The Lottery Book Vs Movie Analysis

506 Words2 Pages

Book vs. Movie The Lottery movie and the book were alike and different in many ways. They both had like the same theme. But they were mostly different. Personally I would prefer the movie over the book… Mostly because the book confused me a lot. In the book and the movie they both have what is called “the lottery”. In both they have the three legged stool and the black box for the lottery. They also have the men in the town each grab a piece of paper from the box, hoping it doesn’t have the black circle on it. Once they find out who got the black circle one, they have the whole family choose out of the box. And in the book and movie its a woman who ends up with it. Eventually all of the citizens of the town have to throw stones at her …show more content…

There was a man in the beginning who’s father dies. His father's last wish was that his ashes be spread across the guy's mother's grave. So throughout the movie he's trying to find out how his mother died and where her grave is. He ends up going to stay at somewhat of a bed and breakfast place. The owners didn't want him to stay since the lottery was coming up but their daughter convinces them to let him. And throughout his journey they get closer together. Well it just so happens the girl's mother was the one chosen to be stoned to death. Once the lady was killed the mayor set the man free. But the cops didn't… So they began chasing him… along with the other men they set off for him. While he's running a car pulls out in front of him and it just so happens to be the girl. She saves him and then takes him to the bus station and lets him go. In the book none of this happened… And I think if they were to add all of this it would be much better. In the book the husband was the one who grabbed the black dot paper. And then his whole family had to choose one. His wife ended up being the one who had to be sacrificed. In the movie the husband was at home because he had a broken leg, so his wife was the one who had to choose for him, and ended up with the black dotted one. So her and her daughter both had to draw to see who would be sacrificed. The mom was the one who ended up having to be stoned. Therefore that was a big

Show More
Related

  • Comparing The Lottery by Shirley Jackson and The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas by Ursula K. Le Guin

    1244 Words  | 3 Pages

    Comparing "The Lottery by Shirley Jackson" and "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas" by Ursula K. Le Guin

    Read More

  • Differences between The Birds the Movie and The Birds short story

    596 Words  | 2 Pages

    Each version also has the main characters boarding up the windows. Anyone who thought the birds won’t attack are usually found dead, but in the movie they are found with their eyes pecked out. Also, both the story and the movie have REALLY bad endings! They aren’t very similar, but they both leave you hanging. When you see a movie or read a book you want to know what happens to the main characters. In these two, you didn’t get an ending. They left you hanging and for some people that ruins it all.

    Read More

  • Like Water For Chocolate - Movie versus Book

    1224 Words  | 3 Pages

    Both book and movie capture good moments and ideas of Esquivel. I would say the book was more entertaining and memorable for me. The novel never rests or drags on, and although it evolves around many tragedies a dying love and lovers, in the end you truly feel happy for the way things turn to be. So does the movie, the end of it is very powerful, I might have not got attached to its characters but I fell in love with the magical fairy tale and romance of Like Water For Chocolate.

    Read More

  • The Lottery Compare And Contrast Essay

    632 Words  | 2 Pages

    Compare and Contrast! Well, you use it on a daily right? The stories “The Lottery” and “The Landlady” are two stories that you can compare and contrast. Some examples of comparisons are that both of the stories use violence, and that they both end with a plot twist no one was expecting. One example of a contrast in both of these stories is that they use their imagery differently. How are these stories alike and how are they different?

    Read More

  • The Lottery Analysis

    751 Words  | 2 Pages

    Did you know that Merle and Patricia Butler from Red Bud, Illinois and three teachers from Baltimore Maryland won the biggest lottery in American history at $656 million dollars? That means every person acquired $218.6 million dollars each from the lottery (Carlyle). Unfortunately, the citizens of Shirley Jacksons’ fantasy short story “The Lottery” were not imbursed with money, but were stoned to death by their peers. “The Lottery” is a lottery of death in which the town uses to keep the population down (Voth). The story consist of many subjects to analyze which include: irony, imagery, and pathos.

    Read More

  • Roll Of Thunder Hear My Cry Research Paper

    882 Words  | 2 Pages

    For example, Mama goes to the bank in the movie and is given a hard time about paying her mortgage, but this did not happen in the book. Another major difference is that the school bus scene, where the Logan kids played a trick on the white kids, was not shown in the movie, even though it was an important part of the story. There are some character changes as well. Lillian Jean, Jeremy, R.W, and Melvin are Simms’ in the book, but in the movie they are Kaleb Wallace’s children. However, the main plot difference is how the movie starts in the middle, summarizing everything from the first part of the book very briefly. Additionally, many scenes are switched around and placed out of order. Altogether, the plot and character changes contribute to my unfavorable impression of the

    Read More

  • Comparing Fahrenheit 451 And The Lottery

    623 Words  | 2 Pages

    War as seen through the eyes of Ambrose Bierce in An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge depicts it as truly gritty. The author successfully sends a message of how death is a part of war, and it is not as noble or glorious as one would think it is. Due to popular media, we have this attitude that the protagonist is going to go down in a blaze of glory, and while it may be true for some, it is not like that for everyone. War is rough, dark, and gritty but no one ever wants to talk about those parts of war because it would ruin the fantasy of it.

    Read More

  • analysis the lottery

    772 Words  | 2 Pages

    Shirley Jackson wrote many books in her life, but she was well known by people for her story “The Lottery” (Hicks). “The Lottery” was published on June 28, 1948, in the New Yorker magazine (Schilb). The story sets in the morning of June 27th in a small town. The townspeople gather in the square to conduct their annual tradition, the Lottery. The winner of the lottery will stoned to death by the society. Although there is no main character in the story, the story develops within other important elements. There are some important elements of the story that develop the theme of the story: narrator and its point of view, symbolism, and main conflict. The story “The Lottery,” by Shirley Jackson, argues practicing a tradition without understanding the meaning of the practice is meaningless and dangerous.

    Read More

  • Literary Elements Of The Lottery

    1312 Words  | 3 Pages

    They both held annual drawings that choose people for a ritual. The districts of The Hunger Games called it a "reaping" which chose two people to fight for their district having a great chance of being killed. "The Lottery" held a "lottery" which first drawn families then draws a person from that family to certainly be killed. First, the fear that was instilled in the people. In The Hunger Games, the people of the districts feared speaking out against President Snow because of the consequences they would face. While in The Lottery, the villagers were also very fearful of being condemned if they were to express opposing views.(Yarmove, 1994) Next is the free will of the two stories. There was no freedom at all in the way of living in The Hunger Games they had no say so in their lives. In The Lottery the villagers were pretty free living except when it came to the lottery itself, there was no way of getting out of that situation. Since the characters in both stories did not have free will, the conformed to the ways of the law. In The Hunger Games, there were strict rules to abide by, it was follow or die. No one would speak out against President Snow because of fear. In The Lottery, all villagers followed the routine of that day the people do not speak out just accept what it to be. Now in both stories, there are people in each story who finally speak out but for different

    Read More

  • Animal Farm Book and Movie

    623 Words  | 2 Pages

    One thing that can make a book good is characters. In the book, there were many more animals in the farm. The movie did not show many animals except for the main animals. Even thought this is a small difference, it can be noticeable. In the book, Mollie was a character.

    Read More

  • Critical Analysis Of The Lottery By Shirley Jackson

    1206 Words  | 3 Pages

    The black on the box itself is a universal symbol that represents death. The black box also represents a platform of life or death for each individual townsperson at the lottery and holds the tragic and evil acts of murder that has been practiced in the past and the future ones. According to James M. Gibson’s, “An Old Testament Analogue for “The Lottery”", the three-legged stool represents the Christian Trinity that consists of God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit. The three-legged stool holds the box that represents death and has the fate of every individual that lives in the town inside of it. According to Kurt J. Fickert’s, “Dürrenmatt’s “The Visit” and Job, The Lottery the Christian Trinity has a significant meaning to the story because they manipulate the religion to support the murdering of an innocent civilian, making it a normality to stone someone to death for religious

    Read More

  • Being There: Comparison of Book and Movie

    1118 Words  | 3 Pages

    From reading the book and watching the movie, I think the book was more insightful, but the movie was more entertaining. The only problem with the movie is that you don't know what is going through Chance's mind and his background information. The movie does help make some things clearer by seeing it, instead of just picturing it in your mind. The added scenes in the movie helps to put some humor into the story and make it more entertaining. By just watching the movie, some people could be confused if they don't know some background on Chance. I think that by reading the book, you can understand the story better and by watching the movie you can enjoy the story better.

    Read More

  • An Analysis of The Lottery, by Shirley Jackson

    390 Words  | 1 Pages

    In "The Lottery," by Shirley Jackson, there are a series of traditions the story revolves around. The characters in the story don't seem to follow their traditions anymore. The story begins by explaining how the lottery works. The lottery takes place in many other towns. In this town it takes place on June 27 of every year. Everyone within town would gather at the town square, no matter what age. The black box is brought out and each head of the household pulls a small paper out of it. Only one of the papers will not be blank, it will have a black-penciled spot that is put on by the owner of the coal company. The black spot will send someone, from the family who chose it, to death. This is decided by a draw. The family member who pulls out the spotted paper will be stoned to death. After a long period of time, people forget the traditions by slowly disregarding as the years pass.

    Read More

  • Analysis of The Lottery by Shirley Jackson

    696 Words  | 2 Pages

    “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson was written in 1948. The story takes place in a village square of a town on June 27th. The author does not use much emotion in the writing to show how the barbaric act that is going on is look at as normal. This story is about a town that has a lottery once a year to choose who should be sacrificed, so that the town will have a plentiful year for growing crops. Jackson has many messages about human nature in this short story. The most important message she conveys is how cruel and violent people can be to one another. Another very significant message she conveys is how custom and tradition can hold great power over people. Jackson also conveys the message of how men treat women as objects.

    Read More

  • Comparing The Lottery And The Story Of An Hour

    554 Words  | 2 Pages

    Death can come in many ways. It can be sudden, or over a strenuous period of time. It can seem random, but sometimes is planned and thought out. There are just about as many ways to deal with death, as there are ways to die. While both The lottery and The Story of an Hour explore the theme of death and grief, The lottery tells a tale of the sacrificial death for a community (necessary, no grief) while The Story of an Hour depicts the natural death of a loved one (grief, but, later, revelation) and how we eventually come to terms with it.

    Read More

More about The Lottery Book Vs Movie Analysis

Open Document