piece of paper meant the death of thousands of people. It was the Nazis declaration of war on the Netherlands. One of the most anti-Semitic regimes in recent history now occupied a country who had housed Jews for the last few centuries. Critics have blamed the large amounts of Jewish deaths on the lack of Dutch resistance to the Nazis. However, it was not the lack of moral responsibility amongst the non-Jews, but the insufficient finances and food supplies that caused the decimation of horrific amounts of Dutch Jews during World War II. The gentiles attempted to save the Jews, but the cost of hiding them was too extreme, leaving no choice other than letting the Jews be deported.

Introduction
The Netherlands is famous for being one of the most resistant countries during World War II. Yad Vashem has honored more “religious gentiles” from the Netherlands than any other country. However, of the approximately 140,000 Jews in the Netherlands, 107,000 were deported. Only 5,000 of those Jews returned, and of the Jews in hiding, only 30,000 survive. This meant that 75% of the Dutch Jewish population was eradicated, the second largest amount after Poland.
Many question why so few Jews survived while so many people tried to save them. My hypothesis is that the limited amount of food and money made hiding the Jews to difficult and expensive for the non-Jews, giving them virtually no choice but to let the Jews be deported.

The Buildup
Initially the Netherlands attempted to stay neutral during World War II, as it had been in the First World War, however, the Nazis still attacked. The final Nazi-free moments for the Dutch were those on May 10, 1940, the day Hitler invaded the Netherlands...

... middle of paper ...

...they managed to save almost all of their Jews. This is a stark contrast to the Netherlands who only managed to save a quarter of its Jewish population, although both had a very strong resistance. I mention this comparison throughout the paper in multiple footnotes.
Woolf, Linda M., Ph.D. "Survival and Resistance: The Netherlands Under Nazi Occupation." Lecture. United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, Washington D.C. 6 Apr. 1999. Webster University. Webster University, 6 Apr. 1999. Web. 31 Oct. 2013. This source is one of the main ones that I used to write this paper. It is full of useful, statistical facts about the Jews in the Netherlands during World War II. It gives many examples of how they were resistant and how they helped the Jews. It is a reliable source since a Ph. D. professor wrote it. I use information from this source frequently throughout the paper.

Show More
Related

  • Use Of Artifice In Empire Of Illusion By Chris Hedges

    629 Words  | 2 Pages

    At a time of loss, the German people needed a reason to rebuild their spirits. The Jews became a national target even though Hitler’s theory could not be proven. Even as a Jew, he accused the Jews people for Germany’s defeat in order to rally the people against a group of people Hitler despised. The story-telling of the Jews’ wickedness distracts the Germans from realizing the terror Holocaust. Millions of Jewish people died because Hitler said they caused the downfall of Germany. Innocent lives were taken. The death of millions mark the rise of Hitler. He sets the stage for the largest massacre in

    Read More

  • The Horrors of Killing Centers During the Holocaust

    813 Words  | 2 Pages

    "World War II in Europe." 10 June 2013. United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. 18 March 2014 .

    Read More

  • How Did Jews Survive During The Holocaust?

    554 Words  | 2 Pages

    Due to this over 60% of the Jewish population was put to torture and death.”Haaretz” During the Holocaust, Jews used armed and unarmed forms of resistance in order to retain their humanity. Unarmed resistance was a way Jewish people fought against the Nazis, not with guns and knives, but simply finding ways to survive their living hell. Unarmed resistance took for in escaping, stealing food, and not following the Nazis demands. Thousands of young Jews resisted by escaping from the ghettos into the forests.some.

    Read More

  • Allied Response to The Holocaust

    1157 Words  | 3 Pages

    The extermination of Jewish people during World War II was a horrific and merciless event that was effectively stopped by the Allies. Once the Allies became aware of the Holocaust, they immediately took action to end it. There have been countless suggestions of what the Allies could have done to prevent the Holocaust, however those would not have been as effective as the solution the Allies had put in place. Despite arguments that the Allies did not make a strong attempt to saving the Jews, by putting all their resources into the complete defeat of Nazi Germany, they were essentially doing all they could.

    Read More

  • The Dutch in World War Two

    576 Words  | 2 Pages

    Throughout World War II thе Nеthеrlands was a placе of opprеssion and starvation as morе than 200,000 Dutch wеrе killеd. Thе Gеrman rulе of Holland bеgan in 1940 and еndеd in 1945. A fеw of thе major еvеnts in this timе pеriod was thе royal Dutch family bеing еxilеd, thе Hungеr Wintеr, thе bombing of Rottеrdam, Opеration Markеt Gardеn, and thе Dutch rеsistancе.

    Read More

  • Westerbork Concentration Camp Research Paper

    699 Words  | 2 Pages

    During WWII the Germans made the brutal environment. Westerbork was located in the Netherlands. Westerbork had weird things like, it had a classroom, a restaurant, a hairdresser, and an orchestra so it wasn't that ruff. Westerbork was 500x500m, and surrounded by barbed-wire, 7 watchtowers, and 24 wooden barracks were constructed. It was always crowded when the Germans brought more Jews. The Jewish Security Service chose their own people

    Read More

  • Corrie Ten Boom Short Story

    709 Words  | 2 Pages

    When war broke out, Holland chose to be neutral like in the past, but when it was bombed by Germany (Corrie Ten Boom Biography), it became part of the allies. Due to the bombing, the royal family fled to different countries. The Queen fled to England; the Crowned Princess fled to Canada. The Queen was a sense of security to the Dutch. Many changes came about (Carlson, 74). The Germans forced Jews to wear yellow stars and enforced the Bicycle Blockade; the Bicycle Blockade resulted in no bicycles or no tires on the bicycle. In addition to that, each attack on a German soldier resulted in shooting a minimum of ten, innocent civilians (Carlson, 75-76).

    Read More

  • Persecution of Jews during World War II

    742 Words  | 2 Pages

    Persecution of Jews increased during World War two as Nazis invaded more countries; which contained thousands of Jews. The increased number of Jews meant that the problem increased greatly. The ways in which the Nazis dealt with the Jews gradually changed throughout the years. First it started by isolating them from society, then exportation out of Europe, then ghettoisatiion;which failed because of the mass number of people. Later on they brought in methods such as the Einsatzgruppen, Concentration and labour camps and gas chambers. In this essay I will write about each of these methods that contributed to the elimination of Jews from 1941 onwards.

    Read More

  • Narrative Essay On Ghetto

    679 Words  | 2 Pages

    When I was about to leave the ghetto, trains had begun to arrive and people had begun to depart. Thousands of people were hoarded onto boxcars, carrying suitcases and dragging their feet. Families were filed out their homes and into the trains to be deported. It seemed that there was a quota to be filled. Though the exact number is not known, the streets were empty the next day. Among the ghetto’s inhabitants, the depor-tations were seen as resettlements, a chance to start a new life far away from the Nazis. Though the validity of this is unknown, many Jewish people inside the ghetto have found hope.

    Read More

  • Denmark During WWII: How the Danish Jews Were Spared from Nazi Invasion

    2738 Words  | 6 Pages

    Yahil, Leni. The rescue of Danish Jewry, test of a democracy.. [1st ed. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1969. Print.

    Read More

  • Anne Frank Biography And The Short Story Line

    807 Words  | 2 Pages

    In their now home in Amsterdam, the Frank Family felt free and safe, until the German Army invaded the Netherlands on May 10, 1940. The Occupation of the Netherlands began on May 15, 1940. The discrimination against the Jews began then as well: Jews couldn't own their own businesses, Jewish children had to go to Jewish schools, all Jews had to wear a yellow star, and countless other restrictions. There were even rumors that the Jews would be packed off to Germany.

    Read More

  • Holocaust Survivors

    1277 Words  | 3 Pages

    When the infamous Hitler began his reign in Germany in 1933, 530,000 Jews were settled in his land. In a matter of years the amount of Jews greatly decreased. After World War II, only 15,000 Jews remained. This small population of Jews was a result of inhumane killings and also the fleeing of Jews to surrounding nations for refuge. After the war, emaciated concentration camp inmates and slave laborers turned up in their previous homes.1 Those who had survived had escaped death from epidemics, starvation, sadistic camp guards, and mass murder plants. Others withstood racial persecution while hiding underground or living illegally under assumed identities and were now free to come forth. Among all the survivors, most wished not to return to Germany because the memories were too strong. Also, some become loyal to the new country they had entered. Others feared the Nazis would rise again to power, or that they would not be treated as an equal in their own land. There were a few, though, who felt a duty to return to their home land, Germany, to find closure and to face the reality of the recent years. 2 They felt they could not run anymore. Those survivors wanted to rejoin their national community, and show others who had persecuted them that they could succeed.

    Read More

  • The Jews In New York

    814 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Jews were able to fit it with the Dutch because of their common skills and merchant based economy. Even though Jews made up only one and a half percent of the Dutch population, four to six percent of the major stockholders for Dutch West India Company and Bank of Exchange were owned by Jews. Jews especially liked the Netherlands because of their focus on the economy rather than religion. The Netherlands were religiously tolerant which greatly impacted the Jews’ desire to be there. The Netherlands were such a good place for the Jews that German Ashkenazis moved there as well. In the Netherlands, a Jewish government was set up, called the Mahamad, which was led by the most important Jews in the community. The Mahamad set up schools, monitored religious observance, supervised social welfare, negotiated with Christian societies, and could excommunicate Jews. Clearly, he Netherlands became an incredibly important place for the Jews, giving them asylum, and ultimately being one of the major forces that helped bring them to New

    Read More

  • Antisemitism In Poland

    683 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Nazis believed that the Dutch and Scandinavians would be sympathetic to their cause. However, it proved quite the opposite. The Germans

    Read More

  • The Holocaust: A Crime Against Humanity

    889 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Holocaust is one of the greatest crimes ever committed against humanity. At first, the Nazi’s put pressure on the Jews by forcing them out of high statuses by boycotting their stores, and eventually by physically persecuting them. However, several Jews did emigrate, more so to North America. After the annexation of Austria and the invasion of Poland in 1939, Nazi control eventually spread to Holland, Norway, northern France, and Czechoslovakia; as the Nazi’s power spread, the more executions occurred. Those Jews, who wanted to flee, found it difficult, because several countries refused to take in massive amounts of Jews, including the United States. The Jews were without defenders, and when World War II was declared, they were trapped. Hitler then began to exterminate all European Jews.

    Read More

More about Why the Dutch Failed to Save Their Jews During World War II

Open Document