Richard Rorty Inception

1487 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Correspondence theory of truth essay

Rebecca S. Raymond
Professor Valerie Giovanini
Philosophy 170
April 29, 2016
Truth and the Movie, Inception
While watching the movie, Inception, one wonders if the characters see reality as truth and dreaming as some variation of truth, or perhaps another level of truth. The dilemma these characters face is whether they are in reality or in a dream. How do they prove the truth of reality? Thus, Inception can be used as a vehicle to explore the philosophical concept of truth. The objective of this paper is to answer questions relating to truth and Richard Rorty’s criticism of the correspondence theory of truth. In order to accomplish this objective, the paper is organized into four main sections. The first section will answer the question, …show more content…

Rorty criticized this theory of truth as part of his argument to drop the distinction between objective and subjective (Pojman 250). He stated the concept of truth should apply equally to all disciplines, science, considered the objective, as well as humanities and arts, often referred to as subjective. Rorty believed the emphasis of weight placed on truth should not vary between disciplines (Pojman 250). Rorty defended this by claiming that if the distinction between truth as correspondence to reality and truth as well-justified beliefs was eliminated; society would be better off (Pojman 251). He alleged pragmatists do not believe one thing is relative to another, and there should not be any difference between knowledge and opinion. Additionally, Rorty claimed pragmatists do not have a theory of truth (Pojman …show more content…

Truth is not just a conversation, and it certainly is not fuzzy. If we believe Mr. Rorty’s argument that truth is based on what the group believes then the Nazi’s must have been right. Further, Mr. Rorty is mistaken when he aligns himself with pragmatists and says they have no theory of truth. In reality, Mr. Rorty does believe in a concept of truth as Mr. Dennett points out. Mr. Dennett writes that Mr. Rorty agrees with truth having its uses, albeit in a “modest, serviceable way” (Pojman 259). I believe comparing two maps for reliability is using the correspondence theory of truth. So, does this render Mr. Rorty a pragmatist or a

Show More
Related

  • The Reasons Of Descartes: The Dream Argument For Skepticism

    902 Words  | 2 Pages

    Premise 3: So, you cannot know that you are not dreaming right now (from P2).

    Read More

  • The All-Powerful Mind: An Overview of Subjective and Objective Idealism

    1983 Words  | 4 Pages

    This paper will examine the reliability of George Berkeley’s metaphysical theory of Idealism. Berkeley’s Idealism holds that reality is made real by what the mind perceives and that what we perceive to be material is really a collection of immaterial sensations. Idealism is defined as the view “that only mental entities exist, so physical things exist only in the sense that they are perceived” (“Idealism”). Berkeley’s argument of Subjective Idealism is the view that reality consists of one’s mind and its ideas, while Objective Idealism says in addition, a supreme mind produces ideas in the physical world that do not depend on human minds to exist (Velasquez 146). Without Objective Idealism, one can undergo solipsism which is the belief that only one’s self and experiences of the world are real and everything else does not exist (“Solipsism”). Opposing Idealism is the metaphysical view of Materialism which holds that only physical things exist (“Materialism”). This paper will start by examining George Berkeley’s views of Subjective and Objective Idealism and how they apply to reality. Then, the critiques made and supported by Aristotle and Thomas Hobbes against both views of Idealism will be argued. However, these arguments fail to properly examine Berkeley’s Idealism, thus causing the critiques to be based upon misinformation. Although the criticisms pose potential flaws, Berkeley’s Idealism continues to be a major discussion in the metaphysical debate.

    Read More

  • Cartesian and Platonic Philosophical Themes in The Matrix

    2052 Words  | 5 Pages

    This student of Philosophy now sees the movie The Matrix in a whole new way after gaining an understanding of some of the underlying philosophical concepts that the writers of the movie used to develop an intriguing and well thought out plot. Some of the philosophical concepts were clear, while others were only hinted at and most likely overlooked by those unfamiliar with those concepts, as was this student when the movie first came out in theaters all those many years ago. In this part of the essay we will take a look at the obvious and not so obvious concepts of: what exactly is the Matrix and how does it related to both Descartes and Plato, can we trust our own senses once we understand what the Matrix is, and how Neo taking the Red Pill is symbolic of the beginning of the journey out of Pl...

    Read More

  • Certainty is Decartes' Discourse of Method

    947 Words  | 2 Pages

    applies the "Dream Argument, " (32) where he states that based on senses alone, there is

    Read More

  • A Marxist Philosophy of Life - Reading Mao’s Three Essays

    656 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Mao’s essays, the idea of pragmatism is shown mainly by Mao’s emphasis on the importance of practice. The word pragmatism comes from the Greek word pragma, which means "deed, act"; the latter, in turn, derives from the Greek word prassō, which means "to practise, to achieve". Advocates for pragmatism argue that the value of an ideology or proposition lies in the fact whether it works satisfactorily in practice (McDermid). Such principle is evident in most of Mao’s works. For instance, In In Memory Of Norman Bethune, Mao commended the Canadian doctor for “putting this Leninist line into practice” (Mao, In Memory Of Norman Bethune). In Serve the People, Mao stressed again on the significance of practice. He argued that “Anyone … if what he proposes will benefit the people, we will act upon it” (Mao, Serve the People). Here Mao suggests that an idea, as long as it is in line with the Communist Party’s goal of serving the people, should be put into practice, no matter of its origins. This has once again shown the stress Mao had laid on the importance of practice, which is in line with pragmatism principles.

    Read More

  • Biography Of Maurice Richard

    739 Words  | 2 Pages

    Born in August 4, 1921, Maurice Richard was the eldest of eight children of Onesime and Alice Richard. Maurice’s parents moved from Gaspe region to Nouveau-Bordeaux so that his father could work as a machinist at the Canadian Pacific Railway. He started playing hockey when he was a young kid and he was good in boxing as well. In 1937, a young Maurice Richard at age16, was dropped out of school and worked with his father as a machinist and that was his only income other than some income in the winter with the senior Canadiens.

    Read More

  • The Dream Argument by Rene Descartes

    1011 Words  | 3 Pages

    ... middle of paper ... ... When the creator of the argument is not 100 percent behind it, it is very difficult to get behind it yourself. Even with the farfetched ideas, contradictions and inconsistencies of Rene Descartes’s dream argument, it is still a very interesting outlook on the topic that has not been seen from Descartes angle by anyone before.

    Read More

  • Plato's Doctrine of Recollection

    412 Words  | 1 Pages

    The 'doctrine of recollection' states that all true knowledge exists implicitly within us, and can be brought to consciousness - made explicit - by recollection. Using the Platonic concepts of 'Forms', 'particulars', 'knowledge' and 'true opinion', this essay explains what can or cannot be recollected, why all knowledge is based on recollection, and why the doctrine does not prove the soul to be immortal.

    Read More

  • Metaphysics Of Consciousness

    3101 Words  | 7 Pages

    In this term paper, I have tried to tackle the metaphysical issues of consciousness by first defining consciousness and doing a thorough study about the term. Then I proceeded to the metaphysical aspects of consciousness, examining and understanding them.

    Read More

  • Descartes Knowledge

    1087 Words  | 3 Pages

    our existence in reality is a question which philosophers have tackled throughout time. This essay will look at the

    Read More

  • Philosophy: Plato’s Theaetetus

    1005 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...ue belief have no distinction within the ‘awake state’ of mind, which I proved to be uncertain (Pearl, p. 110). By pointing out the skeptics view on the question, “How can you determine whether at this moment we are sleeping and all our thoughts are a dream; or whether we are awake and talking to one another in the waking state”, inquired by Socrates to Theaetetus in Plato’s Theaetetus, Pearl gained insight into the opposing position, which in turn gave him more information when refuting the skeptics argument. Plato’s Theaetetus have sparked many exuberant discussions over decades on simple topics many people would not think to bring to light, giving philosphers more insight into _______.

    Read More

  • Nietzsche

    1664 Words  | 4 Pages

    ... something when it fact, we never ask ourselves why we know it. We tend to take for granted what counts the most in this world, that is, knowing ourselves. Human beings think that knowledge of things will lead them to enlightenment. But in reality, it is nothing but an illusion made by man himself to create a kind of path towards success. Those who follow this path will get nowhere close to success, rather, they bring upon suffering along the way, pulling us farther from ourselves. Thus, if only we were aware of this deceptive nature of language and metaphor to that of knowledge, we would come to understand that truth indeed is nothing but a man-made word and is therefore a mere figment of our imagination. The facts do not count, only our interpretations of them. So it seems that Reality then isn’t so far from our dreams, perhaps it’s really the other way around.

    Read More

  • The Ethics of Ambiguity

    1534 Words  | 4 Pages

    Wittgenstein, Ludwig; G. E. M. Anscombe, P.M.S. Hacker and Joachim Schulte (eds. and trans.). Philosophical Investigations. 4th edition, Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 2009. Print.

    Read More

  • Descartes Skepticism

    1205 Words  | 3 Pages

    The most important of these is the agency, or control, of the subject over its own mind. While it may be evident that, of course, one has control over what one thinks about, in reality, there are many cases in which thoughts arise unbidden, or a memory suddenly appears, fresh as day. A good example of this may, in fact, be dreaming. Dreaming is a case in which our psychic apparatus controls the dream, and yet, what we perceive as ‘ourselves’ in the dream does not actually have agency over the content or progression of the dream itself, nor privileged information about what events will emerge. If, according to Descartes’ method, we are to get rid of any faculty that has been shown to be not totally reliable, then we are to get rid of the faculty of agency, which of course would undermine the method of doubt, that assumes the faculty of agency precisely in order to doubt. This is one reason to render doubtful the validity of Descartes’ method, however, it is not enough to salvage external world

    Read More

  • The Philosophy Behind Inception Analysis

    1421 Words  | 3 Pages

    He argued the fact that because we are not able to know that the world around us is our reality, we can not gain knowledge and the word itself will become meaningless. After years of research, Rene concluded that “it’s impossible in a dream for it to occur to you that you might be dreaming. What that means is that in order to consider the possibility that you might be dreaming, you need to be awake. This distinguishes dreams from reality, and provides a basis for holding that you aren’t currently dreaming.”(1) While the director is inspired by the ideas of Descartes, he rejects his argument. As it can be seen in the movie, when Cobb is dreaming, he is aware of the possibility that he might be in a dream. Additionally, Inception can be compared to the “Allegory of the Cave” by Plato. The film resembles Plato's allegory, where the dream acts like the cave where people are free to believe in their own reality. As you go into deeper layers of the dream, the more convinced you will become about that the events which are happening in the dream is your true reality. In the Allegory of the Cave, the man that was set free can be compared to Cobb in Inception. In the movie Cobb still accepted the true reality which was blasted right at him the moment he woke up from his dream. The other prisoners can be associated to Mal, who was convinced that their

    Read More

More about Richard Rorty Inception

Open Document