Literary Analysis Of The American Can-Do-Spirit

971 Words2 Pages

The American ‘can-do-spirit’ is a well-known term, and many texts, poems, books and movies revolve around this outstanding ‘can-do-spirit’, which appears to be significant for the average American’s self-image. Two poems focused on this spirit are Dedication for a Plot of Ground by William Carlos Williams and Nobody Loses All the Time by E. E. Cummings, both by American writers, written 16 years apart. Even though both poems contemplate the American ‘can-do-spirit’, they seem to have two different ideas regarding what this so called spirit is all about. One praises it, and one mugs it. Dedication for a Plot of Ground by William Carlos Williams was written in 1938. The poem is about a woman called Emily Dickinson Wellcome (perhaps Williams’ …show more content…

E. Cummings was written 16 years later in 1954. The poem has many parallels to Dedication for a Plot of Ground but still differs in, for example, the tone of the poem. The poem is about a man called Uncle Sol. Just like Emily, Uncle Sol’s life has been full of misfortunes. Uncle Soll starts a farm, but it is ruined by chickens, “so my Uncle Sol had a chicken farm”, hereafter skunks eat the chickens and Uncle Sol decides to kill himself by drowning himself in a water-tank “and down went my Uncle Sol and started a worm farm”. In the beginning Uncle Sol is resourceful. When the chickens cause his vegetable farm to fail, he just opens a chicken farm. This is a good example of the American ‘can-do-spirit’. Nothing is so bad that it can’t be turned into something good, and that is exactly what Uncle Sol does. Unfortunately Uncle Sol loses this ‘can-do-spirit’ when the chicken farm fails, and commits suicide. In that way he differs from Emily, who is more persistent, and therefore represents the American ‘can-do-spirit’ better. Another way Emily and Uncle Soll differs, is that Uncle Soll was a liked person. At his funeral “we all cried like the Missouri”, and that won’t be the case when Emily dies. The style of Nobody Loses All the Time is much like the style of Dedication for a Plot of Ground, the sentences are abrupt and the poem is condensed. The poems’ tones differ, and that causes the view of the American ‘can-do-spirit’ to differ as well. Nobody Loses All the Time is written in a sarcastic tone, which for example can be seen, when Uncle Soll’s suicide is

Open Document