Pros And Cons Of Light Rail In Arizona

2679 Words6 Pages

Introduction:
There are many ways people in Arizona get from place to place, especially using public transportation. One specific use is the light rail that serves in Arizona that combines certain cities including Mesa, Tempe, and Phoenix. Looking at history that has taken place we look at how we have grown and how far we have come to help better advance the light rail. We look at how great it is to include the light rail into cities and how impactful it has been in other cities such as Boston, Massachusetts and Portland, Oregon (Figure 1). I found that businesses did improve their profit and really benefitted from the light rail, along with the increasing positive environmental impacts. Although we only look at the positive impacts, negative …show more content…

Starting with money, we find that the construction for the light rail for these 3 cities came out to be 1.4 billion dollars. “The federal government paid for nearly half, and Phoenix, Tempe and Mesa kicked in a combined 40 percent. The Proposition 400 transportation tax covered the rest,”(Creno). Where now, “The projections call for Phoenix to pay $75.35 million toward the operating budget and for Tempe to pay $32.08 million. Mesa is down for $6.50 million. Other Valley cities pay token amounts.”(Creno). Which is putting us in a worse situation. Disruption takes place as a bigger issue because this involved a lot of businesses that suffered because the building of the light rail ran in the way of their business. Businesses near the light rail have been effected by this says, “Jacob Johnson owner of Watson Flowers in Tempe, said the construction hurt his business severely, and he does not believe it has had a positive impact on sales since completion.” (Quizon). Along with businesses disruption there is also traffic congestions, “a 50-year-old Scottsdale resident who works in downtown Phoenix, said the trains doing test runs have been causing traffic problems, nobody knows where they're going.”(Creno). It was also stated from “Sal Navarro, 27, of Avondale, said only people who work downtown will have any use for light rail.”(Creno). Looking at the location that was picked helps explain why …show more content…

Neelesh Nidadhavolu. “The Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority”. http://mobile.usablenet.com/mt/net4.ccs.neu.edu/home/neelesh/Project/documentation.html
9. The Brooklyn Daily Eagle, vol.53, NO.149, pg.10. “Trains Running this Morning”. May 30, 1893
10. Light Rail Now. “New subway (metro) systems cost nearly 9 times as much as light rail.” February. 13, 2014. https://lightrailnow.wordpress.com/2014/02/13/new-subway-metro-systems-cost-nearly-9-times-as-much-as-light-rail/
11. Thompson, Jonathan. High Country News. “Light rail enters the West’s most sprawling metropolis”. Nov. 14, 2104.
12. Creno, Glen. The Arizona Republic. “Valley residents remain split over cost, effects of light rail.” Nov. 26, 2008
13. Creno, Glen. The Arizona Republic. “Coping with light-rail costs”. Dec. 9, 2008
14. Quizon, Derek. The Arizona Republic. “Effects of light-rail on businesses mixed, owners say.” Jul. 13, 2010
15. Jesse Victor and Diane E. Brown. Arizona PIRG Education Fund. “The Businesses of Light Rail: A Compilation of Local Business Interviews”. < http://www.arizonapirg.org/sites/pirg/files/reports/The-Businesses-of-Light-Rail.pdf>. April

Open Document