Their Eyes Were Watching God Synthesis Essay

993 Words2 Pages

What defines a good writer? In Zora Neale Hurston’s psychological fiction, Their Eyes Were Watching God, the writer tells the story of a woman by the name of Janie and her multiple marriages. Describing her romances and her endless struggle to try and find love. Ms. Hurston describes all of this in a dialect of the African Americans living in the south during the time period in which the story is based. This is an amazing accomplishment for a writer because it is extremely difficult to accurately and consistently portray a certain dialect of a language. Even though this was a great accomplishment, certain flaws were discovered and brought to light. An acclaimed author and literary critic by the name of Richard Wright read and evaluated Ms. …show more content…

Hurston also failed to write a novel that had a unique perspective on African Americans. It seemed to be that the mission of Ms. Hurston was to write a novel that the Black community could relate to at the time and possibly use as a base for social progress. This novel did not seem to be relatable in any sense to the African American community except for one major factor which would be the use of dialect. Her use of the southern dialect was almost perfect, capturing the unique use of language by those in the Deep South. It is used consistently throughout the entirety of the novel including when someone is describing how beautiful Janie is. Phoebe says, “You’se something tuh make uh man forgit to git old and forgit tuh die”(Hurston__). This is how close Hurston gets to having a unique ‘Negro’ novel. Her representation of the dialect is as accurate as it gets and few have come close to matching its level. Although this is a great accomplishment, this is all she has going for her. Her imagery is bland and predictable, and she does not attempt to cover serious issues in the real world at the time the story was written, one important issue being discrimination and racism in the south. Compared to similar novels this is a childish attempt to cover a serious issue. Mr. Wright’s views on this are extremely similar. In his analysis Mr. Wright says, “Her dialogue manages to catch the psychological movements of the Negro folk-mind in their pure simplicity, but that’s as far as it goes”(Wright__). Mr. Wrights analysis proves that the use of dialect in the novel is the closest Hurston gets to covering ‘Negro Issues’. If she attempted to incorporate a social or economic struggle in the novel, then there would be a different

Open Document